{"name":"Carl Jara","slug":"carl-jara","role":"Sand sculptor · Artist","headline":"Built to disappear. Made to matter.","introduction":"Carl Jara makes art that cannot last forever. The Cleveland sand sculptor joins Keith and Jon to talk about finding his craft, the value of a firsthand experience, and what decades of practice teach your hands.","biography":"Carl Jara is a professional sand sculptor from the Cleveland, Ohio area. His official biography describes more than three decades working and competing internationally. He studied illustration and graphic design at the Myers School of Art in Akron; a fifteen-foot sand sculpture for his BFA exhibition helped launch his professional career.","biographyContext":"In this conversation, Carl traces his start to carving sand in a neighbour’s driveway at eighteen. He explains why temporary work can be worthwhile, how sculpture lets him express personal experiences, and why mastery includes teaching others and finishing the work within the time available.","portrait":{"url":"https://mornings.network/guest-packages/carl-jara/carl-jara-portrait.jpg","width":960,"height":685,"alt":"Carl Jara beside one of his sand sculptures, wearing a medal","caption":"Carl Jara with his work. Photograph from his official biography, used with guest permission.","sourceUrl":"https://www.artcleveland.com/bio"},"questions":[{"id":"why-make-temporary-art","question":"Why make art that will disappear?","answer":"Carl welcomes making something that does not add another permanent object to the world. He compares encountering a sculpture with attending a symphony or a football game: being there, sharing the moment, is an experience a photograph cannot fully reproduce.","sourceLabel":"10:01–10:45","passageIndex":46,"evidenceSeconds":[601.09,603.322,613.365,626.103,633.794,644.351],"url":"https://mornings.network/shows/center-stage/guests/carl-jara#why-make-temporary-art","sourceUrl":"https://mornings.network/shows/center-stage/guests/carl-jara#passage-46"},{"id":"what-mastery-means","question":"What does mastery mean in sand sculpture?","answer":"Carl describes master-level competition as an invitation-based category. For him, the practical skills include rendering an idea, teaching someone else, and completing a finished sculpture within the allotted time.","sourceLabel":"14:46–15:14","passageIndex":69,"evidenceSeconds":[886.758,894.242,908.537],"url":"https://mornings.network/shows/center-stage/guests/carl-jara#what-mastery-means","sourceUrl":"https://mornings.network/shows/center-stage/guests/carl-jara#passage-69"},{"id":"what-judges-notice","question":"What does a sculpture judge notice that a visitor might miss?","answer":"Carl says the answer depends on who is judging. A fellow sand sculptor may look for mastery of the material and a seemingly impossible technical achievement. A visitor may respond first to whether the piece resonates personally.","sourceLabel":"17:31–18:18","passageIndex":83,"evidenceSeconds":[1051.325,1063.335,1082.637,1095.711],"url":"https://mornings.network/shows/center-stage/guests/carl-jara#what-judges-notice","sourceUrl":"https://mornings.network/shows/center-stage/guests/carl-jara#passage-83"}],"canonicalUrl":"https://mornings.network/shows/center-stage/guests/carl-jara","airDate":"2026-11-06","dateLabel":"November 6, 2026","uploadDate":"2026-11-06T16:14:33Z","episode":3173,"episodeUrl":"https://mornings.network/shows/mornings-in-the-lab/magazine/3173","videoId":"U74tof1fdp4","duration":"PT20M55S","durationLabel":"20:55","cover":"https://mornings.network/guest-packages/carl-jara/appearance-cover.png","coverWidth":1672,"coverHeight":941,"coverAlt":"Built to Disappear — illustrative artwork for Carl Jara’s Center Stage appearance","coverCaption":"Illustrative appearance artwork from the episode magazine.","credits":[{"name":"Carl Jara","role":"Guest","source":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U74tof1fdp4"},{"name":"Keith Bilous","role":"Host","source":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U74tof1fdp4"},{"name":"Jon Andersen","role":"Host","source":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U74tof1fdp4"},{"name":"Sophia Grant","role":"Presenter","source":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U74tof1fdp4"}],"links":[{"label":"Carl’s official website","url":"https://www.artcleveland.com/"}],"mediaNote":"The full appearance includes Sophia Grant’s produced introduction and question, plus the original live connection difficulties and shared-video interruption. Highlights use the recorded conversation. Portrait cuts arrange all three participant panels for 9:16 without stretching faces. Automatic captions may contain errors; original camera quality limits detail within the panels.","transcriptNote":"Automatic transcript from the recorded appearance. The source has no reliable dialogue speaker labels. The produced introduction is identified from the production record and video; dialogue turns remain unverified. Guest-name spellings are corrected against the appearance record, and overlapping dialogue may contain errors.","moments":[{"id":"art-that-washes-away","title":"The experience is the point.","label":"Art that washes away","description":"A sculpture can disappear and still be worth making. Carl compares seeing his work firsthand with sharing a live concert or a game.","start":590.558,"end":646.057,"time":"09:50","duration":"56 sec","poster":"/guest-packages/carl-jara/art-that-washes-away-landscape.jpg","portraitPoster":"/guest-packages/carl-jara/art-that-washes-away-portrait.jpg","posterAlt":"Art that washes away — Carl Jara in conversation with Keith Bilous and Jon Andersen","portraitPosterAlt":"Art that washes away — portrait composition of the three recorded participant panels","posterCaption":"Frame from the recorded conversation","defaultFormat":"horizontal","assets":[{"url":"https://pub-176ab0b7668b46259a6c72d4ad146d40.r2.dev/guest-packages/carl-jara/2026-11-06/art-that-washes-away-landscape-1080p.mp4","filename":"art-that-washes-away-landscape-1080p.mp4","width":1920,"height":1080,"bytes":30995003,"kind":"video","orientation":"horizontal","status":"ready","captions":"/guest-packages/carl-jara/art-that-washes-away.vtt"},{"url":"https://pub-176ab0b7668b46259a6c72d4ad146d40.r2.dev/guest-packages/carl-jara/2026-11-06/art-that-washes-away-portrait-1080p.mp4","filename":"art-that-washes-away-portrait-1080p.mp4","width":1080,"height":1920,"bytes":15655417,"kind":"video","orientation":"vertical","status":"ready","captions":"/guest-packages/carl-jara/art-that-washes-away.vtt"},{"url":"/guest-packages/carl-jara/art-that-washes-away-landscape.jpg","filename":"art-that-washes-away-landscape.jpg","width":1920,"height":1080,"bytes":255917,"kind":"artwork","orientation":"horizontal","status":"ready"},{"url":"/guest-packages/carl-jara/art-that-washes-away-portrait.jpg","filename":"art-that-washes-away-portrait.jpg","width":1080,"height":1920,"bytes":215808,"kind":"artwork","orientation":"vertical","status":"ready"}]},{"id":"what-judges-see","title":"What does a sculpture judge see?","label":"What judges see","description":"Carl distinguishes technical mastery from personal resonance—and explains why the person judging changes what gets noticed.","start":1055.011,"end":1098.197,"time":"17:35","duration":"43 sec","poster":"/guest-packages/carl-jara/what-judges-see-landscape.jpg","portraitPoster":"/guest-packages/carl-jara/what-judges-see-portrait.jpg","posterAlt":"What judges see — Carl Jara in conversation with Keith Bilous and Jon Andersen","portraitPosterAlt":"What judges see — portrait composition of the three recorded participant panels","posterCaption":"Frame from the recorded conversation","defaultFormat":"vertical","assets":[{"url":"https://pub-176ab0b7668b46259a6c72d4ad146d40.r2.dev/guest-packages/carl-jara/2026-11-06/what-judges-see-landscape-1080p.mp4","filename":"what-judges-see-landscape-1080p.mp4","width":1920,"height":1080,"bytes":21769257,"kind":"video","orientation":"horizontal","status":"ready","captions":"/guest-packages/carl-jara/what-judges-see.vtt"},{"url":"https://pub-176ab0b7668b46259a6c72d4ad146d40.r2.dev/guest-packages/carl-jara/2026-11-06/what-judges-see-portrait-1080p.mp4","filename":"what-judges-see-portrait-1080p.mp4","width":1080,"height":1920,"bytes":13704990,"kind":"video","orientation":"vertical","status":"ready","captions":"/guest-packages/carl-jara/what-judges-see.vtt"},{"url":"/guest-packages/carl-jara/what-judges-see-landscape.jpg","filename":"what-judges-see-landscape.jpg","width":1920,"height":1080,"bytes":267657,"kind":"artwork","orientation":"horizontal","status":"ready"},{"url":"/guest-packages/carl-jara/what-judges-see-portrait.jpg","filename":"what-judges-see-portrait.jpg","width":1080,"height":1920,"bytes":225125,"kind":"artwork","orientation":"vertical","status":"ready"}]}],"quotes":[],"chapters":[{"title":"Meeting Carl and finding his craft","seconds":251,"time":"04:11"},{"title":"A live detour: the high-wire video","seconds":495,"time":"08:15"},{"title":"Why temporary art matters","seconds":590.558,"time":"09:50"},{"title":"Practice, mastery and making a living","seconds":746,"time":"12:26"},{"title":"Personal stories hidden in sculpture","seconds":968,"time":"16:08"},{"title":"What a sculpture judge sees","seconds":1036.249,"time":"17:16"}],"fullVideoDownload":{"url":"https://pub-176ab0b7668b46259a6c72d4ad146d40.r2.dev/guest-packages/carl-jara/2026-11-06/carl-jara-appearance-master-1080p.mp4","filename":"carl-jara-appearance-master-1080p.mp4","width":1920,"height":1080,"bytes":2242349668,"kind":"video","orientation":"horizontal","status":"ready","sizeBytes":2242349668,"downloadUrl":"https://pub-176ab0b7668b46259a6c72d4ad146d40.r2.dev/guest-packages/carl-jara/2026-11-06/carl-jara-appearance-master-1080p.mp4?download=1"},"sharingVideoDownload":{"url":"https://pub-176ab0b7668b46259a6c72d4ad146d40.r2.dev/guest-packages/carl-jara/2026-11-06/carl-jara-appearance-sharing-1080p.mp4","filename":"carl-jara-appearance-sharing-1080p.mp4","width":1920,"height":1080,"bytes":545212766,"kind":"video","orientation":"horizontal","status":"ready","sizeBytes":545212766,"downloadUrl":"https://pub-176ab0b7668b46259a6c72d4ad146d40.r2.dev/guest-packages/carl-jara/2026-11-06/carl-jara-appearance-sharing-1080p.mp4?download=1"},"transcript":"[00:00] Sophia Grant · produced introduction: You can love what you do and still have one part of it that drives you absolutely mad. Carl knows that feeling. He spent more than three decades sculpting sand, and he says he hates the stuff.