Jeffrey Deskovic: the conversation
Mornings in the Lab · Center Stage · Interview transcript
Transcribed from the recorded guest conversation. Automatic transcription may contain errors. Timestamps refer to the source recording or segment.
[00:00:00] ↗[00:00:00] Maya: Some people are still waiting for an apology that would not give back what was taken anyway. A boss, a parent, a system, somebody did damage, moved on, and left you carrying the bill. The hard question is what you build when the people who owe you will never make it right. After hours in an interrogation room, he broke.
[00:00:21] ↗[00:00:21] Maya: On the floor, sobbing, that moment became his confession. The DNA had already excluded him. Still, at 17, a jury sent him away for rape and murder. He spent 16 years in prison. Some of that time came inside an adult supermax as a teenager. While Jeffrey wrote letters and filed appeals, the person responsible stayed free and another life was lost.
[00:00:44] ↗[00:00:44] Maya: He walked out at 33 with no shortcut back to the years that were gone, so he chased the childhood dream the system could not bury. He became an attorney. Then he used $1.5 million of his settlement to build the Jeffrey Deskovic Foundation for Justice. That foundation has helped free 15 innocent people.
[00:01:03] ↗[00:01:03] Maya: His story now lives on in the feature film 16 Years. Jeffrey, welcome to The Lab. We're grateful to have this conversation with you today.
[00:01:15] ↗[00:01:15] Keith: Hey, Jon and Johnny. At 16 years old, Jeffrey Deskovic, he sat in an interrogation room for hours, exhausted, terrified, grieving a murdered classmate, while detectives fed him details from the crime scene until he broke. We're gonna start the conversation right now with our guest, Jeffrey Deskovic. What's going on, Jeffrey?
[00:01:32] ↗[00:01:32] Jeffrey Deskovic: Hey, glad to be here. the, it's pronounced Deskovic, but listen, that was incredible. I have never been introed in, in that manner before. That was, like, off the charts. That was excellent.
[00:01:43] ↗[00:01:43] Keith: Thank you. Oh my
[00:01:43] ↗[00:01:43] Jeffrey Deskovic: God.
[00:01:44] ↗[00:01:44] Keith: Thank you for those kind words, and thank you for the name correction. so Deskovic. I'm thinking out loud here.
[00:01:48] ↗[00:01:48] Keith: Yeah. it's Eastern European. What, what, Deskovic, what's,
[00:01:51] ↗[00:01:51] Jeffrey Deskovic: It's Cze- it's Czechoslovakian.
[00:01:52] ↗[00:01:52] Keith: Yes, of course, of course. That's awesome, man. Yeah, so welcome to the show. It's Keith and Jon and Jeff- Jeffrey, where are you joining us from today?
[00:01:59] ↗[00:01:59] Jeffrey Deskovic: my, my home in the Throgs Neck section of the Bronx
[00:02:01] ↗[00:02:01] Keith: Oh yeah.
[00:02:02] ↗[00:02:02] Keith: There you go, there you go. Hey, Jeffrey, not many guests get, get a chance to spend time with John with his hat off, so you should feel pretty honored today.
[00:02:10] ↗[00:02:10] Jeffrey Deskovic: I, I do.
[00:02:12] ↗[00:02:12] Jon Andersen: It's... I'm leaving it on and off today, you know. I'm managing, I'm managing temperature, body temperature by hat on and off. I
[00:02:19] ↗[00:02:19] Jeffrey Deskovic: love it. Yeah, I hear you, man.
[00:02:21] ↗[00:02:21] Jeffrey Deskovic: It's been hot lately, so I'm doing the same thing here, just in ways that don't involve a hat.
[00:02:28] ↗[00:02:28] Keith: So Jeffrey, I was really eager to get into the chat today with you, man, because, man, I don't even know where to start. Maybe, maybe I start right here. Johnny, maybe we start here. Let's go back to November '89. Angela Correa goes out with a camera- Yes. Let's get into it. Can we go here? So Angela Correa goes out with a camera photography class and never comes home.
[00:02:48] ↗[00:02:48] Keith: You're not close friends with her, but you're destroyed by it. What was going on inside you that police made looking at you for grief and guilt? Let's get into it, Jeffrey.
[00:02:57] ↗[00:02:57] Jeffrey Deskovic: Sure. na- name pronunciation, adjustment. Angela Correa, but yeah, your facts are, again- Yeah ... spot on. Okay, so-
[00:03:03] ↗[00:03:03] Jon Andersen: You're all over the names, all over the names, brother.
[00:03:05] ↗[00:03:05] Keith: I love it. I love
[00:03:07] ↗[00:03:07] Jeffrey Deskovic: it. But in fairness, it's hard to pronounce names if you never heard them before. There's no real hard and fast rules. It's just generalities that sometimes don't apply.
[00:03:14] ↗[00:03:14] Keith: Yeah. Yeah. So talk to us.
[00:03:16] ↗[00:03:16] Jeffrey Deskovic: Sure. So she was in two of my classes, a freshman, one as a sophomore. I knew her name, she knew mine.
[00:03:21] ↗[00:03:21] Jeffrey Deskovic: That was really the extent of it. I wasn't even really on a hi-bye basis. But I was a sensitive teenager. This was my first real brush with death, and so I had an emotional reaction to it. And the q- police thought that that emotional reaction was disproportionate to what my actual relationship with her was.
[00:03:40] ↗[00:03:40] Jeffrey Deskovic: So they thought that was some sort of outward sign that I was sorry for what I did. but in addition to that, I mean, in overall, I was q- in, in high school I was quiet and to myself. I didn't participate in a lot of organized sports, so, the, when the police interviewed many students from the school, some of them told them that they might wanna talk to me.
