John Petrocelli: the conversation
Mornings in the Lab · Center Stage · Interview transcript
Transcribed from the recorded guest conversation. Automatic transcription may contain errors. Timestamps refer to the source recording or segment.
[00:15:52] ↗[00:15:52] Keith: Alright. Alright. Alright. There he is. Dr. Jon Petra, professor of psychology at Wake Forest, internationally recognized for his research into communication, persuasion, and yes bullshit.
[00:16:05] ↗[00:16:05] Keith: As the director of the Bullshit Studies Lab, that's actually on the actual door, apparently Jon investigates why we fall for misleading claims and how to, he's gonna be busy in the world of ai bullshit and how to outsmart them with evidence-based thinking. The guy's published over 50 scientific papers, an associate editor of two top journals, and his book, Jonny Marty, A Life-Changing Science of Detecting Bullshit.
[00:16:29] ↗[00:16:29] Keith: Fun fact. Jon's core syllabus is probably the only one that makes mums blush. Let's welcome him to the stage, doctor Jon Petro Sally, what's going on, Jon? What's up brother? Hey, thanks. Going on for having me guys. How are you pal? Are you joining us from today? Jon?
[00:16:44] ↗[00:16:44] John V Petrocelli: I'm in Winston-Salem. Oh, Winston Sale Massachusetts.
[00:16:49] ↗[00:16:49] John V Petrocelli: Wake Forest.
[00:16:49] ↗[00:16:49] marty: Wake Forest. North Carolina. North Carolina. Okay, thanks.
[00:16:52] ↗[00:16:52] Jon Andersen: Thanks
[00:16:52] ↗[00:16:52] marty: for listening. You're a
[00:16:52] ↗[00:16:52] Jon Andersen: young looking doctor, brother.
[00:16:57] ↗[00:16:57] John V Petrocelli: I'm 50. Are you really? Dude? Yeah. You don't
[00:17:00] ↗[00:17:00] Jon Andersen: look 50 at all. Holy shit. I was, I would've said you were your Yeah, I was gonna say, I would've said you were in your, like your thirties. Holy shit. Dude.
[00:17:09] ↗[00:17:09] John V Petrocelli: I take, if I take this hat off, you'll see that
[00:17:12] ↗[00:17:12] Keith: Jonny, I was giving him 38 40. Man. No, there's no,
[00:17:14] ↗[00:17:14] Jon Andersen: yeah, I was, there was, I was thinking 35 at the lowest, not 40.
[00:17:20] ↗[00:17:20] Keith: Dude, you what? So are you, before we get into the secret, like what's the secrets man? Is it sleek? Is it water? Is it good light? Is it good? Botox? What's the secret Petrocelli?
[00:17:31] ↗[00:17:31] John V Petrocelli: Not sure exactly what the secret is, but I the last 12 years I have been doing bootcamp, exercise, bootcamp workouts in the mornings.
[00:17:41] ↗[00:17:41] Keith: Yeah.
[00:17:41] ↗[00:17:41] John V Petrocelli: Five 30, about three or five, three to five days a week.
[00:17:45] ↗[00:17:45] Keith: Yeah.
[00:17:46] ↗[00:17:46] John V Petrocelli: And speaking, you know, speaking of bullshit, I I think bullshitted myself for a long time I thought I hated exercise. Oh, I thought I hated exercise. You know, I never wanted to do any exercise. But I got roped into this. This morning workout, military kind of boot camp free fitness fellowship, faith group known as F three.
[00:18:11] ↗[00:18:11] John V Petrocelli: I was roped into that about 12 years ago. And I discovered, I actually enjoy exercise if it's, you know,
[00:18:18] ↗[00:18:18] Keith: you know,
[00:18:18] ↗[00:18:18] John V Petrocelli: it's a group of men, kind of, pushing each other and, yeah. Yeah, absolutely.
[00:18:23] ↗[00:18:23] Jon Andersen: It's that adversity. Overcome that adversity every day. Brother, forgive me.
[00:18:28] ↗[00:18:28] Jon Andersen: You often take that hat off. Do it make me feel better. Lean in a little bit. Okay. I, now I feel better now that, that helps a little bit. Shit.
[00:18:39] ↗[00:18:39] Intro: Alright, Jon, your turn.
[00:18:42] ↗[00:18:42] Keith: See
[00:18:42] ↗[00:18:42] Jon Andersen: I was that way a long time ago. I took it down to the skin. Fuck, 20 years ago.