\n\n[00:12] Sophia Grant · produced introduction: He studied illustration and graphic design, but a 15-foot sand sculpture at his college exhibition helped launch a very different career. That career took him around the world, earning around 100 medals, all from a material that refuses to last forever.\n\n[00:26] Sophia Grant · produced introduction: Ask what he does for people, and Carl's answer is wonderfully simple, \"I create wonder. Just look at what sand can become.\" So what keeps someone coming back to a material he hates? I can't wait to hear his answer.\n\n[00:39] Sophia Grant · produced introduction: An artist who turns ordinary sand into something extraordinary. Carl, welcome to Mornings in the Lab.\n\n[00:48] Speaker unverified: Johnny, I'm looking for the world's interesting people to join us on the show for interesting conversations, and I found a dude that hates sand, yet he became one of the world's greatest sand sculptures. Jimmy, let's bring him up. Carl Jara.\n\n[01:01] Speaker unverified: Carl, how are you? Can you hear us? No, I can't hear you Oh, Cal, Cal. Now I can. Cal. He responded, there we go. Cal, how are you? Cal's got, got something. How you guys doing this morning?\n\n[01:13] Speaker unverified: Good. How are you doing this mor- first of all, where are you joining us from? What time zone are you in? How are you guys this morning? Everything good? We're awesome. How are you? Can you hear me? Yes. Can you hear me? Can you hear me?\n\n[01:27] Speaker unverified: I can hear you now. There we go. Can, can, this is like the classic trope of internet communication here. Yes. Yeah. So Carl, Carl, where are you joining us from? Hmm Oh, so Johnny, maybe you're leading into it.\n\n[01:39] Speaker unverified: You can't hear me. Johnny, go after him. Oh, you can hear me, brother, but you can't hear Keith? Is that it? Yeah, apparently I can't hear Keith. Well, you, yeah, but let, but let me tell you, brother, it's a fucking blessing. You're much happier this way, I promise you. You know, if I could find- Judging by the eight minutes I've seen so far\n\n[01:54] Speaker unverified: a way to fucking push a button and I didn't hear him too, I would've done it a long fucking time ago. You guys are something else anymore, I gotta tell you. Well, I guess, it sounds like you do something with sand sculpturing, but I, I\n\n[02:07] Speaker unverified: kinda wanna keep talking about scrotums. What do you think? As you know, uh, I, I can honestly tell you that, uh, working in sand, uh, I've discovered new parts of my body I didn't know I had.\n\n[02:19] Speaker unverified: Oh. I was gonna say, yeah- … your, your scrotum's gotta be taking a beating there. You know, my, my big pit bull, he's, he's fu- he's gonna be 11 this month. Oh, geez, he's gonna be 11 in, like, four or five days.\n\n[02:32] Speaker unverified: This fucking guy, you know, that shit looks like a fucking avocado that's been- … sitting on a counter for, like, nine months. You ever seen one of those? No- … avocados don't last in my house.\n\n[02:46] Speaker unverified: They disappear fast. I don't touch them, but… Well, I try no- to touch them too, but you, Jesus Christ. So tell me about your sculpturing, brother. Oh, man. Uh, you know, for 35 years I've been going around the world\n\n[03:00] Speaker unverified: making sculptures for people. Um, I, I just, you know, there's something beautiful about, about going out and m- doing something that makes people happy. Yeah. You know? Fuck yes.\n\n[03:13] Speaker unverified: I, I feel like there's so many jobs that you can have that you're just like, \"Why the hell do you do this,\" right? Yeah. There's no high five moment. There's no fulfillment. It's soul-sucking fucking daily rigor. Yep. And I'll say, you know, there are days when I go to work and I'm like,\n\n[03:27] Speaker unverified: \"Oh, my God, why am I doing this?\" And then, and then the people come, and they see what I'm doing, and they talk to me, and they express their amazement. And, and I know that my work isn't, you know, gonna go sit in a museum somewhere\n\n[03:40] Speaker unverified: and be viewed by millions of art critics and whatever, and I don't care about that. Those aren't the people I'm worried about. It's the people who just walk up and experience my stuff, and they know that it's, they're not gonna experience it next week 'cause it ain't gonna be there.\n\n[03:55] Speaker unverified: Yeah, I was gonna say, it's, it's all i- the, the nature has control of how long it stays, yeah? Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm, very much. Well, I mean, we did some, I did some work with the Travel Channel for four years. We actually blew 'em up with T- uh, with, uh, TNT, which is pretty damn cool.\n\n[04:09] Speaker unverified: No shit. Yeah. That's cool. Yeah, we So what got you into this? What was it, what was the catalyst? Um- And he hates sand, Johnny … there was this weird old guy- No shit … living down the street from me, uh, had a pile of sand in his driveway.\n\n[04:22] Speaker unverified: My mother told me to stay the hell away from him. Um, and you know- Well, then you gotta go play in the sand- … we were 18, you don't- … I mean, and fuck your, your mother could've said, \"Please go fuck with his sand,\" and you'd said, \"Mom, there's something about that guy. I don't know what yet.\"\n\n[04:35] Speaker unverified: Right. Exactly. But she told me to stay away from him, and, uh- I, and I went and I hung out with him, and I carved some sand in his driveway. And, uh, this dude was walking his dog, asked me to come back and, and write a story.\n\n[04:47] Speaker unverified: And I'm like, \"Yeah, whatever, dude. I don't care.\" And he turns out he's a journalist for the newspaper, and next thing we know, we got jobs at the art fairs. Uh, we're going to Jamaica. I'm being shipped off to China, Singapore, Australia. How old are you at this point?\n\n[04:59] Speaker unverified: Uh, I was 18 when I started. And you're fucking traveling the world at 18 because of this? Yep, yep, yep. I was a- Jesus Christ, brother … global traveler immediately. In fact, I, I travel out to Florida in two days Well, goddamn brother,\n\n[05:14] Speaker unverified: I mean, getting on- That's- I mean, literally- That's pretty cool think about how many 18-year-olds on this fucking planet who are just fucking lost. Yep, they're doing this. You know? Yeah. Fucking, I mean they, they are, they're, they're happier to distract themselves\n\n[05:30] Speaker unverified: from what, you know, from discovering what their purpose is than they are to- Right … y- you literally, well I guess thank, fuck, you, you, do you often thank your mom for telling you not to go fuck with that guy Sand? Well, she's gone now, so I can't really say much to her.\n\n[05:44] Speaker unverified: Oh, she hears you. I think, I think she ended up changing her mind afterwards. Yeah, I was gonna say, she's, she's probably looking going, \"Jesus Christ.\" Well you know, she probably knows she played reverse psychology on you. You know? Maybe, maybe. So why do you dislike sand?\n\n[05:58] Speaker unverified: Uh, have you, have you ever had- … sand in your pants, in your car, under your nails? Well, I guess I was gonna say, just- Or watching- … there's some, there's some reason we were talking about scrotums before you got here. I think we're winding back to that, aren't we? Yeah, it, it kinda comes back around.\n\n[06:10] Speaker unverified: One of my favorite phrases is, \"I found sand in places I didn't know I had places.\" Brother, when, when, uh, when I was competing as pro strongman, you know, we often would compete on like, you know, tropical environments- Yep … and we would, we would, a lot of it was in on the beach.\n\n[06:25] Speaker unverified: And one of, one of the things I, of course I, I totally agree with what you're saying, but one of the things that I remember was fucking brutal was there's, uh, I can't remember the island we were on, but goddamn, every time we went there, there was these fucking sand fleas.\n\n[06:38] Speaker unverified: Oh, yes. Jesus Christ. I mean, these motherfuckers, it was, it, and the weirdest- Yep … part was this, right? So people from all over the fucking world. Something about the Icelander, the Icelandic team- They eat them alive\n\n[06:52] Speaker unverified: … Jesus, I swear to Christ, it's like the different fucking smell or something. Yeah. I mean, they got the, let's just say that on a scale of one to 10, and it was usually from the knees down. You got all these little fucking bumps. Yeah, yeah, because they're always down here.