[00:03:57] ↗[00:03:57] Jeffrey Deskovic: So that, so those two factors are how I got on their radar, and then that was reinforced by a psychological profile that they got from the NYPD, which pr- claimed to have the characteristics of the actual perpetrator, and I matched that. So it was a reinforcing factor.
[00:04:12] ↗[00:04:12] Keith: Wow. Johnny?
[00:04:15] ↗[00:04:15] Jon Andersen: Wow, brother. So I, I ask this question only 'cause your story is pretty rare.
[00:04:20] ↗[00:04:20] Jeffrey Deskovic: Right.
[00:04:20] ↗[00:04:20] Jon Andersen: So you get out after 16 years.
[00:04:23] ↗[00:04:23] Jeffrey Deskovic: Yes. Right?
[00:04:24] ↗[00:04:24] Jon Andersen: And you... "Oh fuck, we're sorry. You were right." Is there any, do they give you anything besides your fucking clothes back?
[00:04:33] ↗[00:04:33] Jeffrey Deskovic: No. No, no, they don't.
[00:04:36] ↗[00:04:36] Jon Andersen: Fuck me.
[00:04:37] ↗[00:04:37] Jeffrey Deskovic: So, you know- Man, do the world need to- ... one of the big failings in the system is that although you can sue and get compensation, which, which I did, you know, i- and that took five years, you know?
[00:04:46] ↗[00:04:46] Jeffrey Deskovic: So there was no i- i- and there was no in- there was no immediate- So what
[00:04:49] ↗[00:04:49] Jon Andersen: was it, what... At five years, what was the compensation?
[00:04:52] ↗[00:04:52] Keith: So Johnny, they, so he sued for 41, the pre-trial settlement was 10, 10 mil, and he, and he, and he, and he invested 1.5 into a foundation.
[00:04:59] ↗[00:04:59] Jon Andersen: Oh, from the beginning. I'm sorry, I missed that.
[00:05:01] ↗[00:05:01] Jon Andersen: It's okay. Yeah. Trying to get my camera was fuzzy. Yeah. So that's like saying your life is worth about, what, 750 a year?
[00:05:13] ↗[00:05:13] Jeffrey Deskovic: Well, yeah, about, about, well, 10 to... Yeah, yeah, that's the math. Yeah, you're doing fast math s- faster than me, but yeah. Right, but my point overall is that there should've been immediate assistance as far as housing, cost of living, you know, d- doctor, doctor, dental, psy- the men- mental health assistance, classes on technology, job training, job assistance- Oh brother,
[00:05:32] ↗[00:05:32] Jon Andersen: no, I'm, I'm saying you were fucking...
[00:05:34] ↗[00:05:34] Jon Andersen: I, I'm supporting you. I'm saying that's, that's fucking ridiculous. Right. That should've had... Th- that 10 should've been hundreds
[00:05:41] ↗[00:05:41] Jeffrey Deskovic: Yeah, for sure. I, I,
[00:05:43] ↗[00:05:43] Jon Andersen: I
[00:05:43] ↗[00:05:43] Jeffrey Deskovic: agree ...
[00:05:43] ↗[00:05:43] Jon Andersen: Yeah, that's, you can't, that's the, it took 16 years of the one thing that can't replace back from you. You can't replace that time.
[00:05:51] ↗[00:05:51] Jeffrey Deskovic: No, you can't. I mean, just think about just those developers.
[00:05:54] ↗[00:05:54] Jeffrey Deskovic: I mean, so many rites of passage. I mean, I missed births- Yeah ... deaths, weddings. I didn't graduate high school. I didn't go to the prom. I didn't get to finish my, education at a more tradit- at a more traditional age. I mean, when I was released, you know, at, at 32, that had to, I had never before had a driver's license.
[00:06:11] ↗[00:06:11] Jeffrey Deskovic: I had never lived, lived alone. I never had went shopping before. I never wrote a check. I never had to balance a budget. So I had to try to do all those things on the fly, you know, after I was released for the first time. So it was- Wow ... definitely a difficult time, you know, by way of, you know, adjustment.
[00:06:26] ↗[00:06:26] Jeffrey Deskovic: Then there's psychological after effects. I mean, I went to see a mental health professional four times a week for like six years in dealing with the after effects, and also adjusting to everyday life, social stigma. I mean, no one questioned my innocence because the actual perpetrator was caught through the, through the DNA and, and arrested and convicted, but there was still the stigma there.
[00:06:45] ↗[00:06:45] Jeffrey Deskovic: So how much... You were in prison for 16 years wrongfully, sure, but you were there for 16 years, so how much of that rubbed off on you? Is it safe to be alone? Yeah.
[00:06:53] ↗[00:06:53] Jon Andersen: Yeah, it's like a semi-transparent stain. You never- Yeah ... quite get it all the way gone. Right. Brother, I mean, you're... I, all I... At this point, I'm 50, in my 50s now.
[00:07:02] ↗[00:07:02] Jon Andersen: All I try to do is protect my time. So the thought of losing 16 years- Oh ... oh, my God.
[00:07:08] ↗[00:07:08] Keith: Oh.
[00:07:09] ↗[00:07:09] Jon Andersen: It, it's like makes me sick to my stomach just to think about
[00:07:12] ↗[00:07:12] Keith: it. Jeffrey, we had a guest, Keith and John were fortunate, we had a guest on the show last week or a couple weeks ago, and I believe, John, I think he was wrongly convicted as well.
[00:07:19] ↗[00:07:19] Keith: No, or, no, I'm sorry, he was rightfully convicted, actually. He, the white collar fellow, he was, did some,tax and,crime, whatever it was. but, but one of the things Jeffrey he said was when he was in prison, he focused on, on, on, what was it, John? On, on, on building- Oh,
[00:07:35] ↗[00:07:35] Jon Andersen: yeah, yeah. He was basically j- he was, he was basically 100%
[00:07:39] ↗[00:07:39] Keith: Like building an asset base, like a resume, like an asset of accomplishment so that he could show you as the judge or as John, like the good guy, that I've been putting my time in to become a...
