NEXT LIVEMornings in the Lab with Keith, Jon & Friendsin 2h 13m
← Justin Paperny

Justin Paperny: the conversation

Mornings in the Lab · Center Stage · Interview transcript

Transcribed from the recorded guest conversation. Automatic transcription may contain errors. Timestamps refer to the source recording or segment.

[00:00:00] ↗[00:00:00] Sophia: A lot of people know when they've done something wrong. The hard part is admitting it before consequences arrive. So they keep working, they keep answering emails, they keep acting fine and hope the problem goes away. Justin knows that pattern because he spent years avoiding what he had done. He was 25, the youngest Bear Stearns broker in Century City.

[00:00:20] ↗[00:00:20] Sophia: From the outside, his life looked on track. Then the FBI showed up at his door. The case was real, and the image stopped helping. For a while, he still tried to control the story. He paid $16,000 to make the truth harder to find. It didn't work. The press releases were still there. Eventually, he had to answer for the crime.

[00:00:40] ↗[00:00:40] Sophia: Justin pleaded guilty. He was sentenced to 18 months in federal prison and ordered to repay over $500,000. At Taft Federal Prison Camp, he met Michael in the prison library two days after arriving. Michael had been incarcerated since 1987. Still, he woke at 3:00 AM, ran, wrote, and taught every day. That routine changed Justin.

[00:01:01] ↗[00:01:01] Sophia: He saw a man using discipline to build a future, even inside prison. That is where this story turns, not toward escape, toward discipline, responsibility, and what a man does after he stops hiding. Justin, welcome to the lab. We're grateful to sit down with you today.

[00:01:21] ↗[00:01:21] Keith: Hey, Johnny. On April 28th, 2005, the FBI knocked on this man's door, and today, on June 2nd, 2026, he's walking into ours, and his name is Justin Paperny. What's going on, Justin?

[00:01:33] ↗[00:01:33] Justin Paperny: Good morning, guys. I heard you talking about peptides. When guys go to prison, they ask if they can get peptides in, in prison.

[00:01:39] ↗[00:01:39] Justin Paperny: Unfortunately, at this point, the answer's no.

[00:01:41] ↗[00:01:41] Keith: Oh. Let's start, let's start right there because, Justin, you were in prison a number of years back, and that's when they were having that conversation.

[00:01:49] ↗[00:01:49] Justin Paperny: Well, things have really changed since I was in prison in 2008. There was, like, no iPhones back then. Sure. There were disciplinary infractions, but nothing like we have now.

[00:01:57] ↗[00:01:57] Justin Paperny: Last week, I interviewed... He, he'd be a great guest for you guys, Matthew Boyer. He was the bookmaker in that very popular Shohei Ohtani investigation. He was the book-

[00:02:05] ↗[00:02:05] Keith: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah ...

[00:02:06] ↗[00:02:06] Justin Paperny: and, and he just was released from Lompoc, and he was describing, you know, steroids in prison, smuggling in the peptides, the drugs, everything that's going on.

[00:02:14] ↗[00:02:14] Justin Paperny: So yeah, it's a big deal, the hustling inside of prison, and some guys give into it, and the problem is if you get caught, you get exactly what you don't want. You end up staying in prison longer 'cause you get a disciplinary infraction. You lose good time. So there is so much temptation out here, and also in prison.

[00:02:31] ↗[00:02:31] Justin Paperny: But yep, peptides are a big deal in prison.

[00:02:33] ↗[00:02:33] Keith: Wow. Wow. So I, I wanna start the conversation around one word.

[00:02:39] ↗[00:02:39] Justin Paperny: Yes.

[00:02:39] ↗[00:02:39] Keith: It's a word that many m- So our, you know, our show is as mu- is, is, is a show for Gen X, guys like you and I, and that word is guilt. For you to look in your own mirror and intentionally use that word to acknowledge what had happened, dude, that is a humbling- Very

[00:02:56] ↗[00:02:56] Keith: humbling experience. Talk to us about that.

[00:03:00] ↗[00:03:00] Justin Paperny: So it's humbling, but for me, the real guilt and shame didn't happen until I was in federal prison. So I'd been indicted. I plead guilty. For three years, I'm waiting to get sentenced to prison, but I really made it about me. It wasn't about my victims or my family.

[00:03:14] ↗[00:03:14] Justin Paperny: It was about how my own life was imploding. I was very selfish. Then you get to prison, and then you realize how far I had fallen, the pain that I had brought other people, and then you see a lot of guys going home from prison scared with short sentences because you realize, what are they going to do without a law license or an accounting license?

[00:03:32] ↗[00:03:32] Justin Paperny: So shortly after my time in prison, ... I found a mentor, a guy named Michael Santos. He'd served 26 years. He'd been in 22 years when I met him, and he just helped me understand how my decisions would impact the rest of my life. So guilt started by looking inward. It sounds a little cliche, looking inward, reading good literature, finding a mentor.

[00:03:52] ↗[00:03:52] Justin Paperny: And then finally at some point, looking into a prison mirror in the bathroom, as corny as it sounds, saying like, "I am responsible for my plight in life. There's no one to blame but me." And you can't really get on track until you embrace that, but it's humbling to realize, like, how far you have fallen, but you can't begin to build unless you recognize it's, it's all my fault.