\n\n[07:05] Speaker unverified: It was just, dude, your lower leg looked like something was wrong with it, you know? Mm-hmm. I mean, it, it was bad enough where they actually had fucking, you know, that medical people staying on top of the fact that it wasn't getting too bad. But these Icelanders, dude, it, they were getting it t- easily\n\n[07:18] Speaker unverified: twice as bad as everybody else. Oh, yeah. I think it's that, that fucking pure blood that they have, you know? Well, it's like I look at my kiddo and she gets eaten up by mosquitoes and I don't. No shit. I don't know what the difference is. So do the fleas fuck with you on the sand?\n\n[07:32] Speaker unverified: Uh, I, it's, well, it's between the sand fleas and the no-see-ums, which are these little teeny tiny black flies. Like, little tiny suckers. And you're just sitting there working and all of a sudden it's like, \"What the hell is going on, man?\"\n\n[07:45] Speaker unverified: You know the, the, the mental illness where you feel like you got bugs crawling over you? I'm sorry, but that shit's real in my world. Oh, that would… And once it starts, you can't get it to stop, especially when it's real. Exactly.\n\n[07:57] Speaker unverified: Yeah, and there's nothing worse than mixing bug spray and sunscreen. Oh, Jesus. I, you know, I don't know what kind of toxic concoction that produces, but- Yeah, no shit. Jon, I'm- I, I- Jon, I'm gonna jo- Jon, I'm gonna mute you\n\n[08:09] Speaker unverified: I was gonna say, Keith, but I think, I think you can hear Keith now, correct, brother? No. Not, no, man No. I don't know what's up there. You're gonna, yeah, I'm gonna jump in. Johnny, but so, hey Johnny, hey Carl, check this out. I'm nervous. Jimmy, are you, Carl, are you afraid of heights? No, I'm not. We gotta check- Johnny, Johnny, I know you're not, I know you…\n\n[08:22] Speaker unverified: So check this out. Well, look at, look at- well, not AI. Could you imagine this, Anderson? This is a tight walk between- That's not AI. You said that's- … an island and a- That's, hold on. You said that's not AI?\n\n[08:35] Speaker unverified: That's not AI. Fuck. This guy walking here- That's a- … is not AI? Ah, screw that. That, that, that's … So what he's basically, what he's saying is the, this guy is doing this for real. This is not AI. Yeah. That's crazy, man. That's fucking- That's absolutely crazy.\n\n[08:47] Speaker unverified: Look, look. Did you … There was that one angle where you could see, like, his, whatever the fuck he's wi- his rope or his wire. Yeah. Wasn't, like this, like the … You could see it wasn't totally straight, 'cause the wind was, like, blowing it into a fuck\n\n[09:00] Speaker unverified: So you can kinda see it's not- Whoa. See there, the, the bend in it? Yeah, yeah. That's fucking nuts, dude. That- How far across was that? Uh, I'm gonna grab this for us here. That was, uh, where was that? That was in between, uh … Uh, I don't have it to where it was.\n\n[09:14] Speaker unverified: That's insane. That is insane. Keith, Keith is getting some statistics on how far that was- Yeah just so you know, Carl. Uh, that was … Hey, Johnny, ask, uh, ask him what's- Yeah, that guy apparently has balls. So John, there's a question- His balls. … we wanna ask him. Like, what, what's it like, Johnny, what's it like building a sandcastle\n\n[09:28] Speaker unverified: when they just, they always dissolve? Like, he puts all this time into something, and then it- Yeah washes away. So Keith, the qu- the, the question that Keith is asking, which for, just so you know, I, I won't have to filter this one. This is- … actually a decent question.\n\n[09:42] Speaker unverified: So, so basically what he's saying is, you know, when you put all this time and energy … Well, I'm gonna sweeten it up, 'cause it was a little boring, I'll give you. Not a decent question.\n\n[09:50] Speaker unverified: But, but when you put all this time and energy into building a castle- Yeah … and you know it's gonna get washed away, is- Yeah … is I … How do you feel about that? Is that something that you kinda think is cool, or it's like, \"Goddammit\"?\n\n[10:01] Speaker unverified: Well, well so, so I got two, two philosophies on that.\n\n[10:03] Speaker unverified: Number one, the world is full of enough shit already, you know? I don't need to produce more shit that lasts forever in this world. It's kinda nice to make something that goes away.\n\n[10:13] Speaker unverified: Um, the other thing is, um- You know, when you go to a symphony or you go to a football game, you know, and you're there and you're experiencing everything that is that moment.\n\n[10:26] Speaker unverified: The other people, you know, your shared heartbeat, you're all cheering at the same time, you're all crying at the same time, however that works.\n\n[10:33] Speaker unverified: You don't get that same experience from a reproduction, from a photograph or from, from… And so I do, I do work that you have to- Original … experience firsthand, and that's it.\n\n[10:44] Speaker unverified: It's gone after that. And, and you get… It's, it's, dude, it's very interesting, is you, you're creating an original and you got, what? What, what's the, the longest time that you'd have for that fucker gets washed away?\n\n[10:55] Speaker unverified: It's a k- So- Handful of hours … oh, man. I mean, you know, it depends. I do a series of projects here in Cleveland in summer, and they're meant to last all summer, and they do. Uh, part of that is the kind of sand- Oh … I use. Part of it is my technique that I w- I work with.\n\n[11:08] Speaker unverified: Uh, I understand how to keep something from falling apart in the winter, or in the weather, excuse me. Winter, I can't do anything about. Freezes, it's gone. Um- Is all this stuff on the beach or do you do s- Oh, no like sculptures like in- I started working indoors … fucking sandbox and shit.\n\n[11:21] Speaker unverified: I, I come from- Anywhere … I come from Cleveland. You know, we got- Anywhere … six months of the year- Okay … it's under snow, so Yeah, there's no- I learned how to appreciate- … fucking beach, no fucking beach anywhere near. Well, you'd be s- you actually got Lake Erie about six miles north of me.\n\n[11:33] Speaker unverified: Sand isn't any good. The weather isn't any good. Um, but I do a series of pieces on the beach, which is, you know, challenging. Yeah. Well, I, I agree with you. There, there's a f- there's such a difference between a beach on a\n\n[11:45] Speaker unverified: lake versus a beach at the ocean. 100%. There is. There is. Wow. Uh, I gotta say though, when you're standing on Lake Erie shore and, and, and Canada's some 60 miles north of you over the horizon, and it looks\n\n[11:58] Speaker unverified: exactly like the Gulf of Mexico, it, it, you don't think of nothing else. Dude, I'm, I'm literally, if I went out that fucking door, I'm looking at the Gulf of Mexico right now. Nice. Yeah. No, I, I know what you mean. I'll probably be looking at that on Sunday.\n\n[12:11] Speaker unverified: It's fu- it's, it is fucking kinda crazy when you look out and you know that there's something else over there, you know? Right, right. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I, it's, it makes you realize how big the damn world really is.\n\n[12:24] Speaker unverified: Yeah. Yeah, yeah. So when you're, basically when you're making one of these sculptures, and t- talk to me about, uh, like you said you're going to do, you're leaving here to go, I think you said Florida, right? Yep. So some fucking guy calls you and says, \"Hey, I want a sculpture.\"\n\n[12:40] Speaker unverified: I mean, that's pretty much how it works. Um, uh, you know, I have enough of a reputation now after 35 years that, uh, I get invited to a lot of different, a lot of different events. Um, I, I used to be a very, uh, productive competitive sculptor, and I'm\n\n[12:55] Speaker unverified: actually going for the, uh, the Crystal Classic in Siesta Key, uh, next week. Uh, and that is a master level competition. Um, I'm going for my 101st medal. Let's do it. No shit.\n\n[13:08] Speaker unverified: Yeah. Wow. So w- w- but you've been doing it since you were 18, so let's- Yes … how many fucking years have you been doing this? I mean, this is 35 years now. Yeah, I was gonna say, because, you know- Next year's three decades, man.\n\n[13:20] Speaker unverified: Wow. Here- here's a, and clearly a passion, right? So think of this, how many fucking people do we know that have done anything other than fucking go to their soul suck- soul sucking job for more than 30 years?\n\n[13:34] Speaker unverified: Fucking very few, bro. That's right. That's right. So when you find somebody like yourself, or even myself, I'm trying to think really hard about how we can include Keith in this, but I can't do it. But him, it's actually technology, 'cause this little fucker's been burying his\n\n[13:49] Speaker unverified: face in technology before it even existed. But, uh, anyway, it's, it's kind of crazy when you see how good somebody gets at something when they do it for a length of time. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, I think that's- So you're that, you are that guy in the sculpture world.