[00:07:49] ↗[00:07:49] Keith: I've been, I'm building an asset. I'm building a resume. I'm trying to find the words, Jeffrey, where-
[00:07:52] ↗[00:07:52] Jon Andersen: Well, he basically got out and he was better than when he went in.
[00:07:55] ↗[00:07:55] Keith: Yeah, that's it. Jeffrey, can you relate to that? Just made him better. 'Cause you, '
[00:07:59] ↗[00:07:59] Jeffrey Deskovic: cause you were in there. I can absolutely relate, yeah, I can absolutely relate to that.
[00:08:01] ↗[00:08:01] Jeffrey Deskovic: So I, I, I, I did that also in my own way. I don't know that I thought of it quite that way, but I did that. So I'll explain briefly. Yeah. So I got GED. I got the associate's degree. I completed a year towards the bachelor's before funding. I com- ... a lot of vocational trades. I learned to type. General business, which pertains to different applications of computer in a workforce setting.
[00:08:22] ↗[00:08:22] Jeffrey Deskovic: Computer repair, painting, plumbing, food service. I got training and worked as a teacher's aide for other prisoners working to get their G- their, their, their GED- from '98 to 2006, I, I read three or four non-fiction, books. I went to the law library. I, I did everything, putting building blocks i- in, in, in place for the future if and when I regained my freedom.
[00:08:43] ↗[00:08:43] Jeffrey Deskovic: So that w- so I can't think about my- And
[00:08:46] ↗[00:08:46] Jon Andersen: think about this, Keith. He's, he's doing the teenage version of what the adult we had on was doing. He w- you know, he- Yeah ... he, he did... At, at, at the teen, he's doing everything that he thinks he should do, obviously based upon- Yeah ... the time he's lost in there. This other gentleman we had on, you know, was, was already a well-to-do adult that just saw his path of betterment- Yeah
[00:09:10] ↗[00:09:10] Jon Andersen: differently. As, as a teen, he, m- our man here did the same thing.
[00:09:15] ↗[00:09:15] Keith: I love it. So Jeffrey, we got, we got, Dr. Jon Pezzachelli, our, our, one of our, one of our co-hosts, and one of the people in the lab here. He's a bullshit professor out of the Carolinas, and you've got a comment for him now. He's Jeffrey D-
[00:09:24] ↗[00:09:24] Jon Andersen: He, he's a...
[00:09:24] ↗[00:09:24] Jon Andersen: What school does he teach? So we could, we, we- Yeah ... he's at, he's at a, a legitimate university. It's not like- Yeah, I think- ... some fucking TikTok given name, title. Yeah,
[00:09:33] ↗[00:09:33] Keith: yeah. He says, "Jeffrey Deskovic has an amazing story. He was unfairly knocked down, got back up, and look what he's doing now. Wow." And I wanna take that, Jeffrey, because there's a lot of men, a lot of humans, a lot of people in our audience that struggle to get off the couch and get going.
[00:09:47] ↗[00:09:47] Keith: What's your advice to somebody who's struggling to get going?
[00:09:50] ↗[00:09:50] Jeffrey Deskovic: Is have a goal, have a realistic plan, right? I mean, you should be able to look at it three or four different ways and say to yourself, "Well, yeah, I could see how this could work." 'Cause it would suck to carry out a plan that you don't think can work, right?
[00:10:02] ↗[00:10:02] Jeffrey Deskovic: be flexible. Remember, the goal's the goal, the plan's not the goal. work real hard. So I'm not a pie-in-the-sky guy, okay? I don't believe it's all gonna ch- turn out good just because. I think you have to work hard to put yourself in a position for a miracle to occur, for someone to open a door for you.
[00:10:18] ↗[00:10:18] Jeffrey Deskovic: No excuses. There might be reasons why something is harder to do- Yeah ... but no reason why you can't do it. You just have to want it enough. You have to go leave it all out on the field. And, and, lastly, never give up. So when- whenever I feel like I can't go on anymore, I say to myself, "You know, maybe this is it.
[00:10:34] ↗[00:10:34] Jeffrey Deskovic: Maybe this is the, maybe this is the key moment right here, and I was on the verge of a breakthrough, but because I quit it, it's not gonna happen. So I'm gonna-" Keep going. No, I can't. I'm going to do it anyway and, and just to see what happens on the other side. Yeah. You know, that would be my advice. And then once you cross the bridge, reach back a- and help other people that are stuck in that same way.
[00:10:55] ↗[00:10:55] Keith: Yeah, Jeffrey Deskovic.
[00:10:57] ↗[00:10:57] Jon Andersen: One more- Jeffrey, baby, that's right, right? When you think you can't do it, all you gotta take is one more step to prove yourself you can.
[00:11:03] ↗[00:11:03] Keith: You know you are innocent. Like, you know. Right. In your brain, you're like, "I didn't do this." But yet, year after year, day after day, hour after hour, you had to keep being told, "No, you belong here," or you had to...
[00:11:17] ↗[00:11:17] Keith: You're assu- it was implied you are here. Like, how do you keep hope, Jeffrey? Like, how do you actually dig- are you a man of faith? Where do you find hope?
[00:11:27] ↗[00:11:27] Jeffrey Deskovic: Look, well, belief in God was one thing. Second of all is I still naively believed in the system, so I thought that- Oh ... all I gotta do is just hold on for a year or two to the next appeal, which I'm sure I'm gonna win, and I'm gonna, I'm gonna go home.
[00:11:41] ↗[00:11:41] Jeffrey Deskovic: I used to go to the law library, and that gave me a sense of, of empowerment. I would read articles about other people that... And I would use that as inspiration and motivation to keep going. But I would also, how'd they g- you know, who helped them? What route did they take? ... there's another prisoner there that was innocent also, Frank Sterling, and we kept each other going.