[00:04:11] ↗[00:04:11] Jon: Yeah.

[00:04:11] ↗[00:04:11] Keith: Good morning, Jess, Johnny.

[00:04:14] ↗[00:04:14] Jon: Yeah, no, I, the, in the, the intro there was talking about your, the mentor in prison, how he was up way early, he was running, he was teaching. He was, he found, and this is kind of what I always go back to. I, I said if I could, what I, if I ma- if I can make it in prison, it's because I would find even out here every day I have this, as I call it, a loop.

[00:04:34] ↗[00:04:34] Jon: It's every day is I planned ways to, I make sure that at the end of the day I feel improved. And progress as a person is really key. And clearly that gentleman, you know, I would be pick- I get up at 3:00 here, I'd be getting up at 3:00 there. I would find a way to be improved every day. And then at that point, your, your surroundings become less important.

[00:04:56] ↗[00:04:56] Jon: And I think that, you know, when people kind of tend to realize that, that happiness comes from your choices, it comes from how you choose to live your life in this loop that we, that people call a day

[00:05:09] ↗[00:05:09] Justin Paperny: That was really well said. So you, you can live faithfully to your values in prison even though you're confined.

[00:05:15] ↗[00:05:15] Justin Paperny: And for me- Yeah ... learning from someone who is authentic and who had built a record. While I'm interviewing with you guys right now, he's getting ready to go speak in a penitentiary in Pennsylvania. He travels the country, in every BOP prison, influencing millions of people, from the penitentiary down to the camp, and he can do that because of what he did in prison.

[00:05:33] ↗[00:05:33] Justin Paperny: Waking at 2:00 or 3:00 o'clock in the morning, educating himself, building a record. I mean, he, he served eight years in the peniten- in the penitentiary in Atlanta. Then the last decade he served in a camp. So, like, our message at White Collar Advice or this nonprofit we support, Prison Professors, is, like, we're not gonna ask you to do what we haven't done.

[00:05:51] ↗[00:05:51] Justin Paperny: Which is, like, he helped me write a book in prison, Lessons From Prison. Another book, Ethics in Motion. The only way you overcome this conviction isn't by telling people, "My bad. I'm sorry. I'll never do it again." It's by building a record that you can defend over time, like a time-stamped timeline. And Michael had such authority in prison 'cause when I met him, he'd been doing it for 22 years.

[00:06:14] ↗[00:06:14] Justin Paperny: So when he speaks in the penitentiary, like he's there right now, the guys respect him. Not 'cause he served a long sentence, but because he, he did the work. That was very inspiring to me and I, I just wish- It's

[00:06:24] ↗[00:06:24] Jon: how he did his time, correct? It's not just that he did it.

[00:06:28] ↗[00:06:28] Justin Paperny: He lived with digne- yeah, he always said he wanted to emerge with his dignity intact.

[00:06:31] ↗[00:06:31] Justin Paperny: You would never know that he served a day in prison. With a, with a network, with resources, with opportunities to inspire and teach people. And it was frankly his idea in prison, we talk about White Collar Advice that helps people with resources prepare for sentencing in prison. It was his idea in prison to have this business.

[00:06:49] ↗[00:06:49] Justin Paperny: Because one day I'm in his cubicle, and I sound like a total fool. You know, I went to prison kind of fat, bloated, miserable. And then you live 50 yards from a track and pull-up bars, and you... It's hard to not wanna exercise all day and get in better shape. And then one day I'm in his cubicle showing off, like how many pull-ups I did, how many miles I ran.

[00:07:10] ↗[00:07:10] Justin Paperny: And he said, "Hey, dude, like, how much are people gonna pay you to do those pull-ups?" And I'm like, "Well, I don't think anyone's gonna pay me." And that's when it hit me, those early months in prison, I was just exercising all day, and I wasn't preparing for the hardest part, which is coming home with a felony conviction, without licenses- Wow

[00:07:27] ↗[00:07:27] Justin Paperny: owing a h- owing a half a million in restitution. And it really forced me to change my prison term and begin to write and document my experience through prison, all thanks to Michael.

[00:07:37] ↗[00:07:37] Keith: Wow. Justin preparing to hang out with myself and Jon Anderson this morning on Mornings in the Lab. He went to prison and he built an empire helping white-collar criminals.

[00:07:46] ↗[00:07:46] Keith: Justin, what also strikes me about your story, and, and I, and I... is that this, this thing here gets me Is that you paid 16 grand to a reputation management company to sup- to, to, to, to basically suppress that DOJ press release. And, and when you, when you were going through that, that's actually not denial.

[00:08:04] ↗[00:08:04] Keith: It's really much like it's organized denial. You're like, "Okay, I really gotta intentionally, you know, hide this and get rid of it." At what point in your journey, in your own mirror, did you admit to yourself that you're like, "Holy shit, man, I actually can't try to keep buying myself out of this truth"?

[00:08:20] ↗[00:08:20] Justin Paperny: Yeah, so that was an embarrassing moment.