\n\n[14:04] Speaker unverified: It's that mastery. It's that, you know, it's that- Yeah … muscle memory. It's that being able to just, um, you know, I don't have to look at a picture to carve a human being. I, you know, I get it. I understand it. I feel it. I've done it enough times that I- You know, I know how the human body works\n\n[14:18] Speaker unverified: and I can replicate that in sand. You know- Jon- That, that's actually really interesting. You said, Keith, you know, we- Yeah … the word mastery, right? Yeah, yeah, yeah. Because we really don't… People think mastery is, \"Oh, I've been doing this for fucking six or eight…\"\n\n[14:31] Speaker unverified: No, six or eight years, 10 years, that's great. You got a good fucking down payment. You know? That's not mas- no. Yeah. That's what I mean, mastery is like- Yeah … fucking, I, what, what, what would you categorize mastery? I'm gonna have to say three… Once you cross the three decade mark- Oh … you've entered the territory.\n\n[14:46] Speaker unverified: 100%. I mean- What do you think, Carl? You know, uh, in, in the sand sculpting world, um, you're, you're\n\n[14:54] Speaker unverified: considered a master when you've been invited to compete in a master level contest, but I think that some of it has to do with your ability- Mm to render something, your ability to teach somebody else, and your ability\n\n[15:08] Speaker unverified: to fulfill your duty to make a complete, finished sculpture within a time allotted- Mm-hmm … and make it look good. Johnny, what kind of money can they make in that industry as, as a politician? I don't know. I don't have any other definition for you. Yeah, is it, is it…\n\n[15:21] Speaker unverified: I mean, when you're, when you hit that level, is, I mean, do people make fucking good money? Do they make, do they make a living from it? Um, well let's just put it this way. I put a new roof and a new chimney on my house, and it cost me a half a year's, uh,\n\n[15:34] Speaker unverified: wages at the job I'm sitting at right now. It cost me a month wages in sand, so there you go. Oh, fuck. Good for you, brother. Wow. Yeah. And that's the way it should be. Realistically- It should be … when someone becomes fucking great- Yeah … they should fucking be paid, and unfortunately there are plenty of things\n\n[15:50] Speaker unverified: that do- it doesn't work out that way. So what's the, what's the like- I, I wanna say interesting, like crazy, freakiest. I'm gonna take all these words, wrap them together.\n\n[16:03] Speaker unverified: Let's make a word for that, whatever that is. Talk about that sculpture. What is it? What was it? Uh, all right. So in 2008, I, uh, went to my 13th, uh, world championships.\n\n[16:15] Speaker unverified: Um, and I actually took first place Sculptor's Choice and, and, and, uh, People's Choice- Wow with, uh, a piece called What Lies, Beneath. Uh, that's What Lies, comma, Beneath.\n\n[16:28] Speaker unverified: So it, it, it's a play on words, but it was, uh, it was a very intimate look into stuff I don't wanna tell people about. One of the beauties of what I get to do is I can describe my world and my life\n\n[16:42] Speaker unverified: experience, and I can disguise it in a way that you don't know it's about me. Oh. So it's almost like a, it's almost like a fucking songwriter writing a song about- Yeah … about an experience in life. Oh, well said, Johnny. Well said. Yeah. Well, that's fucking nuts, dude.\n\n[16:55] Speaker unverified: Well, yeah. And Jo- and this is sand we're making this. You're telling a story- Yeah … out of fucking sand. Right. God damn. Right, and no, no critics are gonna go back afterwards and analyze what the hell I was talking about, 'cause the pieces are gone.\n\n[17:07] Speaker unverified: John, we got a question from Petro in the comm- in the comments here. Does Car- Got a question coming from Oh, hold on. Hold on. Come here. Sure. What is it? Hold on. Here it comes. Here it comes, from Sophia.\n\n[17:16] Speaker unverified: You have competed at the master level since 1997. What can a judge see in 10 seconds that a tourist usually misses? Oh, good one.\n\n[17:28] Speaker unverified: Damn, you know, that's a really good question.\n\n[17:31] Speaker unverified: Um, and I'm gonna take that on two parts. Number one, you have judges. Who are your judges? Are they other sand sculptors, or are they just some random dude from the beach, right?\n\n[17:43] Speaker unverified: Because the sand sculptor's gonna look for a couple different things. They're gonna look for, A, your level of mastery. Have you taken this material and done something seemingly impossible with it? Wow. Have you moved this material in a way that makes people go, \"What the hell?\"\n\n[17:59] Speaker unverified: That to me, that's what they're looking for. Wow.\n\n[18:02] Speaker unverified: The common guy is looking for, \"Hey, does that resonate with something inside my skull?\" Not to put common people down, but people who don't do this don't understand it- To the intimate level that we do.\n\n[18:15] Speaker unverified: So judging comes with a grain of salt. Oh, so Jon, there, there's a grain of salt in the question from Petro. So he says, Petro says, Jon, does Carl- Yeah, the question's coming. Hold on. Yeah, so Jon, you'll have to read it. Does Carl have a solution to the Sorites heap of sand paradox?\n\n[18:33] Speaker unverified: Do you know what that is, uh- I can't fucking say all that. Jesus Christ. We, we, we have a… He says- And I sure as hell can't fucking read it. We have a, we have a heap of sand if removing a grain is- So green is the sorites- Sorites.\n\n[18:46] Speaker unverified: Oh, he can read it. Good. Carl- Yeah … you can see, can you see it? Read that fucker, please. So the, so- Jesus Christ … okay, does Carl, I think you're, uh, uh, I'm not sure what this means. Does Carl have a solution to the Sorites heap of sand paradox? What is that?\n\n[18:59] Speaker unverified: Can somebody- Jimmy, ru- run the next comment. There's a next comment for you, Carl. There, there you go … heap of sand, and removing one grain of sand from a heap changes it in a non-heap. Then repeating this process forces the absurd conclusion, a single grain of sand. Oh. Jon, tell Pe- Jon, tell, tell, tell- It's like-\n\n[19:13] Speaker unverified: tell what Petro is- The guy, the guy who's throwing these fucking stumper questions at you, he's a fucking professor from Wake Forest. I like this. I like this. And he, and he literally, what he does is he studies his, his whole life's\n\n[19:25] Speaker unverified: work is basically uncovering bullshit. He's not saying you're full of shit, but he's crazy with- he makes all these fucking crazy cl- he just, he sees things differently. So he asks questions that gets people thinking. And fuck- No, actually- Petro, I don't even know what the\n\n[19:39] Speaker unverified: fuck you're talking about. That, that, that does make me think. Uh- But it also makes me think of the paradox of, you know, if you fix your car, if you replace enough pieces on your car, when does it stop being your car, right?\n\n[19:52] Speaker unverified: Oh, fuck. And when does it become a conglomeration of pieces that are not your car? And the same thing is true with sand. I've taken away enough sand, and when does the sculpture happen? That's one of those questions that can never be answered.\n\n[20:06] Speaker unverified: That's fascinating. That's fascinating. Johnny, we're gonna wrap up with Carl here. If, if, if, if we got Petro joining us here, so let's thank Carl for hanging out with us. So Carl, this is… We're just what basically Keith is saying, we've gotta move on to our next segment.\n\n[20:18] Speaker unverified: But we both- Yeah … wanna fucking thank you. It's a real fucking pleasure. And- Thank you, guys. Thank you guys for having me on, man more, and more importantly- You guys are the man, bro. I love it … thank you for, for taking the whole scrotum thing with a, with a grain of sand.\n\n[20:30] Speaker unverified: Not a problem. It was a good intro. Maybe we'll do it another time. Right on, brother. Hey, Carl, it was a pleasure, brother. Keep fucking doing what you're doing. I love to hear about people like yourself who have taken- Right on something that's a passion and done amazing things with it.\n\n[20:43] Speaker unverified: Keep that shit going. You're leading by example. The world needs you. Carl, thanks for hanging out with us, Carl. Thank you, gentlemen. Have a lovely day. All right. Carl Jara here. Fuck, I love him. Anderson, that was awesome, man. That was fucking awesome.","transcriptTextUrl":"/guest-packages/carl-jara/appearance-transcript.txt","transcriptSrtUrl":"/guest-packages/carl-jara/appearance-transcript.srt","transcriptOrigin":"Descript automatic captions","transcriptStatus":"Automatic transcript from the recorded appearance. The source has no reliable dialogue speaker labels. The produced introduction is identified from the production record and video; dialogue turns remain unverified. Guest-name spellings are corrected against the appearance record, and overlapping dialogue may contain errors.","transcriptPassages":[{"seconds":0,"time":"00:00","speaker":"Sophia Grant · produced introduction","text":"You can love what you do and still have one part of it that drives you absolutely mad. Carl knows that feeling. He spent more than three decades sculpting sand, and he says he hates the stuff.","reviewNote":"Presenter identified from the production assembly record and matching video introduction. The transcript is automatic."