[00:12:00] ↗[00:12:00] Jeffrey Deskovic: I mean, he was ultimately exonerated through DNA testing after 18 years, couple years after me. And lastly, a pen pal showed up in the nick of time. 'Cause along the way, I lost seven appeals, wrote letters for four years trying to find someone to take my case for free 'cause I had no money, okay? Yeah. The only way back in the court when your appeals are over is if you can find some new evidence, which you can't do that yourself while you're behind bars.
[00:12:21] ↗[00:12:21] Jeffrey Deskovic: So you have to get someone working on it. And, and, then I went to the parole board where largely because I maintained my innocence rather than expressing remorse and taking responsibility, I got turned down for parole. Last year, I was struggling whether to give up, and I had placed an ad looking for a, a pen pal.
[00:12:38] ↗[00:12:38] Jeffrey Deskovic: And this, I was asking this stranger that I didn't know from a can of paint, "Do you think I should quit? Should I give up? Should I just commit suicide? I'm never gonna get out of here." And, and he suggested to keep going, and so that's what I did. So all those factors were how I survived.
[00:12:51] ↗[00:12:51] Jon Andersen: Wow.
[00:12:52] ↗[00:12:52] Jeffrey Deskovic: How I
[00:12:52] ↗[00:12:52] Jon Andersen: kept going.
[00:12:52] ↗[00:12:52] Jon Andersen: Well, you know, check this out, brother. We often talk about how we're programmed, right? And a lot of times programmed into believing that we can't. His programming wasn't complete. He still believed.
[00:13:00] ↗[00:13:00] Keith: Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's fascinating to me, Jeffrey, that you go to the, the parole board multiple times and they keep saying no to you.
[00:13:10] ↗[00:13:10] Jeffrey Deskovic: Well, I just, I went to the board once. I, I went to the... I, I filed seven appeals, but tho- those are- Okay ... legal proceedings to ch- overturn a conviction. Yeah. I went to the parole board, which was, which is where you're asking for a discretionary release from prison where you'd be on super-. So I went there once and, and I, again, I...
[00:13:26] ↗[00:13:26] Jeffrey Deskovic: They wanted me to express remorse and take responsibility. You know, they wanted me to, to have insight into my behavior and express- Yes. Yes ... and instead I said, "Whoa, whoa. Look, I'm sorry the victim lost their life. Yeah, 100%, but I didn't do it. I'm innocent. I'm still maintaining my innocence. DNA doesn't match me."
[00:13:44] ↗[00:13:44] Jeffrey Deskovic: But they weren't willing to consider even that mere possibility that I was innocent.
[00:13:48] ↗[00:13:48] Keith: Wow. Jeffrey, how do you reconcile forgiveness? For example, there, there, there are some police officers that were absolute that you were the guy to go to jail. Right. And so have you, have you faced those men since then?
[00:14:01] ↗[00:14:01] Keith: Have you, have, do, do you, do you, do you reconcile that they were just doing their job? Like, how do you reconcile that there were massive mistakes that took, to Johnny's point, like, fuck... A, a s- a third of your life was taken away from you because of some arrogance or ignorance or not doing their job, Jeffrey
[00:14:18] ↗[00:14:18] Jeffrey Deskovic: Y- yeah, so I've, I've faced them in the sense that I did bring a lawsuit, I brought a, the federal civil rights law- lawsuit, you know, seeking to hold, you know, th- them, them accountable to, so the extent the system would, would allow-
[00:14:29] ↗[00:14:29] Keith: Yes
[00:14:29] ↗[00:14:29] Jeffrey Deskovic: me to. I did sit across the table from them, you know, but you're not allowed to talk. When you're in litigation with people, you're not supposed to, you're not supposed to talk with them, so that's really the closest that I, that, that I, that I got. you know, I'm not... So l- in terms of this part of it, so the cops here, this was not a g- I don't view this as a good faith error.
[00:14:46] ↗[00:14:46] Jeffrey Deskovic: Okay? They coerced a false confession out of me after interrogating me for six and a half to seven hours on a school day, and, you know, without my parents knowing. I'm hooked up to a polygraph machine. They give me, they give me countless cups of coffee. There's threats, there's false promises. None of, none of this is, recorded, you know, audio or video.
[00:15:05] ↗[00:15:05] Jeffrey Deskovic: They falsely attribute a statement to me. They interviewed 17 witnesses once the DNA didn't match me before the trial, and all those witnesses said, told, told them that the victim had no, boyfriend, there was no consensual sex, and they purposely didn't document the witness interviews. And then when they came to court, they left the threatened false promise out of their story.
[00:15:24] ↗[00:15:24] Jeffrey Deskovic: So just to be clear, I don't consider this to be a good faith error on their part. Same thing with the medical examiner who, you know, he fabricated, he claimed af- you know what? Six months after doing an autopsy, he says he remembered that he forgot to document medical findings that he claimed showed the victim was promiscuous, which is what allowed the prosecutor to argue, "Aha, that's how the DNA doesn't match Deskovic and he's still guilty."
[00:15:49] ↗[00:15:49] Jeffrey Deskovic: Whoa. Okay? So, so that's the background on that. on, on the forgiveness piece of it, I don't really think about them. I don't know, I can't say that I forgave them, but I'll say this, that first of all, I don't, I'm not an angry person and I want to enjoy my life as much as I can, and I can't do that and simultaneously be angry or bitter.
[00:16:07] ↗[00:16:07] Jeffrey Deskovic: Yeah. I've lost so much already as is. Yes. Why would I want to, in effect, lose the rest of my life? Look, it ain't like I'd be impacting them if I was angry or bitter, okay? Just to be clear.