[00:08:22] ↗[00:08:22] Justin Paperny: So when, when I paid for that press release to be removed, I'm s- I sold real estate for three years before I went to prison, and my fear was if someone saw it, they would never work with me. Yeah. And you're very vulnerable. Like-

[00:08:35] ↗[00:08:35] Keith: Yeah ...

[00:08:35] ↗[00:08:35] Justin Paperny: people, you're seeing a lot of this right now in the government where people are trying to sell access to a, a pardon through Trump and this administration.

[00:08:41] ↗[00:08:41] Justin Paperny: You know, for 100 or 200 to 300,000, give me money, I have access. And people are vulnerable. They don't wanna go to prison, and they'll pay for it, and they're being stolen from. So I was very vulnerable. I didn't wanna see it. And of course, it, it backfired, or actually worked against me in court, 'cause the government's like, "Here, you have a guy pretending it didn't happen, paying to pretend- Yeah

[00:09:00] ↗[00:09:00] Justin Paperny: it didn't happen." And then I embraced kind of that, this mantra that the more you talk about it, the more you address and own it, the, the easier it's going to be. So actually talking about the press release, talking about bad decisions- Yeah ... and then encouraging people to see me for the record I'm trying to build.

[00:09:17] ↗[00:09:17] Justin Paperny: But those press releases are, are devastating, and they're meant to deter people, and they want people to know, if you break the law, we're gonna use government resources to issue a release and embarrass you. And it wasn't until I went to prison that I realized it wasn't just more m- I joked I should write a book called How to Flush Money Down the Toilet as a Defendant.

[00:09:35] ↗[00:09:35] Justin Paperny: I'm the king. It, it isn't until you're in prison that you realize all of these bad decisions, they, they, they catch up to you. And thankfully, I was only 33, and I had time to do better. But it was a very difficult experience through my own making.

[00:09:49] ↗[00:09:49] Keith: So Justin, I-

[00:09:49] ↗[00:09:49] Jon: Sounds like, it just goes to show what you're willing to do or, or consciously able to do when you're in denial.

[00:09:56] ↗[00:09:56] Justin Paperny: I didn't wanna do the work. It was easier... I tell this to people who retain our team. I'll say, "It's one thing to scratch a check. It's another thing to actually do the work and build a record." I was a lazy defendant that would pull out a credit card to try to remove a press release. I didn't wanna do the work to build something on top of it.

[00:10:13] ↗[00:10:13] Justin Paperny: I was the guy that would give a big check to a lawyer, thinking they can keep me out of prison. I didn't really wanna demonstrate what it looked like to be sorry. I was the guy that would scratch a check for restitution. Here's 100,000, Judge Wilson, thinking it would keep me out of prison. But I was the defendant where the judge would say, "Sure, you gave money, but it was only to avoid prison.

[00:10:31] ↗[00:10:31] Justin Paperny: You truly aren't remorseful." Yeah. I mean, even lying to the... I do, have done a number of events with the FBI, training agents, and they have told me prior to a presentation at the FBI Academy, "Had Justin not lied to us when we interviewed him, he most likely wouldn't have been prosecuted. But why do you lie?"

[00:10:47] ↗[00:10:47] Justin Paperny: I'm ashamed. I'm embarrassed. I didn't want them to view me as a criminal. So, like, we want people to make better decisions, but instead they tend to compound them, and they just get more of what they want along... more of what they don't want- ... a longer sentence.

[00:11:01] ↗[00:11:01] Jon: It's like when somebody gives you a very, very insincere apology so that they can hopefully get out of trouble.

[00:11:07] ↗[00:11:07] Frankie and Tommy: Yeah,

[00:11:07] ↗[00:11:07] Jon: yes ... you know they're full of shit. Yeah. They're just trying to sidestep what's going on.

[00:11:12] ↗[00:11:12] Justin Paperny: I covered that yesterday with Law & Crime, that, that new Netflix documentary called The Crash, on that woman McKenzie who killed those two people. And she's in prison, she's had, you know, 60 pages of disciplinary infractions, and her parents are like, "Oh, she's sorry, she's remorseful."

[00:11:26] ↗[00:11:26] Justin Paperny: She's not. Those are throwaway words. There's no message or record of remorse. It's all about her, how her own life is falling apart, and it's part of the reason.

[00:11:36] ↗[00:11:36] Keith: Your humility is s- I gotta tell you, Justin, your humility is so welcoming. It is so striking. It is, it is, it is... It's freaking awesome, man. And, and I say that because I have to believe, Johnny, I gotta believe, Justin, you walk your life right now with zero baggage on your shoulders.

[00:11:53] ↗[00:11:53] Keith: Like, you are a free human being. Listen, we all, we all have our shit, and I get it, but for the most part, when I hear you speak, you're just like, "Yeah, I'm fucking embarrassed, I fucked up, made some mistakes, and I am owning it all." Like, you strike me as- Yeah ... a very humble, I-fucked-up human being. That's powerful, Michael.

[00:12:12] ↗[00:12:12] Keith: Justin.