},{"seconds":12.112,"time":"00:12","speaker":"Sophia Grant · produced introduction","text":"He studied illustration and graphic design, but a 15-foot sand sculpture at his college exhibition helped launch a very different career. That career took him around the world, earning around 100 medals, all from a material that refuses to last forever.","reviewNote":"Presenter identified from the production assembly record and matching video introduction. The transcript is automatic."},{"seconds":26.701,"time":"00:26","speaker":"Sophia Grant · produced introduction","text":"Ask what he does for people, and Carl's answer is wonderfully simple, \"I create wonder. Just look at what sand can become.\" So what keeps someone coming back to a material he hates? I can't wait to hear his answer.","reviewNote":"Presenter identified from the production assembly record and matching video introduction. The transcript is automatic."},{"seconds":39.643,"time":"00:39","speaker":"Sophia Grant · produced introduction","text":"An artist who turns ordinary sand into something extraordinary. Carl, welcome to Mornings in the Lab.","reviewNote":"Presenter identified from the production assembly record and matching video introduction. The transcript is automatic."},{"seconds":48.931,"time":"00:48","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Johnny, I'm looking for the world's interesting people to join us on the show for interesting conversations, and I found a dude that hates sand, yet he became one of the world's greatest sand sculptures. Jimmy, let's bring him up. Carl Jara.","reviewNote":"Guest name spelling corrected against the appearance record; speaker attribution remains unverified."},{"seconds":61.469,"time":"01:01","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Carl, how are you? Can you hear us? No, I can't hear you Oh, Cal, Cal. Now I can. Cal. He responded, there we go. Cal, how are you? Cal's got, got something. How you guys doing this morning?","reviewNote":"Guest name spelling corrected against the appearance record; speaker attribution remains unverified."},{"seconds":73.831,"time":"01:13","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Good. How are you doing this mor- first of all, where are you joining us from? What time zone are you in? How are you guys this morning? Everything good? We're awesome. How are you? Can you hear me? Yes. Can you hear me? Can you hear me?"},{"seconds":87.085,"time":"01:27","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"I can hear you now. There we go. Can, can, this is like the classic trope of internet communication here. Yes. Yeah. So Carl, Carl, where are you joining us from? Hmm Oh, so Johnny, maybe you're leading into it."},{"seconds":99.922,"time":"01:39","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"You can't hear me. Johnny, go after him. Oh, you can hear me, brother, but you can't hear Keith? Is that it? Yeah, apparently I can't hear Keith. Well, you, yeah, but let, but let me tell you, brother, it's a fucking blessing. You're much happier this way, I promise you. You know, if I could find- Judging by the eight minutes I've seen so far"},{"seconds":114.73,"time":"01:54","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"a way to fucking push a button and I didn't hear him too, I would've done it a long fucking time ago. You guys are something else anymore, I gotta tell you. Well, I guess, it sounds like you do something with sand sculpturing, but I, I"},{"seconds":127.192,"time":"02:07","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"kinda wanna keep talking about scrotums. What do you think? As you know, uh, I, I can honestly tell you that, uh, working in sand, uh, I've discovered new parts of my body I didn't know I had."},{"seconds":139.95,"time":"02:19","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Oh. I was gonna say, yeah- … your, your scrotum's gotta be taking a beating there. You know, my, my big pit bull, he's, he's fu- he's gonna be 11 this month. Oh, geez, he's gonna be 11 in, like, four or five days."},{"seconds":152.468,"time":"02:32","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"This fucking guy, you know, that shit looks like a fucking avocado that's been- … sitting on a counter for, like, nine months. You ever seen one of those? No- … avocados don't last in my house."},{"seconds":166.302,"time":"02:46","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"They disappear fast. I don't touch them, but… Well, I try no- to touch them too, but you, Jesus Christ. So tell me about your sculpturing, brother. Oh, man. Uh, you know, for 35 years I've been going around the world"},{"seconds":180.787,"time":"03:00","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"making sculptures for people. Um, I, I just, you know, there's something beautiful about, about going out and m- doing something that makes people happy. Yeah. You know? Fuck yes."},{"seconds":193.794,"time":"03:13","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"I, I feel like there's so many jobs that you can have that you're just like, \"Why the hell do you do this,\" right? Yeah. There's no high five moment. There's no fulfillment. It's soul-sucking fucking daily rigor. Yep. And I'll say, you know, there are days when I go to work and I'm like,"},{"seconds":207.951,"time":"03:27","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"\"Oh, my God, why am I doing this?\" And then, and then the people come, and they see what I'm doing, and they talk to me, and they express their amazement. And, and I know that my work isn't, you know, gonna go sit in a museum somewhere"},{"seconds":220.947,"time":"03:40","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"and be viewed by millions of art critics and whatever, and I don't care about that. Those aren't the people I'm worried about. It's the people who just walk up and experience my stuff, and they know that it's, they're not gonna experience it next week 'cause it ain't gonna be there."},{"seconds":235.315,"time":"03:55","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Yeah, I was gonna say, it's, it's all i- the, the nature has control of how long it stays, yeah? Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm, very much. Well, I mean, we did some, I did some work with the Travel Channel for four years. We actually blew 'em up with T- uh, with, uh, TNT, which is pretty damn cool."},{"seconds":249.92,"time":"04:09","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"No shit. Yeah. That's cool. Yeah, we So what got you into this? What was it, what was the catalyst? Um- And he hates sand, Johnny … there was this weird old guy- No shit … living down the street from me, uh, had a pile of sand in his driveway."},{"seconds":262.2,"time":"04:22","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"My mother told me to stay the hell away from him. Um, and you know- Well, then you gotta go play in the sand- … we were 18, you don't- … I mean, and fuck your, your mother could've said, \"Please go fuck with his sand,\" and you'd said, \"Mom, there's something about that guy. I don't know what yet.\""},{"seconds":275.057,"time":"04:35","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Right. Exactly. But she told me to stay away from him, and, uh- I, and I went and I hung out with him, and I carved some sand in his driveway. And, uh, this dude was walking his dog, asked me to come back and, and write a story."},{"seconds":287.264,"time":"04:47","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"And I'm like, \"Yeah, whatever, dude. I don't care.\" And he turns out he's a journalist for the newspaper, and next thing we know, we got jobs at the art fairs. Uh, we're going to Jamaica. I'm being shipped off to China, Singapore, Australia. How old are you at this point?"},{"seconds":299.998,"time":"04:59","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Uh, I was 18 when I started. And you're fucking traveling the world at 18 because of this? Yep, yep, yep. I was a- Jesus Christ, brother … global traveler immediately. In fact, I, I travel out to Florida in two days Well, goddamn brother,"},{"seconds":314.839,"time":"05:14","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"I mean, getting on- That's- I mean, literally- That's pretty cool think about how many 18-year-olds on this fucking planet who are just fucking lost. Yep, they're doing this. You know? Yeah. Fucking, I mean they, they are, they're, they're happier to distract themselves"},{"seconds":330.43,"time":"05:30","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"from what, you know, from discovering what their purpose is than they are to- Right … y- you literally, well I guess thank, fuck, you, you, do you often thank your mom for telling you not to go fuck with that guy Sand? Well, she's gone now, so I can't really say much to her."},{"seconds":344.723,"time":"05:44","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Oh, she hears you. I think, I think she ended up changing her mind afterwards. Yeah, I was gonna say, she's, she's probably looking going, \"Jesus Christ.\" Well you know, she probably knows she played reverse psychology on you. You know? Maybe, maybe. So why do you dislike sand?"