[00:18:50] ↗[00:18:50] Keith: You know what I love about this, Jon, is that Dr. Petrocelli is that we had this conversation yesterday. We had this conversation yesterday with me, AJ and Jon, which was, you know, sometimes we would just have to find what we enjoy to work out. Right. Yeah. And it doesn't yeah. Have to go mean I gotta go push weights or you know, Martin like shooting, Hey Marty didn't like shooting basketball.
[00:19:11] ↗[00:19:11] Keith: Is that, Hey, you do it Marty. Like that. Marty likes shooting basketball.
[00:19:14] ↗[00:19:14] marty: That's awful.
[00:19:14] ↗[00:19:14] Keith: That's, yeah. Yeah. The que the question is simple. What movement do you enjoy? And it's funny how you just, so you discuss, so I wanna go back to this moment. 'cause there's a lot of dudes and I'm gonna lean into this brother.
[00:19:25] ↗[00:19:25] Keith: There's a lot of dudes that think they don't like working out. And you're like, I didn't think I did. But then all of a sudden I did. Was it the social aspect of it? Was it your heart rate getting up? Was it you losing weight? Was it maybe your wife decided to have more sex with you?
[00:19:37] ↗[00:19:37] Keith: Like, what was that? It's like, yeah, I kind of enjoy this and I'm being serious, Jon.
[00:19:41] ↗[00:19:41] John V Petrocelli: Yeah. I do think the social part is a major aspect of it. Because I tried to do yeah the workouts myself. And that usually lasts maybe like two or three weeks. Yes. Consistency. Yes. But then when you know that, okay, there's about a dozen other guys that that you might see, you know, in the morning and they're there.
[00:20:02] ↗[00:20:02] John V Petrocelli: If you miss a workout, you know, you kind of feel it all day and you kind of feel guilty or yes, you you know, it's something that you miss. But I can tell you the the career of a professor too is, it never stops. It's mu it's much more than 40 hours a week. I've always got research projects.
[00:20:23] ↗[00:20:23] John V Petrocelli: Work that I'm working on and it's just busy because you're busy and there's really no time for friends. But then I found that, you know, at five 30 for a 45 minute workout, five 30 in the mornings that, that's my friend time. And I think that is a major part of what pulls in and this group actually is it's gone global.
[00:20:44] ↗[00:20:44] John V Petrocelli: It's every, probably every nook and cranny of the of the world that's you know, it's got a park neighborhood or church or something. Anything is it's always out in the big green gym we call it. And it's, you know, rain or shine or rain or gloom.
[00:21:00] ↗[00:21:00] Keith: Yeah. Yeah.
[00:21:02] ↗[00:21:02] John V Petrocelli: And yeah, I think it's, but I, yeah, I do think the social piece is a major part of that I think kept me coming.
[00:21:09] ↗[00:21:09] Keith: That's awesome. And you still get after it today, like, were you up out this morning? Oh yeah. Were you before? Yeah. Or were you going out after? Yeah.
[00:21:15] ↗[00:21:15] John V Petrocelli: Well, and I thought that when I first started I had been running for about five years beforehand, about 15 or 20 miles a week.
[00:21:23] ↗[00:21:23] Keith: Yeah.
[00:21:24] ↗[00:21:24] John V Petrocelli: So I thought I was in really good shape. Yeah. And then the first workout I found out right away that I wasn't and I could do maybe like two. Well,
[00:21:33] ↗[00:21:33] Jon Andersen: there's different types of shape for different types of activity. You know, you were in good shape for running, you know, but whatever you're doing at this workout place is a different discipline, you know?
[00:21:42] ↗[00:21:42] Jon Andersen: Yeah.
[00:21:42] ↗[00:21:42] Keith: Is that like a rectangular or square Jonny or a circle or round? Is that what you're talking about? Being like, is that what you mean? What's that? Yeah. Bad dad joke. Sorry. That was awful. Yeah, I did.
[00:21:52] ↗[00:21:52] Jon Andersen: That was so fucking bad. I couldn't even, normally I run with your shitty stuff. I couldn't even tell what that was, dude.
[00:21:58] ↗[00:21:58] Keith: Where I got out with Don Petra telling this morning, joining us from North Carolina. Thanks Marty for giving me the geography lesson this morning. So I, so obviously the bullshit stuff is, you know, it's hot. It's. Title grabbing, it's spotlight, grabbing, it's headline grabbing. But I wanna get serious with you about it.