[00:16:17] ↗[00:16:17] Keith: That's close to what
[00:16:18] ↗[00:16:18] Jeffrey Deskovic: you were gonna say. So, and the vehicle that allows me to actualize that is I take that energy and I channel it into the advocacy work that I do, and so I have a, you know, I, it's healing, it's cathartic, it's meaningful, it makes a difference, it makes my suffering count for something.
[00:16:31] ↗[00:16:31] Jeffrey Deskovic: And with that, I, I know I'm doing what I'm supposed to do in the world, and I have an inner peace with that. Well,
[00:16:36] ↗[00:16:36] Jon Andersen: you know, brother, the fact that you gathered that perspective-
[00:16:41] ↗[00:16:41] Preston and Sterling: Yeah ...
[00:16:41] ↗[00:16:41] Jon Andersen: it was a, it was a big price to pay for that perspective. But now you are very, very clear what you want, what you don't want, and now you're living what you want, which most people never get to that point
[00:16:54] ↗[00:16:54] Jeffrey Deskovic: Co- correct.
[00:16:54] ↗[00:16:54] Jeffrey Deskovic: Yeah, correct So, you know- You know, it took me a week ... 16
[00:16:57] ↗[00:16:57] Jon Andersen: years, 16 years is a big price to pay, but you're living a life now that's very different than, you know, most. And, you know, the way that we're programmed, so to speak, you know, had you followed the system all the way through, you may never have gathered this position or this life of purpose
[00:17:15] ↗[00:17:15] Jeffrey Deskovic: I, I, I agree with that completely.
[00:17:17] ↗[00:17:17] Jeffrey Deskovic: I wanted to quickly add, you know, the, the, the, the first week I was angry and I realized at the end of that week it was destroying me and I had to go this other route. in terms of the work that I'm doing, I just wanted to quickly, mention, when I was released I got scholarship, from Mercy University.
[00:17:31] ↗[00:17:31] Jeffrey Deskovic: So I finished a bachelor's. Mm. I got a master's degree, from John Jay College of Criminal Justice. My- I wanted to be able to talk about- Amazing ... wrongful conviction issues beyond just what happened in my case, hence getting the master's. I wrote a thesis on wrongful conviction causes and reform. I started the foundation, Jeffrey Deskovic Foundation for Justice.
[00:17:48] ↗[00:17:48] Jeffrey Deskovic: So since opening our doors in 2011, we've been able to free 15 people. We helped pass nine laws. And last thing I'll quickly add is I got tired. After a while, I got tired of sitting in the front row of the courtroom. I wanted to be able to sit at the defense table. I wanted to represent some of the clients, make some of the arguments, hence going to law school, becoming an attorney.
[00:18:07] ↗[00:18:07] Keith: That's so awesome, man. I, I, I, I, I... It's, as sad and unfortunate your journey has been, Jeffrey, as I researched it, I gotta be, I got goosebumps to see where you are now. Like, just, like, your, your conviction for, like, I was wrong. Like, like, your j- your determination of no, it's... Like, what, what people can learn from your story.
[00:18:28] ↗[00:18:28] Keith: And then Jon, get this next. So the, the guy, the guy picks a fi- bigger fight, Anderson. Your foundation, you handle non-DNA wrongful conviction cases, which almost no innocence organization will touch, yet you do. Because DNA is only available in about 5 to 12%- Yeah ... of serious felony cases. That's a harder fight with less certainty of winning.
[00:18:49] ↗[00:18:49] Keith: Why? Why did you take that on? And, what does it take to build a case when there's no smoking gun science to lean on? Why, Jeffrey?
[00:18:57] ↗[00:18:57] Jeffrey Deskovic: so because for a, for a long time I considered that my case was like a non-DNA case in the sense that all the organizations in the field, virtually all of them, want the DNA.
[00:19:08] ↗[00:19:08] Jeffrey Deskovic: They wanted there to be no, no prior testing. They wanted to get the test results, and if it's negative, then they could present that to the court as newly discovered evidence. So for many years, although there was clear evidence of my innocence, no one wanted to touch my case. So I could relate to that aspect of it.
[00:19:24] ↗[00:19:24] Jeffrey Deskovic: A- and secondly, closely related to that, was I, I feel strongly that if someone's in prison for a crime they didn't commit and there's a potential way to win it, why should they be turned down simply because it can't be proven, under a microscope? So those are two clear-cut reasons. And the third thing is I wanted to give, some, some, some hope for people in non, in non-DNA cases.
[00:19:45] ↗[00:19:45] Jeffrey Deskovic: In terms of how to go about it, like you said, exactly, in, in cases- ... where there is no scientific smoking gun. So we look for, similar crimes in nearby areas. We look for, Alternative suspects. We file FOIA requests. Sometimes our doc- documents that are supposed to have been turned over to the defense before the trial were buried, but they surface through a FOIA request.
[00:20:05] ↗[00:20:05] Jeffrey Deskovic: We re-interview witnesses. Sometimes new witnesses, bubble to the surface. Sometimes a bad a- actor, a forensic scientist, their misconduct bubbled to the surface in an unrelated case, so now that's new evidence. Sometimes a, a case was obtained, in part by junk science, so that gives us a area of attack.
[00:20:24] ↗[00:20:24] Jeffrey Deskovic: So to sum up, we ha- we have to check the box in two areas. Number one, do we believe the innocence claim is based on something objective, which includes us analyzing what was used as evidence of guilt in the first place. And second, we see, have to see a potential route to exonerations, to exoneration. If we can't check both of those boxes, then we can't move ahead.
[00:20:44] ↗[00:20:44] Keith: Yeah, yeah. Jeffrey Deskovic, myself, Jon Anderson this morning on Mornings Live with Keith, John, and friends. And Jeffrey, how much of this is, how much, h- h- how much of your case is political?