[00:12:13] ↗[00:12:13] Justin Paperny: Well, that, that means a lot to me, you, you saying that. Thank you. I, I'm 51 now. I have two young kids. I've been home from prison for 17 years. I... People would probably tell you I'm stoic, a little quiet. I'm a total introvert and reserved. I could sit in my closet all day and work and read and be fine.

[00:12:27] ↗[00:12:27] Keith: But find- I'll be right there next to you.

[00:12:29] ↗[00:12:29] Justin Paperny: Yeah. But, but finding a mentor in literature really helped me. Like, when I have a few minutes, I'm reading, you know, a, a stoic book. I love the Ryan Holiday books, you know? Right thing, right- Yeah ... now. I'm trying to be a, I'm trying to be a- I

[00:12:39] ↗[00:12:39] Jon: have that book in your right hand.

[00:12:40] ↗[00:12:40] Justin Paperny: Yeah. I'm not gonna tell people... A big part of our message is, like, I'm not gonna ask you to do what we don't do. So I'm continuing to read literature. How does it, how does it help me? I'm writing every single day. I'm creating. I want people to know, like, my 18 months in prison was the easiest part of the experience, 'cause it's clearly defined.

[00:13:00] ↗[00:13:00] Justin Paperny: While you're waiting to go to sentencing, it's hard because- Oh ... you're in the land of the unknown. Oh my- You're just waiting to get sentenced. That's the hardest part and I, and I had so... I have so much regret over how I lived for that three years. So I will say, at times when I wanna revert back to prior behavior, I'll think, "Where did that get me?

[00:13:18] ↗[00:13:18] Justin Paperny: Standing for count." And then I just make the opposite decision.

[00:13:21] ↗[00:13:21] Keith: Well, so Jo- oh, you just said something. What, it's ... John, you know how good I am at paraphrasing what somebody says. But you said that- ... my prior behavior. So it's li- it's like your brain went back to this, "Oh, there's some self-sabotaging behavior that I'm running towards.

[00:13:37] ↗[00:13:37] Keith: I better stop it," Justin.

[00:13:41] ↗[00:13:41] Justin Paperny: Y- I, yes.

[00:13:41] ↗[00:13:41] Jon: Well, it, it sounds like he's one of the few people that actually uses the word regret for- Yeah ... rather than to wallow.

[00:13:49] ↗[00:13:49] Justin Paperny: Well, I recall ... Yes, that's a good way for people to make better decis- better decisions. The problem is people get used to the status quo. They get s- used to the numb, the numbness of this- Yeah

[00:13:59] ↗[00:13:59] Justin Paperny: and the pain- Yes. Yes ... where they begin to reason, like, "Nothing's coming my way anyway, I'm a criminal. Nothing's going to matter," so you get used to this life, and I was used to that for three years until I met Michael, who began to mentor and helped me understand there could be a better way. But as Michael would say, "It, it's not gonna be through happy talk and platitudes.

[00:14:16] ↗[00:14:16] Justin Paperny: You actually have to build incrementally, daily." The most impactful lesson in my life was the tortoise and the hare, right? Slow and steady wins, wins the race. And when I began to do that, I began to see how one page became five, became 10, and I began to build my way out of this terrible mess that I had created.

[00:14:36] ↗[00:14:36] Justin Paperny: Because w- we work primarily with white collar defendants, but we heavily support Prison Professor's Children's- ... Foundation. But I would argue most defendants are so overwhelmed, it's very difficult for them to begin recalibrating or the idea of starting over at 50 and 60. But others have done it. They're going to need to as well, because you're, the consequences of a conviction are so, so severe, and they're supposed to be.

[00:15:00] ↗[00:15:00] Keith: Wow. Justin, preparing myself, Jon-

[00:15:02] ↗[00:15:02] Jon: Real quick, real quick. Yeah. Brother, forgive me. Hold up your coffee cup for me. Oh. My man's drinking out of a measuring cup. I fucking love that.

[00:15:09] ↗[00:15:09] Justin Paperny: No, I'm a, I'm a Trojan. I was a- I thought that was a

[00:15:11] ↗[00:15:11] Jon: measuring cup ... I

[00:15:12] ↗[00:15:12] Justin Paperny: was a for- I'm a big, I'm a big Trojan. I was a former baseball player at USC, and my Trojans actually won last night.

[00:15:17] ↗[00:15:17] Justin Paperny: They're going to the Super Regionals in North Carolina, so I was up late watching them like- I thought,

[00:15:20] ↗[00:15:20] Jon: because I could see through it and I saw the red, I was like, "My man's drinking out of a measuring cup."

[00:15:24] ↗[00:15:24] Justin Paperny: Yeah.

[00:15:24] ↗[00:15:24] Jon: That's fucking savage.

[00:15:26] ↗[00:15:26] Justin Paperny: I got my cup. I'm a proud Trojan.

[00:15:27] ↗[00:15:27] Keith: Dude, I'm loving this, man. Justin, what does, what does the word respect mean in prison, and how does one earn it?

[00:15:37] ↗[00:15:37] Justin Paperny: So there's a ver- myriad definitions of, of respect. I, some respect is you just mind your own business. Yes. You lay low. You don't offer unsolicited advice. respect for a white collar guy like me could simply be you're doing your job, which is surprising. You shouldn't be rewarded for doing your job, but it's surprising how many guys respected me for doing the job I was supposed to do or laying low.