[00:22:15] ↗[00:22:15] Keith: How did you end up and work your way into really kind of owning that narrative, building a business around this idea of beating bullshit and calling out bullshit?
[00:22:25] ↗[00:22:25] John V Petrocelli: Yeah. Well, it's, it was rather simple. I had read a couple of papers, primarily Harry Frankfurt's seminal paper 1986, which was turned into probably the bestselling book in philosophy probably the bestselling book of all time in philosophy.
[00:22:42] ↗[00:22:42] John V Petrocelli: And it was called On Bullshit. And here I am a social psychologist, so that means I, I use science to study everyday social behavior. Yes. And how social situations, the self other people influence, thoughts, feelings, and behaviors. Okay. And I can't think of a more social behavior than communication.
[00:23:07] ↗[00:23:07] Intro: Yes.
[00:23:08] ↗[00:23:08] John V Petrocelli: And for whatever reason this particular topic has had at the time, escaped. Empirical investigation. And I thought, you know, I'm a social psychologist. I don't know why people bullshit. I don't know what increases the likelihood, what, you know, what are the antec, the causes of it? What are the consequences of it?
[00:23:28] ↗[00:23:28] John V Petrocelli: Can it be used for good or bad? I knew nothing about it because there was nothing in the literature. So about 2015, I started conducting experiments just to figure out, okay, well under what conditions do people bullshit? And under what? Under what? Under what conditions do people refrain from bullshitting?
[00:23:47] ↗[00:23:47] John V Petrocelli: You know, so, so we manipulate these, the conditions. It turns out that Harry Frankfurt was primarily correct in his theorizing that people will do it when it's relatively easy to get away with. You know, when the audience doesn't know better you're not, isn't
[00:24:07] ↗[00:24:07] Jon Andersen: that humans in general, they're gonna do anything when it's easy?
[00:24:10] ↗[00:24:10] Jon Andersen: Definitely human nature.
[00:24:11] ↗[00:24:11] John V Petrocelli: Yeah. When it's easy. And unfortunately when people feel obligated to share an opinion about something. Which is pretty much all of the time. So most people do not have the same amount of knowledge to match the obligation. So when the obligation to share an opinion or belief about something exceeds actual knowledge about the topic, people tend to bullshit.
[00:24:39] ↗[00:24:39] John V Petrocelli: And when you put those two things together, sort of the obligation to share, and it's kind of easy to get away with, then the gloves are really off and people just go to town, especially if others have signaled within a conversation that, that it's okay. And it's, and bullshit is acceptable in this context.
[00:24:57] ↗[00:24:57] Keith: So it's not lost upon me. We're hanging out with Dr. Jon Prera, Sally, the professor of psychology at Wake Forest. It's not lost upon me that right now in this current state, regardless of where your politics fall, Petra, Sally, that we have an awesome bullshitter right now leading the world. And and the guy's just bullshitting left and right, just one day bullshit here.
[00:25:16] ↗[00:25:16] Keith: One day, the bullshit here. And then we have this Epstein scandal in front of all of us right now. And he's trying to escape the bullshit of that. So in many ways was as you observe society and observe the politics of the world today, it must be fascinating for you to go to work and fascinating for you to free to conduct your work because you can literally, you have a case study every single day around bullshit.
[00:25:37] ↗[00:25:37] Keith: Am I correct? Yeah.
[00:25:38] ↗[00:25:38] John V Petrocelli: Well, quite frankly, it's overwhelming because there's just too much of it. And Yes. And what we find too in, in our studies is we have a lot methods for detecting bullshit, but the, yeah, what is
[00:25:50] ↗[00:25:50] Jon Andersen: That's in the, like, what are the top three methods for detecting that?
[00:25:53] ↗[00:25:53] Jon Andersen: Somebody's full of shit?
[00:25:54] ↗[00:25:54] John V Petrocelli: Yes. Oh actually, Jon your random, or not random, but you're peppering people with questions quickly is actually a primary method. So you have to ask questions because if you identify the motives of the communicator. So the communi, the bullshitter doesn't care about the truth.
[00:26:15] ↗[00:26:15] John V Petrocelli: They're communicating something without any regard for truth, genuine evidence, established knowledge, which is different from lying. Because typically the liar actually knows the truth and they're remembering the truth because they want to something. This is,
[00:26:34] ↗[00:26:34] Jon Andersen: man, this is that's actually really cool you, is that most people probably wouldn't know the difference between the two.