},{"seconds":358.741,"time":"05:58","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Uh, have you, have you ever had- … sand in your pants, in your car, under your nails? Well, I guess I was gonna say, just- Or watching- … there's some, there's some reason we were talking about scrotums before you got here. I think we're winding back to that, aren't we? Yeah, it, it kinda comes back around."},{"seconds":370.79,"time":"06:10","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"One of my favorite phrases is, \"I found sand in places I didn't know I had places.\" Brother, when, when, uh, when I was competing as pro strongman, you know, we often would compete on like, you know, tropical environments- Yep … and we would, we would, a lot of it was in on the beach."},{"seconds":385.018,"time":"06:25","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"And one of, one of the things I, of course I, I totally agree with what you're saying, but one of the things that I remember was fucking brutal was there's, uh, I can't remember the island we were on, but goddamn, every time we went there, there was these fucking sand fleas."},{"seconds":398.889,"time":"06:38","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Oh, yes. Jesus Christ. I mean, these motherfuckers, it was, it, and the weirdest- Yep … part was this, right? So people from all over the fucking world. Something about the Icelander, the Icelandic team- They eat them alive"},{"seconds":412.954,"time":"06:52","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"… Jesus, I swear to Christ, it's like the different fucking smell or something. Yeah. I mean, they got the, let's just say that on a scale of one to 10, and it was usually from the knees down. You got all these little fucking bumps. Yeah, yeah, because they're always down here."},{"seconds":425.524,"time":"07:05","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"It was just, dude, your lower leg looked like something was wrong with it, you know? Mm-hmm. I mean, it, it was bad enough where they actually had fucking, you know, that medical people staying on top of the fact that it wasn't getting too bad. But these Icelanders, dude, it, they were getting it t- easily"},{"seconds":438.546,"time":"07:18","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"twice as bad as everybody else. Oh, yeah. I think it's that, that fucking pure blood that they have, you know? Well, it's like I look at my kiddo and she gets eaten up by mosquitoes and I don't. No shit. I don't know what the difference is. So do the fleas fuck with you on the sand?"},{"seconds":452.102,"time":"07:32","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Uh, I, it's, well, it's between the sand fleas and the no-see-ums, which are these little teeny tiny black flies. Like, little tiny suckers. And you're just sitting there working and all of a sudden it's like, \"What the hell is going on, man?\""},{"seconds":465.049,"time":"07:45","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"You know the, the, the mental illness where you feel like you got bugs crawling over you? I'm sorry, but that shit's real in my world. Oh, that would… And once it starts, you can't get it to stop, especially when it's real. Exactly."},{"seconds":477.424,"time":"07:57","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Yeah, and there's nothing worse than mixing bug spray and sunscreen. Oh, Jesus. I, you know, I don't know what kind of toxic concoction that produces, but- Yeah, no shit. Jon, I'm- I, I- Jon, I'm gonna jo- Jon, I'm gonna mute you"},{"seconds":489.62,"time":"08:09","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"I was gonna say, Keith, but I think, I think you can hear Keith now, correct, brother? No. Not, no, man No. I don't know what's up there. You're gonna, yeah, I'm gonna jump in. Johnny, but so, hey Johnny, hey Carl, check this out. I'm nervous. Jimmy, are you, Carl, are you afraid of heights? No, I'm not. We gotta check- Johnny, Johnny, I know you're not, I know you…","reviewNote":"The original live conversation pauses here for a shared high-wire video and reactions."},{"seconds":502.731,"time":"08:22","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"So check this out. Well, look at, look at- well, not AI. Could you imagine this, Anderson? This is a tight walk between- That's not AI. You said that's- … an island and a- That's, hold on. You said that's not AI?","reviewNote":"The original live conversation pauses here for a shared high-wire video and reactions."},{"seconds":515.628,"time":"08:35","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"That's not AI. Fuck. This guy walking here- That's a- … is not AI? Ah, screw that. That, that, that's … So what he's basically, what he's saying is the, this guy is doing this for real. This is not AI. Yeah. That's crazy, man. That's fucking- That's absolutely crazy.","reviewNote":"The original live conversation pauses here for a shared high-wire video and reactions."},{"seconds":527.747,"time":"08:47","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Look, look. Did you … There was that one angle where you could see, like, his, whatever the fuck he's wi- his rope or his wire. Yeah. Wasn't, like this, like the … You could see it wasn't totally straight, 'cause the wind was, like, blowing it into a fuck","reviewNote":"The original live conversation pauses here for a shared high-wire video and reactions."},{"seconds":540.148,"time":"09:00","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"So you can kinda see it's not- Whoa. See there, the, the bend in it? Yeah, yeah. That's fucking nuts, dude. That- How far across was that? Uh, I'm gonna grab this for us here. That was, uh, where was that? That was in between, uh … Uh, I don't have it to where it was.","reviewNote":"The original live conversation pauses here for a shared high-wire video and reactions."},{"seconds":554.496,"time":"09:14","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"That's insane. That is insane. Keith, Keith is getting some statistics on how far that was- Yeah just so you know, Carl. Uh, that was … Hey, Johnny, ask, uh, ask him what's- Yeah, that guy apparently has balls. So John, there's a question- His balls. … we wanna ask him. Like, what, what's it like, Johnny, what's it like building a sandcastle","reviewNote":"The original live conversation pauses here for a shared high-wire video and reactions."},{"seconds":568.156,"time":"09:28","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"when they just, they always dissolve? Like, he puts all this time into something, and then it- Yeah washes away. So Keith, the qu- the, the question that Keith is asking, which for, just so you know, I, I won't have to filter this one. This is- … actually a decent question."},{"seconds":582.09,"time":"09:42","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"So, so basically what he's saying is, you know, when you put all this time and energy … Well, I'm gonna sweeten it up, 'cause it was a little boring, I'll give you. Not a decent question."},{"seconds":590.558,"time":"09:50","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"But, but when you put all this time and energy into building a castle- Yeah … and you know it's gonna get washed away, is- Yeah … is I … How do you feel about that? Is that something that you kinda think is cool, or it's like, \"Goddammit\"?"},{"seconds":601.09,"time":"10:01","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Well, well so, so I got two, two philosophies on that."},{"seconds":603.322,"time":"10:03","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Number one, the world is full of enough shit already, you know? I don't need to produce more shit that lasts forever in this world. It's kinda nice to make something that goes away."},{"seconds":613.365,"time":"10:13","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Um, the other thing is, um- You know, when you go to a symphony or you go to a football game, you know, and you're there and you're experiencing everything that is that moment."},{"seconds":626.103,"time":"10:26","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"The other people, you know, your shared heartbeat, you're all cheering at the same time, you're all crying at the same time, however that works."},{"seconds":633.794,"time":"10:33","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"You don't get that same experience from a reproduction, from a photograph or from, from… And so I do, I do work that you have to- Original … experience firsthand, and that's it."},{"seconds":644.351,"time":"10:44","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"It's gone after that. And, and you get… It's, it's, dude, it's very interesting, is you, you're creating an original and you got, what? What, what's the, the longest time that you'd have for that fucker gets washed away?"},{"seconds":655.147,"time":"10:55","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"It's a k- So- Handful of hours … oh, man. I mean, you know, it depends. I do a series of projects here in Cleveland in summer, and they're meant to last all summer, and they do. Uh, part of that is the kind of sand- Oh … I use. Part of it is my technique that I w- I work with."},{"seconds":668.343,"time":"11:08","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Uh, I understand how to keep something from falling apart in the winter, or in the weather, excuse me. Winter, I can't do anything about. Freezes, it's gone. Um- Is all this stuff on the beach or do you do s- Oh, no like sculptures like in- I started working indoors … fucking sandbox and shit."