[00:20:56] ↗[00:20:56] Jeffrey Deskovic: You know, o- only to the extent that the pol- there was a political intersection in this, in this, that there was a lot of public pressure on the police department to- Yes
[00:21:04] ↗[00:21:04] Jeffrey Deskovic: solve the case. Yes. I mean, there were town halls that were repeatedly held where progress on investigation were given, safety tips were conveyed. You know, parents were driving their kids directly to school, picking them up immediately afterwards. So the whole city of Peekskill essentially sh- So there was political political on that.
[00:21:22] ↗[00:21:22] Jeffrey Deskovic: And then also the state police were breathing down the Peekskill police neck, because the victim's family didn't think the Peekskill police knew what they were doing. So they went to the state police and asked them- Wow ... to take over the investigation. They didn't do that, but they did convey that they came to them.
[00:21:38] ↗[00:21:38] Jeffrey Deskovic: And, and another thing I'll say is, you know, when the, when the, DNA databank was created in 1997, '98, you know, I, I asked the then district attorney, of Westchester, Jeanine Pirro, I asked for further testing in a letter, which she denied. We asked for further testing in federal court documents. So I think that that aspect of it was political in the sense that they didn't want to an error of, of their, of their office.
[00:22:04] ↗[00:22:04] Jeffrey Deskovic: some of the people that worked on my case were still active, you know, in, in that office. I think that they didn't want the scrutiny. Well, what if someone decides to look at other case worked on? What if someone decides to look at other cases that that medical examiner did autopsies on, or that this prosecutor worked on?
[00:22:23] ↗[00:22:23] Jeffrey Deskovic: So I think wanna open Pandora's box that way. So I think that those aspects of it, were, were political.
[00:22:29] ↗[00:22:29] Jon Andersen: For sure. I mean, think it like this, you got, back in these days too, this is a fucking huge ordeal. Yes. Correct. This shit happens all the time now, but I mean, you know, think about it. You got a fucking town, a school, a whole fucking area just freak the fuck out.
[00:22:45] ↗[00:22:45] Jon Andersen: The police chief and the mayor are going, telling the, the, all the detectives, "You motherfuckers, go convict somebody so we can settle this place down."
[00:22:54] ↗[00:22:54] Jeffrey Deskovic: Right.
[00:22:55] ↗[00:22:55] Keith: Yeah, yeah. Well, so, so, so Jeffrey, let's talk about Jeanne Pirro. So, after you were convicted, you spent years appealing to the DA, who by the time you were fighting hardest, it was Jeanne- Jeanine Pirro, for a post-conviction DNA test.
[00:23:09] ↗[00:23:09] Keith: She refused repeatedly. And while she was refusing, I think my facts are correct here, Steven Cunningham was freed, and he committed another murder. Right. Jesus. So what, what should people understand about that whole refusal and that cost, not just to you, but everybody? Like M- Jesus Murphy.
[00:23:29] ↗[00:23:29] Jeffrey Deskovic: Right. Yeah, so your facts are, again, spot on, as they've been throughout the interview.
[00:23:34] ↗[00:23:34] Jeffrey Deskovic: Pirro often likes to say, you know, to distance herself from my case, "Oh, I wasn't the DA when he was convicted." Okay, fair enough, you weren't. But you did take office before my appe- first appeal was decided. Your office fought me in seven, in seven appeals, including blocking me from further DNA testing several, several t- Office wrote in a brief that a...
[00:23:57] ↗[00:23:57] Jeffrey Deskovic: Listen to this one. You're gonna love this, guys. Yeah. A negative DNA test result is no insulation to a guilty verdict, right? Your lawyers wrote that. What? Okay, you got me bounced out of federal court because the court clerk, 'cause my petition was four days too late, a lateness that was caused by the court clerk giving my lawyer the wrong information, right?
[00:24:19] ↗[00:24:19] Jeffrey Deskovic: You w- you fought to uphold that ruling in the next three legal proceedings. You won that. You blocked me from DNA testing several times. And meanwhile, Cunningham kills another victim three and a half years later, a schoolteacher, Patricia Morrison, of Peekskill, who had, who, who had, was, had three children.
[00:24:35] ↗[00:24:35] Jeffrey Deskovic: And you're trying to tell me that you bear no moral culpability of that whatsoever because you weren't the DA, that, that's what you're saying? And the bigger point, I'll sum up with this on this point. The bigger point that I want your audience to know is that every time the wrong person goes to prison, that means the actual perpetrator is free to strike again.
[00:24:58] ↗[00:24:58] Jeffrey Deskovic: And therefore wrongful conviction is a big public safety issue. And that, that, that happened in my case. He killed someone else.
[00:25:06] ↗[00:25:06] Jon Andersen: Can you imagine a thing like this? You know, you're one of the, call it a, one of the group of people that were trying to just push this through to c- get someone convicted to calm the place down.
[00:25:18] ↗[00:25:18] Jon Andersen: You get out, right? You become a fucking lawyer. What worse threat can you fucking have for these poor motherfuckers? They're thinking, "Holy Christ, our worst fucking nightmare has just come true. That fucking kid we put away 16 years ago now can fucking sue the pants off this department."
[00:25:36] ↗[00:25:36] Keith: It's not lost upon me, Johnny, too, the irony of it, right?
[00:25:38] ↗[00:25:38] Keith: The irony of the whole fucking thing. He's like, Jeffrey's like, "No, I'm coming after you motherfuckers."
[00:25:44] ↗[00:25:44] Jeffrey Deskovic: Right. Right. And on a, so, so building off of that, the, ne- next book is... Look, first of all, I mean, look, I want to be the person I wish I had while I was on the inside, okay? That was one thing. Second thing, you know, I, I feel so fortunate, you know, that, I still have my mind.
[00:25:59] ↗[00:25:59] Jeffrey Deskovic: I didn't lose my mind. I've had educational opportunities that I availed myself of that a lot of other people, either don't have or don't avail themselves of. So you know, I, I feel like it, it's, it's a big moral responsibility that I put on myself, you know, that I can't just walk away or forget or pretend.