[00:26:39] ↗[00:26:39] Jon Andersen: Most people, I, I couldn't have defined it like you just did. I would've known that they were in the same family, but I wouldn't have known how to describe the difference.
[00:26:47] ↗[00:26:47] John V Petrocelli: Yes. And you'll hear people say like, don't bullshit me. What they're really saying is don't lie to me. So it's often confused for lying.
[00:26:55] ↗[00:26:55] John V Petrocelli: But yeah. In some, in, in some cases, by accident, just by chance, bullshitters will say something that's actually correct, but even they wouldn't know it because they're not paying any attention. They don't have any care. For truth, genuine evidence. Established knowledge.
[00:27:13] ↗[00:27:13] Jon Andersen: So, brother, go back to the, you said something about questions.
[00:27:16] ↗[00:27:16] Jon Andersen: I didn't quite follow that. Yes. Pepper with questions. What was that?
[00:27:19] ↗[00:27:19] John V Petrocelli: Yes. Well, you get asked questions that get at the heart of the motivation of the, so
[00:27:24] ↗[00:27:24] Jon Andersen: The non bullshitter the one that's trying to detect the bullshitter should start peppering questions.
[00:27:28] ↗[00:27:28] John V Petrocelli: Yes. And I mean, you can ask even if you don't have the opportunity to ask questions, you can say, well, well, you know, who is this person?
[00:27:36] ↗[00:27:36] John V Petrocelli: What is their expertise? What is their agenda? What are they trying to sell me? If you can communicate with the potential bullshitter you, the best questions to ask are like, what exactly are you saying? What identify what the claim actually is. Yeah. And what often happens is bullshitters will kind of take a few back steps and kind of.
[00:27:58] ↗[00:27:58] John V Petrocelli: Start to clean up
[00:28:00] ↗[00:28:00] Keith: claim. Yeah. Yeah.
[00:28:01] ↗[00:28:01] John V Petrocelli: Because they're not willing to say, okay, well I'm not going that far with a claim. And so it's a great tactic because they already start exposing you to less bullshit. Yeah. Dude,
[00:28:12] ↗[00:28:12] Jon Andersen: on a realistic level, people come to me all the time. They're like, oh, you know, I've done this, that, and the other with talking about strength or bodybuilding.
[00:28:20] ↗[00:28:20] Jon Andersen: Oh really? I'll know they're full of shit. I'll ask a question. They would never know. And then they'll just kind of like almost dismiss themselves because they don't even have a clue where to start. And they know that I know.
[00:28:30] ↗[00:28:30] John V Petrocelli: Yes. You have signaled the audience. And then, and that's one of the factors that we know that like for instance, I'm not gonna bullshit a an auto mechanic.
[00:28:39] ↗[00:28:39] John V Petrocelli: They're gonna know right away that I don't know what I'm talking about. Right. And I, even though I try to learn as much as I can each time. But it's, it's usually a conversation killer for the bullshitter when they determine like, okay, the audience has more knowledge than I do, and they're gonna detect the bullshit.
[00:28:57] ↗[00:28:57] John V Petrocelli: And then that's probably not acceptable in this context. But another good question to ask is, well, how do you know, how do you know the claim is true? And an even better question though, to ask one that is rarely considered is how might the claim be wrong? How might the claim be wrong? That usually will get people to think about potential disconfirming evidence, things that don't support the claim.
[00:29:26] ↗[00:29:26] John V Petrocelli: And it's probably something that they've never done. It's extremely rare if you ask, how do you know? People tend to produce confirmatory evidence, things that support the claim. And then the other question you get ask is is have you considered any other alternatives? And then when you get answers to these types of questions, you can make a better assessment as to the motives of the speaker.
[00:29:50] ↗[00:29:50] John V Petrocelli: And then you can make a better decision as to whether or not you're actually buying what it's that they're selling.
[00:29:55] ↗[00:29:55] Keith: Keith, Jon Marty with Dr. Jon. Can I ask a
[00:29:57] ↗[00:29:57] marty: quick
[00:29:57] ↗[00:29:57] Keith: question to Jon? Go ahead there Marty. Go ahead, brother.
[00:30:00] ↗[00:30:00] marty: I got a question about the saying you can't bullshit a bullshitter.
[00:30:04] ↗[00:30:04] John V Petrocelli: Yeah.
[00:30:06] ↗[00:30:06] marty: So how do you interpret that?