[00:16:00] ↗[00:16:00] Justin Paperny: I think they respected that I got up at 3:00 or 4:00 in the morning. I would work with Michael. I would go run eight or 10 miles on the track. I would do my prison job, pots and pans. Then I would work and write, all afternoon into the evening. I'd go to bed at 7:00. I never complained. I didn't offer unsolicited, advice.

[00:16:17] ↗[00:16:17] Justin Paperny: I learned from men around me. I found a sense of perspective, and I tell people because they respected me when I made mistakes, and I did, I think some of the longer term prisoners took it easy on me. For example, a mistake I made, I would tend to talk too loudly on the phone. They'd be like, "Dude, y- s- everyone can hear you.

[00:16:35] ↗[00:16:35] Justin Paperny: Be quiet." Oh. One time while running back to count, I used the restroom. I urinated. I didn't wash my hands, 'cause if you don't get back for count, you're in trouble. And a long-term prisoner's like, "Hey, man, like, we touch the, the phone here with our hands." And I'm like, "I made a mistake. I'm sorry." But they didn't give me a difficult time- Oh

[00:16:51] ↗[00:16:51] Justin Paperny: because they could see that I was minding my own business. I didn't get into petty gossip. I didn't complain. I didn't speak to guards, which is a huge no-no in prison. Then there, I think there's a different sort of respect for someone like Michael Santos, who endured 22 years, eventually 25 in prison through brutal circumstances, overcoming and building regardless.

[00:17:13] ↗[00:17:13] Justin Paperny: So for me, it was minding my own business, avoiding the gossip, and making sure I didn't succumb to the inevitable boredom, which is the highest value inside of a prison camp. The boredom will drive some men insane

[00:17:27] ↗[00:17:27] Keith: I kind of... Yeah, the boredom will drive some men insane. Johnny?

[00:17:30] ↗[00:17:30] Jon: Well, and that, and that comes down to the way it sounds like you, you set up your loop.

[00:17:35] ↗[00:17:35] Jon: You were up. Yeah. Yes. You did this, you did that. Yes. And then you finished your day, most importantly, with some sort of growth. You know, it leaves a man content. He can sleep, get up looking forward to doing it again tomorrow.

[00:17:49] ↗[00:17:49] Justin Paperny: See, what you guys do is what I strive to do every day in prison. By filming this right now, you have some asset that becomes part of your asset library or catalog.

[00:17:56] ↗[00:17:56] Justin Paperny: Someone may see it, they may invest in you. It brings more people to your community. This is an asset. We encourage people going through the criminal justice system, if you've just been indicted, you're going to prison, you're home from prison, you too need to create some asset that shows who you are, what you've learned, how you could be of value to someone.

[00:18:15] ↗[00:18:15] Justin Paperny: So by creating an asset every day with Michael, a blog that eventually became a book, when I shook hands with my probation officer, Isaiah Murrow, in the halfway house in Hollywood, California, I wasn't even telling him what I wanted to do. "Hey, I wanna go speak to businesses. I wanna work with my colleague."

[00:18:29] ↗[00:18:29] Justin Paperny: You were showing him. He saw the assets that I had built. Holy smoke. I had a record

[00:18:34] ↗[00:18:34] Keith: of success. That... So it's f- that's the... Right. That's a nugget. 'Cause what drives me nuts is the I want is and the I'm gonna's. "Oh, I wanna do this. I'm gonna do this." And, and you're sitting there going, "I can go try to do pull-ups and be fitness f- f- a fitness guy for 20...

[00:18:48] ↗[00:18:48] Keith: And get a... Be- with be- being fit, or I can create something which shows myself, shows the world that I've ... that I'm actually you know, humble. You, you know, I- I'm moving forward. I've... I'm working on my restitution for myself. Here's who I am.

[00:19:02] ↗[00:19:02] Justin Paperny: There is no other way. But it is- I'm being

[00:19:04] ↗[00:19:04] Jon: clear. If anyone's in crime- If you strip this away and you go back in time, you see all of the great men did exactly what he's talking about.

[00:19:11] ↗[00:19:11] Jon: Yes. It's the fuck- It's our cur- As the world gets more lazy, it just becomes harder to find these people.

[00:19:18] ↗[00:19:18] Justin Paperny: Well, it gets even harder now in the age of AI. So it- we encourage people to put yourself in the shoes of, like, a judge. What do they hear? Yes. Like, I'm gonna do a live vi- I'm gonna do a live video today showing clips of interviews we've done with judges.

[00:19:32] ↗[00:19:32] Justin Paperny: Yeah. And they are skeptical. They think we say one thing and do another. Prosecutors think we... They think we're criminals. Yes. How do you over- how do you overcome that? It isn't by, "I'm sorry, I'll never do it again." You build a record. But with AI, you can prompt ChatGPT to say, "Write a paper as if I have a, a PhD from Harvard," and it's gonna produce something.