},{"seconds":681.002,"time":"11:21","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"I, I come from- Anywhere … I come from Cleveland. You know, we got- Anywhere … six months of the year- Okay … it's under snow, so Yeah, there's no- I learned how to appreciate- … fucking beach, no fucking beach anywhere near. Well, you'd be s- you actually got Lake Erie about six miles north of me."},{"seconds":693.318,"time":"11:33","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Sand isn't any good. The weather isn't any good. Um, but I do a series of pieces on the beach, which is, you know, challenging. Yeah. Well, I, I agree with you. There, there's a f- there's such a difference between a beach on a"},{"seconds":705.419,"time":"11:45","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"lake versus a beach at the ocean. 100%. There is. There is. Wow. Uh, I gotta say though, when you're standing on Lake Erie shore and, and, and Canada's some 60 miles north of you over the horizon, and it looks"},{"seconds":718.658,"time":"11:58","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"exactly like the Gulf of Mexico, it, it, you don't think of nothing else. Dude, I'm, I'm literally, if I went out that fucking door, I'm looking at the Gulf of Mexico right now. Nice. Yeah. No, I, I know what you mean. I'll probably be looking at that on Sunday."},{"seconds":731.342,"time":"12:11","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"It's fu- it's, it is fucking kinda crazy when you look out and you know that there's something else over there, you know? Right, right. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I, it's, it makes you realize how big the damn world really is."},{"seconds":744.328,"time":"12:24","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Yeah. Yeah, yeah. So when you're, basically when you're making one of these sculptures, and t- talk to me about, uh, like you said you're going to do, you're leaving here to go, I think you said Florida, right? Yep. So some fucking guy calls you and says, \"Hey, I want a sculpture.\""},{"seconds":760.989,"time":"12:40","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"I mean, that's pretty much how it works. Um, uh, you know, I have enough of a reputation now after 35 years that, uh, I get invited to a lot of different, a lot of different events. Um, I, I used to be a very, uh, productive competitive sculptor, and I'm"},{"seconds":775.661,"time":"12:55","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"actually going for the, uh, the Crystal Classic in Siesta Key, uh, next week. Uh, and that is a master level competition. Um, I'm going for my 101st medal. Let's do it. No shit."},{"seconds":788.322,"time":"13:08","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Yeah. Wow. So w- w- but you've been doing it since you were 18, so let's- Yes … how many fucking years have you been doing this? I mean, this is 35 years now. Yeah, I was gonna say, because, you know- Next year's three decades, man."},{"seconds":800.91,"time":"13:20","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Wow. Here- here's a, and clearly a passion, right? So think of this, how many fucking people do we know that have done anything other than fucking go to their soul suck- soul sucking job for more than 30 years?"},{"seconds":814.005,"time":"13:34","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Fucking very few, bro. That's right. That's right. So when you find somebody like yourself, or even myself, I'm trying to think really hard about how we can include Keith in this, but I can't do it. But him, it's actually technology, 'cause this little fucker's been burying his"},{"seconds":829.092,"time":"13:49","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"face in technology before it even existed. But, uh, anyway, it's, it's kind of crazy when you see how good somebody gets at something when they do it for a length of time. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, I think that's- So you're that, you are that guy in the sculpture world."},{"seconds":844.24,"time":"14:04","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"It's that mastery. It's that, you know, it's that- Yeah … muscle memory. It's that being able to just, um, you know, I don't have to look at a picture to carve a human being. I, you know, I get it. I understand it. I feel it. I've done it enough times that I- You know, I know how the human body works"},{"seconds":858.71,"time":"14:18","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"and I can replicate that in sand. You know- Jon- That, that's actually really interesting. You said, Keith, you know, we- Yeah … the word mastery, right? Yeah, yeah, yeah. Because we really don't… People think mastery is, \"Oh, I've been doing this for fucking six or eight…\""},{"seconds":871.693,"time":"14:31","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"No, six or eight years, 10 years, that's great. You got a good fucking down payment. You know? That's not mas- no. Yeah. That's what I mean, mastery is like- Yeah … fucking, I, what, what, what would you categorize mastery? I'm gonna have to say three… Once you cross the three decade mark- Oh … you've entered the territory."},{"seconds":886.758,"time":"14:46","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"100%. I mean- What do you think, Carl? You know, uh, in, in the sand sculpting world, um, you're, you're"},{"seconds":894.242,"time":"14:54","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"considered a master when you've been invited to compete in a master level contest, but I think that some of it has to do with your ability- Mm to render something, your ability to teach somebody else, and your ability"},{"seconds":908.537,"time":"15:08","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"to fulfill your duty to make a complete, finished sculpture within a time allotted- Mm-hmm … and make it look good. Johnny, what kind of money can they make in that industry as, as a politician? I don't know. I don't have any other definition for you. Yeah, is it, is it…"},{"seconds":921.043,"time":"15:21","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"I mean, when you're, when you hit that level, is, I mean, do people make fucking good money? Do they make, do they make a living from it? Um, well let's just put it this way. I put a new roof and a new chimney on my house, and it cost me a half a year's, uh,"},{"seconds":934.41,"time":"15:34","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"wages at the job I'm sitting at right now. It cost me a month wages in sand, so there you go. Oh, fuck. Good for you, brother. Wow. Yeah. And that's the way it should be. Realistically- It should be … when someone becomes fucking great- Yeah … they should fucking be paid, and unfortunately there are plenty of things"},{"seconds":950.079,"time":"15:50","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"that do- it doesn't work out that way. So what's the, what's the like- I, I wanna say interesting, like crazy, freakiest. I'm gonna take all these words, wrap them together."},{"seconds":963.465,"time":"16:03","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Let's make a word for that, whatever that is. Talk about that sculpture. What is it? What was it? Uh, all right. So in 2008, I, uh, went to my 13th, uh, world championships."},{"seconds":975.947,"time":"16:15","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Um, and I actually took first place Sculptor's Choice and, and, and, uh, People's Choice- Wow with, uh, a piece called What Lies, Beneath. Uh, that's What Lies, comma, Beneath."},{"seconds":988.106,"time":"16:28","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"So it, it, it's a play on words, but it was, uh, it was a very intimate look into stuff I don't wanna tell people about. One of the beauties of what I get to do is I can describe my world and my life"},{"seconds":1002.457,"time":"16:42","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"experience, and I can disguise it in a way that you don't know it's about me. Oh. So it's almost like a, it's almost like a fucking songwriter writing a song about- Yeah … about an experience in life. Oh, well said, Johnny. Well said. Yeah. Well, that's fucking nuts, dude."},{"seconds":1015.311,"time":"16:55","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Well, yeah. And Jo- and this is sand we're making this. You're telling a story- Yeah … out of fucking sand. Right. God damn. Right, and no, no critics are gonna go back afterwards and analyze what the hell I was talking about, 'cause the pieces are gone."},{"seconds":1027.791,"time":"17:07","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"John, we got a question from Petro in the comm- in the comments here. Does Car- Got a question coming from Oh, hold on. Hold on. Come here. Sure. What is it? Hold on. Here it comes. Here it comes, from Sophia."},{"seconds":1036.249,"time":"17:16","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"You have competed at the master level since 1997. What can a judge see in 10 seconds that a tourist usually misses? Oh, good one."},{"seconds":1048.717,"time":"17:28","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Damn, you know, that's a really good question."