[00:30:09] ↗[00:30:09] John V Petrocelli: Yeah. Well, people want to protect themselves from bullshit. Even though most people don't think it's harmful, which is, seems like a paradox that but they're trying to, they're trying to create some sort of expertise and their ability to detect bullshit, and they're trying to guard themselves against it, I would say implicitly, because most people think they're actually really good at detecting bullshit.
[00:30:34] ↗[00:30:34] John V Petrocelli: And actually more recent studies have shown, demonstrated what we've always thought for the ba past decade as we've demonstrated now that the people who are most susceptible to bullshit happen to be the people who are most confident in their ability to detect it. So, so the people are most likely to say, well, you can't bull, you know, I'm a, you know, I'm a bullshitter.
[00:30:57] ↗[00:30:57] John V Petrocelli: You can't bullshit me. That's not supported by the empirical evidence at all. It's actually the, it's actually the opposite which baffles me because most people just kind of blow off bullshit. You know, when most people sort of know when. People don't care about the truth and that, well, what brother, what do you think about this?
[00:31:19] ↗[00:31:19] Jon Andersen: As you say that it makes sense because it seems like from my experience, someone that's bullshitting is trying to, like, they're trying to join a club that they're not a part of.
[00:31:29] ↗[00:31:29] John V Petrocelli: Oh, yes.
[00:31:30] ↗[00:31:30] Jon Andersen: Yeah. And so because they're trying to do that. They're trying to talk shop with someone that they're trying to talk shop in the shop, they don't belong to.
[00:31:37] ↗[00:31:37] Jon Andersen: The guy that belongs to the shop knows right away. So it's almost like the bullshitters are trying to get on board and they're doing it to the people that can easily recognize that they're full of shit.
[00:31:49] ↗[00:31:49] John V Petrocelli: Yeah. Yes. This a few years, well, the last Batman movie that came out years ago, I afterwards discussing it with a few friends, and there was one friend I have that I know did not watch the movie.
[00:32:02] ↗[00:32:02] marty: Oh man.
[00:32:03] ↗[00:32:03] John V Petrocelli: But he did not skip a beat. He was able to talk, you know, just kind of,
[00:32:09] ↗[00:32:09] Keith: you know,
[00:32:10] ↗[00:32:10] John V Petrocelli: go through the conversation about the new Batman movie. And I know he hadn't watched it. But so it's rather easy and it's if it's an acceptable part of you know, of what we sometimes call a bullshit session yeah.
[00:32:24] ↗[00:32:24] John V Petrocelli: These guys just talking that, and it's acceptable there. But I'm really, I'm convinced that this type of communication, this social substance that we call bullshit. Distinct from lying is sort of a major cause of just bad thinking, bad decision making and sort of the root of many of our beliefs, many of our assumptions about everything from the world, relationships, homes, cars, wine, jewelry, exercise, everything that we, almost everything that we believe, because all, most of these things have escaped sort of a critical analysis.
[00:33:03] ↗[00:33:03] Keith: Yeah.
[00:33:03] ↗[00:33:03] John V Petrocelli: Until you have that you're gonna be influenced by bullshit.
[00:33:06] ↗[00:33:06] Keith: Good morning, Fontan. I see your comments there. MB gesture. I see your comments. Ur, welcome to the show here at mornings in the lobby at eight o'clock eastern time, right here on LinkedIn, YouTube, and next. Hey, Dr. Jon. So you must be like, what do you think of the climate of the world today when you open up the day and all you see is bullshit everywhere?
[00:33:24] ↗[00:33:24] Keith: And I'm serious. You know, it's just, it's like, it's like what is real, what is not real? And that is the legitimate question today, isn't it? Like, what is bullshit? What is not bullshit? How do you find the truth? And how would you encourage humans today to go through their world?
[00:33:37] ↗[00:33:37] Keith: Trying to decipher through the bullshit. And I'm serious because I was watching some stuff yesterday and I had to find myself looking for a few extra sources to confirm whether it was true or not, because I got this show here that I'm trying to give truth to folks and some it's getting harder and harder.
[00:33:52] ↗[00:33:52] Keith: How are we waiting through bullshit? Especially when leaders are talking bullshit, just like it's no, this or that.
[00:34:00] ↗[00:34:00] John V Petrocelli: So I don't know if I have the answer, but I suspect that it has to do with how we respond to lying. So a major distinction between bullshitting and lying is that with lying, there are consequences.