[00:19:50] ↗[00:19:50] Justin Paperny: The problem is you don't have the knowledge. You haven't done the work, and it might fool some people. It ain't gonna fool a judge. It ain't gonna fool a probation officer. Yeah. The only thing that works is, "Here's what I did when I got into trouble. Here's what I did last week. Here's a book I read. Here's $100, $500 I set aside towards my victims, 'cause the primary focus here is not me, it's victims that I created.

[00:20:12] ↗[00:20:12] Justin Paperny: Here's how I'm paying restitution." AI can't do... It cannot replace the work, the body of work you need to create over time, and unfortunately, too many defendants don't embrace that, and it's why they'll call me after sentencing and say, "Oh my God, I was expecting 18 months. I got three years. The judge filleted me.

[00:20:30] ↗[00:20:30] Justin Paperny: What do I do?" And I look at everything they did leading up to sentencing and I'm like, "You didn't do any work." It's what you

[00:20:35] ↗[00:20:35] Jon: didn't do, you dumb son of a

[00:20:36] ↗[00:20:36] Justin Paperny: bitch. Yes. That's correct. There's no, there's no sh- it's all cliches. There are no shortcuts. These people are incredibly cynical, and to not embrace that cynicism means you're naive.

[00:20:47] ↗[00:20:47] Justin Paperny: It's like believing, you know, tobacco companies really don't want you to smoke cigarettes- ... 'cause it's not good for you. You got... It's... doesn't make any sense.

[00:20:54] ↗[00:20:54] Jon: Well, I mean, 99 out of 100 people that come into that courtroom, they're, they're not displaying what you're displaying. The judge's job is to look through all the bullshit to find out if they're actually doing what you're describing.

[00:21:06] ↗[00:21:06] Jon: So of course. Yeah. I mean, it's... I mean, Jesus Christ, it's like if you, if you know that you're gonna have a conversation with someone that doesn't believe you, your number one goal- Yeah ... is to figure out how to get them to believe you, and your words don't mean shit. It's what have you done?

[00:21:20] ↗[00:21:20] Keith: Well, at the end of the day, man, like, so at the end of the day, that judge over there is a human being, and at the end of the day, that person's a human being.

[00:21:28] ↗[00:21:28] Keith: And in society, I think at the end of the day, all we want to do is know that, A, you've made a mistake. "Here's what I've done. I'm trying to hold myself accountable, and I'm sorry, and I'm showing you what I've done." That's it. Like, you don't have to even think about it that way, right? The judge just wants to know that you as a human are gonna try to contribute to society in a positive way, Justin.

[00:21:47] ↗[00:21:47] Justin Paperny: I love what... This, Jon said something so profound, 99 people. Years ago, Michael Santos sent me this great book called The Purple Cow by Seth Godin, and he's like, "People in our community need to be the purple cow." You drive down the side of the road- Yeah ... you see 100 cows, 99 of them are brown. You don't remember.

[00:22:03] ↗[00:22:03] Justin Paperny: If one of them is purple- ... you remember the purple cow.

[00:22:06] ↗[00:22:06] Keith: Yep.

[00:22:06] ↗[00:22:06] Justin Paperny: You've got to be the purple cow by going through the system. People think I paid... I avoided problems in prison, or I had a job. They think compliance or doing the bare minimum is extraordinary and compelling. It is not. It- to Jon's point, that's what the 99 people do.

[00:22:20] ↗[00:22:20] Frankie and Tommy: Yes.

[00:22:20] ↗[00:22:20] Justin Paperny: How do you stand out? Well, you've got to wake early, you've got to create, you've got to identify with victims, you've got to look for work. Even, you speak about humility, and I'm grateful of you saying that. And when you talk about humility, that tends to mean you don't have it. But here's an example.

[00:22:32] ↗[00:22:32] Justin Paperny: When I came home from prison, I picked up phones for several months, and it was a law-abiding wage. Many defendants traversing the system, if you're a doctor, a lawyer, a banker, it's hard to stido- start over doing Ur- Uber or delivering food for DoorDash or picking up phones. But I cold walked into law offices in downtown peddling my book with hopes they would take it and give it to a c- I, my highest value is freedom and not encumbering my parents' retirement, frankly, and actually paying back the half a million bucks.

[00:23:00] ↗[00:23:00] Justin Paperny: So you're willing to do things, and I believed in what I was doing. I thought I could help people. So we want purple to... We want people to be that purple cow, to stand out. That's the only way you get more of what you want, shorter sentence, earlier release, not working

[00:23:14] ↗[00:23:14] Jon: for other people half

[00:23:14] ↗[00:23:14] Justin Paperny: the time. Well,

[00:23:14] ↗[00:23:14] Jon: and brother, forgive me for interrupting.

[00:23:16] ↗[00:23:16] Jon: That, that purple cow, being the purple cow out here, it's the same fucking formula, for Christ's sake.

[00:23:22] ↗[00:23:22] Frankie and Tommy: Same formula.

[00:23:23] ↗[00:23:23] Jon: Yes, it is. Jesus Christ, it's not like it's... And, and that's the, the... I mean, it's like how to... If, if you're gonna lead... It's, it's like as a parent, your kids don't give a shit what you say. They watch what you do.