},{"seconds":1051.325,"time":"17:31","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Um, and I'm gonna take that on two parts. Number one, you have judges. Who are your judges? Are they other sand sculptors, or are they just some random dude from the beach, right?"},{"seconds":1063.335,"time":"17:43","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Because the sand sculptor's gonna look for a couple different things. They're gonna look for, A, your level of mastery. Have you taken this material and done something seemingly impossible with it? Wow. Have you moved this material in a way that makes people go, \"What the hell?\""},{"seconds":1079.277,"time":"17:59","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"That to me, that's what they're looking for. Wow."},{"seconds":1082.637,"time":"18:02","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"The common guy is looking for, \"Hey, does that resonate with something inside my skull?\" Not to put common people down, but people who don't do this don't understand it- To the intimate level that we do."},{"seconds":1095.711,"time":"18:15","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"So judging comes with a grain of salt. Oh, so Jon, there, there's a grain of salt in the question from Petro. So he says, Petro says, Jon, does Carl- Yeah, the question's coming. Hold on. Yeah, so Jon, you'll have to read it. Does Carl have a solution to the Sorites heap of sand paradox?"},{"seconds":1113.065,"time":"18:33","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Do you know what that is, uh- I can't fucking say all that. Jesus Christ. We, we, we have a… He says- And I sure as hell can't fucking read it. We have a, we have a heap of sand if removing a grain is- So green is the sorites- Sorites."},{"seconds":1126.408,"time":"18:46","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Oh, he can read it. Good. Carl- Yeah … you can see, can you see it? Read that fucker, please. So the, so- Jesus Christ … okay, does Carl, I think you're, uh, uh, I'm not sure what this means. Does Carl have a solution to the Sorites heap of sand paradox? What is that?"},{"seconds":1139.348,"time":"18:59","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Can somebody- Jimmy, ru- run the next comment. There's a next comment for you, Carl. There, there you go … heap of sand, and removing one grain of sand from a heap changes it in a non-heap. Then repeating this process forces the absurd conclusion, a single grain of sand. Oh. Jon, tell Pe- Jon, tell, tell, tell- It's like-"},{"seconds":1153.512,"time":"19:13","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"tell what Petro is- The guy, the guy who's throwing these fucking stumper questions at you, he's a fucking professor from Wake Forest. I like this. I like this. And he, and he literally, what he does is he studies his, his whole life's"},{"seconds":1165.652,"time":"19:25","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"work is basically uncovering bullshit. He's not saying you're full of shit, but he's crazy with- he makes all these fucking crazy cl- he just, he sees things differently. So he asks questions that gets people thinking. And fuck- No, actually- Petro, I don't even know what the"},{"seconds":1179.027,"time":"19:39","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"fuck you're talking about. That, that, that does make me think. Uh- But it also makes me think of the paradox of, you know, if you fix your car, if you replace enough pieces on your car, when does it stop being your car, right?"},{"seconds":1192.016,"time":"19:52","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Oh, fuck. And when does it become a conglomeration of pieces that are not your car? And the same thing is true with sand. I've taken away enough sand, and when does the sculpture happen? That's one of those questions that can never be answered."},{"seconds":1206.203,"time":"20:06","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"That's fascinating. That's fascinating. Johnny, we're gonna wrap up with Carl here. If, if, if, if we got Petro joining us here, so let's thank Carl for hanging out with us. So Carl, this is… We're just what basically Keith is saying, we've gotta move on to our next segment."},{"seconds":1218.52,"time":"20:18","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"But we both- Yeah … wanna fucking thank you. It's a real fucking pleasure. And- Thank you, guys. Thank you guys for having me on, man more, and more importantly- You guys are the man, bro. I love it … thank you for, for taking the whole scrotum thing with a, with a grain of sand."},{"seconds":1230.523,"time":"20:30","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Not a problem. It was a good intro. Maybe we'll do it another time. Right on, brother. Hey, Carl, it was a pleasure, brother. Keep fucking doing what you're doing. I love to hear about people like yourself who have taken- Right on something that's a passion and done amazing things with it."},{"seconds":1243.796,"time":"20:43","speaker":"Speaker unverified","text":"Keep that shit going. You're leading by example. The world needs you. Carl, thanks for hanging out with us, Carl. Thank you, gentlemen. Have a lovely day. All right. Carl Jara here. Fuck, I love him. Anderson, that was awesome, man. That was fucking awesome.","reviewNote":"Guest name spelling corrected against the appearance record; speaker attribution remains unverified."}],"publicationStatus":"published","publisher":"Mornings in the Lab","clips":[{"id":"art-that-washes-away","title":"The experience is the point.","start":590.558,"end":646.057,"shareUrl":"https://mornings.network/shows/center-stage/guests/carl-jara?format=horizontal#art-that-washes-away","formats":[{"url":"https://pub-176ab0b7668b46259a6c72d4ad146d40.r2.dev/guest-packages/carl-jara/2026-11-06/art-that-washes-away-landscape-1080p.mp4","filename":"art-that-washes-away-landscape-1080p.mp4","width":1920,"height":1080,"bytes":30995003,"kind":"video","orientation":"horizontal","status":"ready","captions":"/guest-packages/carl-jara/art-that-washes-away.vtt","sizeBytes":30995003,"downloadUrl":"https://pub-176ab0b7668b46259a6c72d4ad146d40.r2.dev/guest-packages/carl-jara/2026-11-06/art-that-washes-away-landscape-1080p.mp4?download=1"},{"url":"https://pub-176ab0b7668b46259a6c72d4ad146d40.r2.dev/guest-packages/carl-jara/2026-11-06/art-that-washes-away-portrait-1080p.mp4","filename":"art-that-washes-away-portrait-1080p.mp4","width":1080,"height":1920,"bytes":15655417,"kind":"video","orientation":"vertical","status":"ready","captions":"/guest-packages/carl-jara/art-that-washes-away.vtt","sizeBytes":15655417,"downloadUrl":"https://pub-176ab0b7668b46259a6c72d4ad146d40.r2.dev/guest-packages/carl-jara/2026-11-06/art-that-washes-away-portrait-1080p.mp4?download=1"}],"artwork":[{"url":"https://mornings.network/guest-packages/carl-jara/art-that-washes-away-landscape.jpg","filename":"art-that-washes-away-landscape.jpg","width":1920,"height":1080,"bytes":255917,"kind":"artwork","orientation":"horizontal","status":"ready","sizeBytes":255917,"downloadUrl":"https://mornings.network/guest-packages/carl-jara/art-that-washes-away-landscape.jpg?download=1"},{"url":"https://mornings.network/guest-packages/carl-jara/art-that-washes-away-portrait.jpg","filename":"art-that-washes-away-portrait.jpg","width":1080,"height":1920,"bytes":215808,"kind":"artwork","orientation":"vertical","status":"ready","sizeBytes":215808,"downloadUrl":"https://mornings.network/guest-packages/carl-jara/art-that-washes-away-portrait.jpg?download=1"}]},{"id":"what-judges-see","title":"What does a sculpture judge see?","start":1055.011,"end":1098.197,"shareUrl":"https://mornings.network/shows/center-stage/guests/carl-jara?format=vertical#what-judges-see","formats":[{"url":"https://pub-176ab0b7668b46259a6c72d4ad146d40.r2.dev/guest-packages/carl-jara/2026-11-06/what-judges-see-landscape-1080p.mp4","filename":"what-judges-see-landscape-1080p.mp4","width":1920,"height":1080,"bytes":21769257,"kind":"video","orientation":"horizontal","status":"ready","captions":"/guest-packages/carl-jara/what-judges-see.vtt","sizeBytes":21769257,"downloadUrl":"https://pub-176ab0b7668b46259a6c72d4ad146d40.r2.dev/guest-packages/carl-jara/2026-11-06/what-judges-see-landscape-1080p.mp4?download=1"},{"url":"https://pub-176ab0b7668b46259a6c72d4ad146d40.r2.dev/guest-packages/carl-jara/2026-11-06/what-judges-see-portrait-1080p.mp4","filename":"what-judges-see-portrait-1080p.mp4","width":1080,"height":1920,"bytes":13704990,"kind":"video","orientation":"vertical","status":"ready","captions":"/guest-packages/carl-jara/what-judges-see.vtt","sizeBytes":13704990,"downloadUrl":"https://pub-176ab0b7668b46259a6c72d4ad146d40.r2.dev/guest-packages/carl-jara/2026-11-06/what-judges-see-portrait-1080p.mp4?download=1"}],"artwork":[{"url":"https://mornings.network/guest-packages/carl-jara/what-judges-see-landscape.jpg","filename":"what-judges-see-landscape.jpg","width":1920,"height":1080,"bytes":267657,"kind":"artwork","orientation":"horizontal","status":"ready","sizeBytes":267657,"downloadUrl":"https://mornings.network/guest-packages/carl-jara/what-judges-see-landscape.jpg?download=1"},{"url":"https://mornings.network/guest-packages/carl-jara/what-judges-see-portrait.jpg","filename":"what-judges-see-portrait.jpg","width":1080,"height":1920,"bytes":225125,"kind":"artwork","orientation":"vertical","status":"ready","sizeBytes":225125,"downloadUrl":"https://mornings.network/guest-packages/carl-jara/what-judges-see-portrait.jpg?download=1"}]}]}