[00:34:18] ↗[00:34:18] John V Petrocelli: You know, you can be, you can be fired for lying on your resume, you know, from the start. So, right. Yeah. So you can when friends tell us lies, you know, it hurts. They're gonna have to tell us 500 truths again, for a, for us to trust. Yeah. It's damage. Yeah. Lie is damage.
[00:34:35] ↗[00:34:35] Keith: Yeah.
[00:34:35] ↗[00:34:35] John V Petrocelli: It's damage. So I have proposed that we start to treat bullshit like lies because if someone is not, is communicating something, and they don't even care about truth. So this is where Harry Frankfort philosopher that created the sort of definition, this empirical definition that I use of bullshitting suggested that bullshit was worse than lying because he held truth.
[00:35:01] ↗[00:35:01] Keith: Yes.
[00:35:01] ↗[00:35:01] John V Petrocelli: Yeah. A concern for truth was paramount. So he said, well, at least the liar is concerned about the truth, but the bullshitter isn't concerned. They're tried to cover up.
[00:35:12] ↗[00:35:12] Keith: They're because the liar is intentionally lying and they know the truth. He's
[00:35:16] ↗[00:35:16] Jon Andersen: protecting the truth.
[00:35:18] ↗[00:35:18] Keith: Yeah. But if I'm bullshitting, I'm just trying to pardon my language to fuck with your head a little bit.
[00:35:22] ↗[00:35:22] Keith: I don't really care. I have no care. Right. Buts I have no care.
[00:35:25] ↗[00:35:25] John V Petrocelli: Yeah. And it, it may also just be because you want to see what it sounds like to feel what it sounds like to say something. Oh, geez. Or you hope it to be true. You wish it to be true. You think it's true? Some people just like to talk to, sometimes people do believe their own, they believe their own bullshit.
[00:35:42] ↗[00:35:42] John V Petrocelli: This is actually why it's actually more difficult to detect, in my opinion, than lying because with lying, you have to remember the lie, right? A few months later if you forget. Yeah, that sucks. If you forget, you can be caught. You know, your audience remembers and you forgot.
[00:35:58] ↗[00:35:58] John V Petrocelli: Oh, yeah. Now that they've got you in a inconsistency, but the bullshitter often believes their own bullshit, so they don't have the burden of having to remember the truth. They just go back to what they hope. And Well,
[00:36:10] ↗[00:36:10] Jon Andersen: you said about lying. You know, when I was younger, you know, of course, especially in the female realm, you know, seeing more than one female at a time, you're stacking up fucking bullshit.
[00:36:18] ↗[00:36:18] Jon Andersen: Well, I shouldn't say bullshit. Bullshit, yes. And lies, but then all of a sudden you get this inventory of shit you gotta remember. It creates like this anxiety and this. I was like, this is not fucking worth it. You know? This is not a way to live. You know, so I can only imagine a person that does that, like with their actual loved ones, like the people that really fucking matter.
[00:36:40] ↗[00:36:40] Jon Andersen: I was just doing it to a bunch of chicks that I didn't know very well. You know,
[00:36:47] ↗[00:36:47] Keith: I I gotta be honest, I never thought this would be as fascinating as it is and no shit. Because of how No, because of how serious it is. And I'm just, because I'm thinking about it and everything you're saying, I'm just thinking about the world today, and I'm just, because when you say that bullshitters believe their own bullshit, dude, that's actually the world right now.
[00:37:06] ↗[00:37:06] Jon Andersen: Well, and it's opened up a new dimension of this conversation that most people wouldn't have recognized as even there it's like talking about macro versus micro Yes. People like, what do you mean?
[00:37:16] ↗[00:37:16] John V Petrocelli: Yeah. One of the, one of the things that we learned in the earliest studies that we conducted too was that our primary method of measuring bullshit is just to ask the individuals.
[00:37:26] ↗[00:37:26] John V Petrocelli: So we have people write about anything, you know, and then we feed and we say, write one thought per screen frame, and then we feed them back their thoughts later, and we ask them, okay, this is a thought that you wrote moments ago when you wrote this thought, to what degree were you. Were you truly concerned about truth, genuine evidence?
[00:37:49] ↗[00:37:49] John V Petrocelli: You can't just say evidence, genuine evidence or established knowledge. You rate it on a zero to 10 scale. And so the average that we get is a six. Wow. Just about any, so, so we convert that to four 'cause we subtract it from 10. It's the lack thereof, right? So on average, across probably 24 studies now where we've asked people to write about something and then we ask them their attitudes about it, we really don't care.