[00:26:13] ↗[00:26:13] Jeffrey Deskovic: so that's one aspect of it. But on a different level, different points, se- different branch, same tree,I wanna share that the Pero successor, Janet DiFiore, became the DA after that. I, I, I always give her her props and, and, and respect that, look, you granted me the further testing Pero didn't. You consented to the conviction being overturned, consented it to be- being dismissed on, on innocence grounds.
[00:26:39] ↗[00:26:39] Jeffrey Deskovic: But she didn't get a free pass from me either, okay? Her, her body of wrongful conviction work unfortunately begins and ends with my case. So there've been plenty of other cases, including those that have ended in exoneration, other Westchester County cases where I, where I went against her, you know? At the end of the day, you gotta be against wrongful conviction a- a- and be about truth, justice, accuracy, all day, every day, twice on weekends.
[00:27:03] ↗[00:27:03] Jeffrey Deskovic: And if you don't, you're one side of the street a- a- a- and I'm on the other. You don't get a pass from me just because you did the right thing for me.
[00:27:14] ↗[00:27:14] Keith: Yeah. Jeffrey Deskovic, I know we're coming up on time. Do you have, do you have two extra minutes for me?
[00:27:18] ↗[00:27:18] Jeffrey Deskovic: Absolutely.
[00:27:19] ↗[00:27:19] Keith: So I- I... Johnny, I'm wondering this. You spend 16 years in prison with a lot of men who are also innocent In quotes.
[00:27:28] ↗[00:27:28] Keith: You get out. How quickly is your, without, I'm joking, I'm being serious here. Right. How quickly is your phone ringing going, "Jeffrey, I'm innocent too. I'm innocent too. I'm innocent too." And you're like, "Oh, fuck. I know you're not. I know you might be. I know you're not." I'm being serious here because I gotta think once you got out, there's a lot of dudes you hung out with who were like, "Okay, I gotta call Jeffrey 'cause he'll get me out as well."
[00:27:50] ↗[00:27:50] Jeffrey Deskovic: 100% that people do that. And, and the breakdown... I know that you might be... No, I, I doubt it on, on over here. Hun- 100%. Yeah. That, that happened, a lot. And but by the way, that still happens now, just in a slightly different manner. Instead of the metaphorical phone ringing, you know, when people write the, the Foundation, you know, before they even get into their case, they always make sure, some people, they make sure, "Well, but I knew Jeff while I..."
[00:28:18] ↗[00:28:18] Preston and Sterling: Yeah. Yes.
[00:28:19] ↗[00:28:19] Jeffrey Deskovic: And you know, the staff lets me know and I go, "Well, who, who was this?" Well, and you know, ask them for a picture. But you know, most of the time they don't, I, I don't know them, they just falsely claim that. But honestly speaking, they don't seem to realize- It wouldn't me if you were the dude that I hung out with the most.
[00:28:36] ↗[00:28:36] Jeffrey Deskovic: E- either we believe in your innocence claim or... And there's a pot- and there's a potential way to win it, or we don't. Y- your case is still gonna rise or fall on its own merits. That's not gonna earn you anything. That's just... When I ask, "Hey, what's the name?" or, "Give me a picture," that's just to satisfy my curiosity.
[00:28:52] ↗[00:28:52] Jeffrey Deskovic: It doesn't, it doesn't impact the case analysis whatsoever.
[00:28:56] ↗[00:28:56] Keith: Yeah. Yeah.
[00:28:57] ↗[00:28:57] Jon Andersen: It's not, it's not, "Oh, fuck. He used to give me his brownie at dinner. I'm gonna get him
[00:29:03] ↗[00:29:03] Jeffrey Deskovic: out." Right. Exactly. And then, and then- No, absolutely not, because look, it w- a quick point I'll make as, as a follow-up to that. You know, once you've been convicted, you don't have the presumption of innocence no more.
[00:29:13] ↗[00:29:13] Jeffrey Deskovic: As a matter of fact, you're... It's the opposite. You're presumed to be guilty. So now you have to prove- Oh ... to the court that you're innocent. So in the case of somebody that's guilty, right, w- where is it that I'm gonna go to go a- a- and find some evidence to prove that a guilty person's innocent? You know?
[00:29:29] ↗[00:29:29] Jeffrey Deskovic: Yeah. It- it's not gonna happen. So if I were to take cases of pe- You know, we wouldn't go anywhere. We, we would just be spinning our wheels and not- Spinning
[00:29:36] ↗[00:29:36] Keith: in circles. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And Jeffrey, and finally, I, I, I suspect I know the answer to this, but I have to ask it.
[00:29:42] ↗[00:29:42] Jeffrey Deskovic: Sure.
[00:29:42] ↗[00:29:42] Keith: I, I'm gonna, I'm gonna lead with it.
[00:29:44] ↗[00:29:44] Keith: I suspect you do not spend much time of your life today worrying about what you could have been had you not spent 16 years in prison, because I believe after spending 35 minutes with you, you recognize that's not a good use of your time. You're just getting on with your life. Am I correct, Jeffrey?
[00:30:02] ↗[00:30:02] Jeffrey Deskovic: You are complete...
[00:30:03] ↗[00:30:03] Jeffrey Deskovic: Yes, you are completely correct. Yes. Yeah.
[00:30:07] ↗[00:30:07] Keith: Yeah.
[00:30:08] ↗[00:30:08] Jeffrey Deskovic: Look, I can deal with today. I can, I can work towards what I wanna do tomorrow. I, I, there, there's no do-overs, right? Someone figures that out, contact me. I, I, I got the biggest do-over ever. I love it. But short of, short of that, I, I have to deal with today and tomorrow.