[00:23:36] ↗[00:23:36] Jon: And so does society, so does that judge. You want to be the purple cow, don't fucking talk about it. Go do it.

[00:23:43] ↗[00:23:43] Keith: And that's a great, and that's a great segue, Jon, 'cause I wanted to ask Justin this as we're working towards wrapping up with Justin. Justin, you said you have kids, and I cannot imagine- what it was like being a father before going into your journey, coming out of your journey, and then those, all those years in between it all.

[00:24:02] ↗[00:24:02] Keith: I just, I- maybe that's a whole other conversation, but brother, as a dad, I c- I, I really can't imagine h- how you went through that.

[00:24:09] ↗[00:24:09] Justin Paperny: Well, I was very fortunate because most of the people in our community go to prison with children. So when I tell people my experience was easier, I was 33, I, I didn't have a wife or children.

[00:24:19] ↗[00:24:19] Justin Paperny: But it's something when I came home and I began to, to date, I actually met my wife Sandra on a dating website. Okay. And I remember disclosing on the website that I had been to prison, and the administrator said, "Remove it." Dude, that's- And I'm like, "I'm just, I'm just trying to be transparent that I went to prison.

[00:24:32] ↗[00:24:32] Justin Paperny: I'm not joking." I think a woman... I, if m- I would want my daughter to know if she's dating some dude out of jail. Wow. So I didn't remove it.

[00:24:39] ↗[00:24:39] Keith: Wow.

[00:24:39] ↗[00:24:39] Justin Paperny: And, and then I... But when we eventually married and, and had children, like, my daughter's 11 now and we go to Dodger games together, we're very close, but she knows that I went to prison, and they ask questions or they, they wanna know more about the experience and, and how it happened.

[00:24:54] ↗[00:24:54] Justin Paperny: And there is a, a kind of a stigma that will follow, that will follow for them. And I, I know if you were to interview Matt, you know, Matt has five children, and he describes his five-year-old son Kingston visiting him in prison, you know, and he's hanging onto his legs at the end of the visit and, and doesn't want the visit to end, to, to end.

[00:25:12] ↗[00:25:12] Justin Paperny: So prison's incredibly difficult, especially if you have children. And that's why I tell people that the hardest part of the punishment isn't for the prisoner, it's for the family who suffers more.

[00:25:22] ↗[00:25:22] Jon: Wow.

[00:25:23] ↗[00:25:23] Keith: Johnny, some closing words for Justin?

[00:25:27] ↗[00:25:27] Jon: Amazing conversation, brother. You know, and I, and I think that, I mean, obviously when it comes right down to it, I think one of the most helpful things for people to see in this is your purple cow. You, you gotta be the purple cow wherever the fuck you are.

[00:25:42] ↗[00:25:42] Keith: Yeah.

[00:25:42] ↗[00:25:42] Justin Paperny: Yeah.

[00:25:43] ↗[00:25:43] Keith: Yeah. Justin?

[00:25:44] ↗[00:25:44] Justin Paperny: It's d- it's, it's, it's m- it's as Michael Santos wrote in Lessons From Prison, this book that I wrote with him 17, 18 years ago, "It's slow and steady wins the race."

[00:25:54] ↗[00:25:54] Justin Paperny: Too many defendants or people in crisis, they want it all back at one time, the money, the reputation, the cars, the income, the status. It's so overwhelming you can't even begin. Michael helped me understand what can I do in the next day? If the next day is too overwhelming, the next 20 minutes, the next 10 minutes.

[00:26:10] ↗[00:26:10] Justin Paperny: And it starts with cr- exactly as you just did, as you do every single day. You have created something that doesn't exist. People need to create something that doesn't exist and build on it over a sustained period of time, and then you wake up and you've got a library you can defend and share with your family for decades to come.

[00:26:29] ↗[00:26:29] Justin Paperny: Even if it doesn't get you a shorter sentence, you still build, build, build because this is- Well, yeah.

[00:26:34] ↗[00:26:34] Jon: Yeah It's your self-development.

[00:26:36] ↗[00:26:36] Keith: Yes.

[00:26:37] ↗[00:26:37] Justin Paperny: Yes, that- Nobody

[00:26:38] ↗[00:26:38] Jon: can take that away from you. You

[00:26:39] ↗[00:26:39] Justin Paperny: know, you can, Nobody can take, nobody can take away if you learn to tell your story without blaming or excusing.

[00:26:44] ↗[00:26:44] Justin Paperny: You've got to own it. This is... I admire what you guys do, and I'm, I'm really thankful to have the opportunity to, to speak with you guys.

[00:26:51] ↗[00:26:51] Keith: Dude, I, I gotta be honest here. Coming up in a couple minutes, we've got Brianna Bass joining us, the desire gap, what m- what men really want in bed. We're gonna have that conversation, myself, Jon, and, and Br- and Brianna Bass.

[00:27:01] ↗[00:27:01] Keith: but before we do that, a couple of quick, quick things from me. Justin, we have a, a resident, a bullshit professor in our lab. He joins us every single Friday. His name's Dr. John Petrocelli. He's a professor of bullshit studies down in the Caribbean. A real

[00:27:12] ↗[00:27:12] Jon: professor. A real professor.