[00:38:18] ↗[00:38:18] John V Petrocelli: But we really wanna get at their thoughts and how connected that is to their concern. For truth, they give us a six, we convert that to a four. So that's basically 40%. So 40%. Of what people report they, they're readily willing to admit is bullshit. 40% is a lot. That's, I actually think it's more like 60 se to 70%, but they're real, they're readily willing to admit that 40% of what they just wrote was bullshit.
[00:38:48] ↗[00:38:48] John V Petrocelli: Well then, so
[00:38:49] ↗[00:38:49] Keith: Jesus Murphy, so lemme ask you this then. So are we, I'm just blown away right now. We seem to be living in a world now where people just are accepting that Jon Petro is bullshitting me and it's almost, would you say that the bar has gone down for truth that Jon and Marty and Keith really don't like?
[00:39:07] ↗[00:39:07] Keith: We don't really want truth, we just want to hear what we want to hear.
[00:39:13] ↗[00:39:13] John V Petrocelli: Oh, I that's hard to say. I think the one thing that we can conclude though is that the documentation of bullshit is is an all time high because of what is recorded digitally, whether it's, you know, it's video, audio or written.
[00:39:31] ↗[00:39:31] John V Petrocelli: There's so much of it. I mean, it's just, it's hard to follow everything. I mean, you know, years ago when I was growing up, there was, you know, there was the maybe two or three. Television shows per night that everybody watched. And yeah, it's just like, it's just like, you know, binge, binge watching Netflix and things.
[00:39:51] ↗[00:39:51] John V Petrocelli: I mean, it's just like, there's so many options. Right. And the same goes for social media. I mean, it's like all these different platforms, it's difficult to follow. But all of it's being recorded. So, so there's sort of a digital lab that is opened, and again I've said it, it's, I've tried to get more people interested in the topic, to examine it empirically to ask, you know, scientific questions and investigate what where's the greatest amount of support for, or is there none for this idea?
[00:40:25] ↗[00:40:25] John V Petrocelli: And it's been a little slow going and for whatever reason, I don't know it. And some, I think some of the news of the conclusions about bullshit are a little discouraging because it's really difficult to eradicate. But I believe that if we can start to treat bullshit like lies and deliver the consequences that we do for lies, the social consequences, I think we can at least change what I call the communicative culture.
[00:40:52] ↗[00:40:52] John V Petrocelli: That is rather accepting of bullshit, primarily because people assume that it's harmless. But that's, but people can't be more wrong. Bullshit change, you know, shapes learning memory, attention and most importantly beliefs. And there's nothing more powerful, nothing more foundational. Decision making than what you believe to be true.
[00:41:14] ↗[00:41:14] John V Petrocelli: Yeah, because there's nothing more important.
[00:41:16] ↗[00:41:16] Keith: Well, and Dr. Jon Petrocelli, if our leaders, whether they're in business or in politics, are bullshitting us on a daily basis, it's hard for the rest of us to decide whether it's bullshit or reality. And I, as I go through the world chasing truth I it's hard to wonder what's true and what's bullshit.
[00:41:33] ↗[00:41:33] Keith: And I don't know if it's gonna get any easier as time goes forward.
[00:41:38] ↗[00:41:38] John V Petrocelli: Yeah. I would say too, Keith not to discourage you further, but Yeah. What we find we've conducted studies in our bullshit studies lab that, that look at the, in the influence, the persuasion of, yeah.
[00:41:50] ↗[00:41:50] John V Petrocelli: Bullshit and social perceivers, if they pick up on cues, communicative cues. Okay. Like, I don't care what the research says, here's what I believe.
[00:42:03] ↗[00:42:03] Intro: Ah, that's bullshitter.
[00:42:04] ↗[00:42:04] John V Petrocelli: All right. Yeah. Jon, I don't care what the nutritionist and exercise expert, you know, what they believe. Here's what I think. So, so now I'm telling you that I don't really care about the truth, right.
[00:42:15] ↗[00:42:15] John V Petrocelli: Or established knowledge. So when that happens, people tend to mentally kind of, check out not set, not shut down, but yeah. But they tend to use what we call peripheral route processing. So they're influenced by appearance. Maybe. Known credibility of the communicator. They're not influenced by the strength, the argument quality Oh.