[00:30:23] ↗[00:30:23] Jeffrey Deskovic: I can't think about... That, it, it's futile. Nothing good's gonna come of it. It's a waste of time. You know, I'll get myself stressed out or feel other human emotions that I don't, that are not necessary.
[00:30:33] ↗[00:30:33] Keith: Yeah. Yeah. Johnny
[00:30:34] ↗[00:30:34] Jeffrey Deskovic: Colzen- You know, all these things I wanna ex- I wanna ex- You know, you- Plus, you know, the small things.
[00:30:37] ↗[00:30:37] Jeffrey Deskovic: I appreciate the small things, man. I, I like, like feeling the sun on my face, fresh air, freedom of movement- Yeah ... going new places, trying new food, having new experiences. So I wanna do those things and appreciate what most of us, including me, I don't exempt myself, used to take for granted before I lost it.
[00:30:53] ↗[00:30:53] Jeffrey Deskovic: So why would I wanna do the opposite of that and just think about, you know, what, what could, coulda, shoulda, woulda?
[00:30:59] ↗[00:30:59] Keith: Yeah. Yeah. Johnny Colzen?
[00:31:00] ↗[00:31:00] Jon Andersen: Yeah, I was just gonna say, brother, you taking a really fucking humongous, humongous fucking lemon and turning it into lemonade.
[00:31:10] ↗[00:31:10] Keith: Yeah. Yeah. Jeffrey Deskovic, I, I'm so grateful that, you chose to spend some time, you know, and I use the word chose 'cause you didn't have to.
[00:31:17] ↗[00:31:17] Keith: You chose to spend some time with myself and Johnny this morning. So grateful for that. love your energy, love your perspective. And one thing, John, I'll pick up on Jeffrey here. Brother, I was, I was very focused today because I notice with you, which I can really appreciate, the facts are extremely important to you.
[00:31:33] ↗[00:31:33] Keith: Yes.
[00:31:33] ↗[00:31:33] Jon Andersen: By the names, right out of the gate. Yeah.
[00:31:35] ↗[00:31:35] Keith: The names and somebody And, and, dude, and as I was w- as I was... I have some notes here in front of me. As I was listening to you, I was really being intentional, 'cause I love that and I respect that, 'cause I did not wanna get anything wrong. So I thank you for y- y- you having some fun with us today.
[00:31:49] ↗[00:31:49] Keith: Thank you for sharing your story with us. And any closing comments before you say goodbye?
[00:31:54] ↗[00:31:54] Jeffrey Deskovic: Yeah. If, if people have liked what they heard from me today and would like to hear more, please follow us on social media. Our, our Instagram, Deskovic Foundation. on Facebook, my name Jeffrey Deskovic is there.
[00:32:04] ↗[00:32:04] Jeffrey Deskovic: Also, The Jeffrey Deskovic Foundation, for Justice. Look, my ultimate dream is to have a chapter of the Deskovic Foundation in each state and ultimately each country. I, I see this as a worldwide issue, and countries where we don't hear about wrongful conviction, I can assure you it's not because the system is getting it right 100% of the time.
[00:32:22] ↗[00:32:22] Jeffrey Deskovic: So that expansion will, will happen as, yeah, as we're able to get the,public financial support. Dream for a second, fellas. What if 25,000 people were willing to sacrifice $5 current monthly basis to our Patreon website? That would give us close to a million dollars. We could have other attorneys, paralegals, other essential personnel could work on freeing even more innocent people than we currently have the capacity to, given our, limited infrastructure.
[00:32:46] ↗[00:32:46] Jeffrey Deskovic: we could do policy work. So, you know, lastly, another thing is my biggest challenge as a founder of a nonprofit, I didn't make it in business 10, 20, 30, 40 years. Now I have a cachet of people that rose through the ranks with me I can turn to, "Hey, this is my charitable endeavor," and everyone helps. So that means I gotta rely on third parties who can function as connectors to people of capacity.
[00:33:06] ↗[00:33:06] Jeffrey Deskovic: And it's a short conversation. "Here's who I am. Here's my credentials. Here's my body of work. Here's the m- foundation's,track r- mission, our track record. Here's the metrics we could make, meet if we had additional resources. Is this something that appeals to you?"
[00:33:20] ↗[00:33:20] Keith: Love it. I love it. Jeffrey Diskovat, Keith and John.
[00:33:23] ↗[00:33:23] Keith: Actually, I thought you were gonna say my dream was to have a morning show with Keith and John, but that was, not part of your answer there, so
[00:33:30] ↗[00:33:30] Jeffrey Deskovic: Right.
[00:33:31] ↗[00:33:31] Keith: He's like-
[00:33:32] ↗[00:33:32] Jeffrey Deskovic: It would be a lot of fun, though. I can sense that from this conversation.
[00:33:36] ↗[00:33:36] Keith: It would be a lot of fun. Good, good,
[00:33:37] ↗[00:33:37] Jeffrey Deskovic: good. Well, you- You guys got a great shtick already, as, as is.
[00:33:40] ↗[00:33:40] Jeffrey Deskovic: I'm, I'm grateful you shared your platform with me on, on this morning. Oh, thank you. I had a lot of fun, guys. I really, really did.
[00:33:46] ↗[00:33:46] Keith: That's awesome. Well, it's really kind of you to drop those words, and, we are, we... On behalf of Johnny and myself and the whole team, we're really grateful you spent some time with us today.
[00:33:52] ↗[00:33:52] Keith: And, dude, brother, just keep fucking kicking ass, as Johnny would say, man, because, you are clearly kicking it, and just keep kicking ass, Jeffrey.
[00:33:59] ↗[00:33:59] Jeffrey Deskovic: Will do. Thank you.
[00:34:00] ↗[00:34:00] Keith: Awesome. Thank you. All right.
[00:34:01] ↗[00:34:01] Jon Andersen: Great speaking with you, brother.
[00:34:03] ↗[00:34:03] Jeffrey Deskovic: Same here.