[00:27:13] ↗[00:27:13] Keith: Like, like he, he's

[00:27:14] ↗[00:27:14] Jon: at a fucking institution, not just a, a-

[00:27:16] ↗[00:27:16] Keith: No

[00:27:16] ↗[00:27:16] Jon: handle on social media.

[00:27:18] ↗[00:27:18] Keith: Yeah, like a solid dude. He's educated. He's here every Friday dropping great conversation, and he's dropped a comment. He's like, "I've got Justin coming in with the lowest BS index score, A+." But Johnny, more importantly, somewhere along the way, Kai put the image up, Justin and John Petrocelli have been separated at birth.

[00:27:35] ↗[00:27:35] Keith: L- l- look at this image. Johnny, check this out. Like, look at these two side by side. They're actually the same person. They're actually the same person. Justin and John. Justin, I invite you to meet John. John, meet Justin over on LinkedIn. On LinkedIn. you guys can go connect on LinkedIn. And Justin, I just wanna say this from me to you personally, man.

[00:27:50] ↗[00:27:50] Keith: like I, I have a... I'm gonna use the L word. Man, I, I got a lot of love for you as a human being. I, I'm really, I'm really taken aback by your humility, your responsibility, your accountability, the simple things that you said that so many people that I u- I use, I like to use the term "early" that are sitting in the stands, the 99% wondering how to get on stage.

[00:28:10] ↗[00:28:10] Keith: And you just kind of, you just said it. It's not rocket science. Build, build, build some assets. Show the world how different you are

[00:28:16] ↗[00:28:16] Justin Paperny: I appreciate you saying that very much. Can you give me 30 seconds to say one more thing that'll help?

[00:28:22] ↗[00:28:22] Keith: Please.

[00:28:22] ↗[00:28:22] Justin Paperny: Yeah, please. Please. You have M- you have M&M behind, you have M&M behind you in your office.

[00:28:26] ↗[00:28:26] Keith: I

[00:28:26] ↗[00:28:26] Justin Paperny: do. If anyone's made a bad decision, here's what helped me. You remember the m- the end of the movie 8 Mile with the rap scene- Yes ... and he takes the microphone, it's kind of, it's covered a lot in sales, where he says, "You know, I am white trash." Yes, yes. "He did shoot himself in the leg. I do live with my mom in the trailer."

[00:28:40] ↗[00:28:40] Justin Paperny: He took all of the words out of their mouth, so I encourage people, if you've made bad decisions, don't suppress it as I did stupidly by paying money. We're human beings. We make bad decisions. Talk about what you did, what you've learned, and how you'll do better moving forward. People will embrace and respect that message.

[00:28:54] ↗[00:28:54] Justin Paperny: Yeah. You cannot pretend it didn't happen. Take the words out of their mouth.

[00:28:59] ↗[00:28:59] Keith: Wow. Wow. I, I, I can't even f- I can't follow that up. Justin Paperny, myself and Jon Anderson, Sophia Grant. Mornings in the Lab with Keith, Jon, and friends. we've got comments from, Cheryl saying, "Agreed, Petro. Beautiful guest.

[00:29:10] ↗[00:29:10] Keith: Thanks for being here, Justin." And of course, our very own Mike Sullivan says, "Very good guest. Adding his book to my reading list." Hey, how can folks get your book, connect with you, and find you, Justin, before we let you go?

[00:29:19] ↗[00:29:19] Justin Paperny: It's all, it's all free if people go to whitecollaradvice.com. Everything there is, is free, including the books.

[00:29:25] ↗[00:29:25] Justin Paperny: I, White Collar Advice on YouTube. I produce a lot of, content around sentencing and prison lessons that I've learned. So I would say White Collar Advice YouTube is the best way to get content that our team creates.

[00:29:37] ↗[00:29:37] Keith: Awesome. So Justin, we have a sex relationship expert on our show. Her name's Brianna Bass, coming up.

[00:29:42] ↗[00:29:42] Keith: We have a bullshit professor on our show on Fridays. He's here every Friday. I'd like to think, Johnny, we now have the ultimate white collar prison expert that when we need somebody who's like, "I've got in trouble," we're bringing Justin on the show to say- Wow ... "Hey, here's what you gotta do to get out of prison."

[00:29:56] ↗[00:29:56] Keith: And all you gotta do, Johnny, is actually go to work. There's no rocket science. There's no secret sauce. It's just, meet a guy like Michael Santos, who clearly, Justin, changed your life.

[00:30:05] ↗[00:30:05] Justin Paperny: He changed my life. You need a mentor and a truth teller, and you have to be willing to have difficult conversations and do the work on days you don't want to.

[00:30:13] ↗[00:30:13] Keith: Oh. Justin Paperny, myself, and Jon Anderson on Mornings in the Lab with Keith, Jon, and friends. Thank you, Justin. Have a good day, brother.

[00:30:19] ↗[00:30:19] Justin Paperny: Thanks, bub. Thank

[00:30:20] ↗[00:30:20] Keith: you, brother. Awesome.

Appeared in