[00:42:41] ↗[00:42:41] John V Petrocelli: Of a communicator. So, and that makes sense, right? Because if I know that you're bullshitting me, then I don't really have to, I don't have to bring my A game to counter argue. Yeah,
[00:42:49] ↗[00:42:49] Jon Andersen: no. Yeah, you, at that point, you just, they just used your dis I don't, you're full of shit. I don't need to finish.
[00:42:55] ↗[00:42:55] Jon Andersen: I'm not wasting another breath on you.
[00:42:57] ↗[00:42:57] John V Petrocelli: Yes. And if you're not concerned about research and facts and evidence that might otherwise support your case, you know, why should I, you know, so, so, so then at that point, people. When they process the message, they can't detect the difference between strong and weak arguments.
[00:43:14] ↗[00:43:14] Jon Andersen: So in that case where someone says, you know, I don't believe in the proven facts, A, B, and C, so, okay, well, what evidence do you have to support your disbelief? That's, that would be a way to shake 'em out the woods. Correct. That's what you're saying. Ask him a question to, to deliver some sort of supporting evidence why they don't believe
[00:43:36] ↗[00:43:36] John V Petrocelli: Yes, absolutely.
[00:43:36] ↗[00:43:36] John V Petrocelli: But the problem is the good bullshit is just
[00:43:39] ↗[00:43:39] Keith: gonna dismiss him. I'm thinking, right. The good bullshit is just gonna dismiss Jon's question right off the Yeah.
[00:43:44] ↗[00:43:44] John V Petrocelli: The majority of the au audience has already mentally and checked out in se in the sense that they're not gonna be able to detect the difference between strong and weak arguments.
[00:43:54] ↗[00:43:54] John V Petrocelli: Now, if you tell me the opposite, you say I'm actually concerned about truth, genuine evidence, established knowledge in whatever way. Then it's very easy to detect the difference between strong and weak arguments. Because then we're using what we call central route processing, where attitudes, opinions are only shaped, influenced by the strength of the arguments.
[00:44:17] ↗[00:44:17] Jon Andersen: So it's kind of interesting because there's like, cholesterol is a topic that I have lots of conversation with my clients about, right? And I said, and I start off by saying, listen, don't believe what I'm about to tell you. Go do your own research, because I'm gonna take a stance against a lot of the common knowledge in the medical field of what's going on with cholesterol.
[00:44:37] ↗[00:44:37] Jon Andersen: But I started off by, I, I don't just discredit everything and say, boom. I say, look, this is, you know, I kind of let them know that they've got a job to do, to find their own way through this before I just slam the current, you know, beliefs.
[00:44:52] ↗[00:44:52] John V Petrocelli: Yes. Yeah. And I think that's extremely important. Primarily because, I mean, I'm, as a social psychologist, I know that there are really no absolutes.
[00:45:03] ↗[00:45:03] John V Petrocelli: There are no. Sort of blanket solutions to everything for everyone. They're what we call sometimes in, in business they call it either categories or sections.
[00:45:16] ↗[00:45:16] Keith: Yeah.
[00:45:16] ↗[00:45:16] John V Petrocelli: And so social psychology we call it moderators. These are variables that kind of switch a light on or off or take, you know, relationship that might be a positive relationship and turn it into the negative relationship, you know, so it's, these are important variables that change the direction of what appears to be true.
[00:45:37] ↗[00:45:37] John V Petrocelli: Right. So, and there's a really I, I guess. If I could plug a book right now for Please for Anne Lako. She has a book out fascinating book out right now called Tiny Experiments. And it's basically that same idea, Jon, that you're saying that if you experiment, you know, for yourself, I mean, she has, you know, suggestions like, just get up and take a walk.
[00:46:06] ↗[00:46:06] John V Petrocelli: You know, like, you know, try that, see what that does, you know, for you. Like, maybe it doesn't work for everyone, maybe it doesn't but these tiny experiments that if you're just, if you're willing to you know, have sort of a mind of skepticism and and treat ideas as ideas, not as facts.
[00:46:25] ↗[00:46:25] John V Petrocelli: I add it, you know, certainty, certainty is a subjective feeling state. It's not a fact. So if you kind of challenge even sort of your or question some of your own beliefs and willing to test sort of your assumptions and ideas people can find many different, you know, solutions maybe that don't work for everyone, maybe work for a subsection, you know, of the population that you know, it can, and it can range from how people approach other people in relationships or physical mental health.
[00:47:00] ↗[00:47:00] John V Petrocelli: Careers, all kinds of things. It's just a willingness to kind of say, well, let me test this idea. Not rely only on you know, what others say. And I think that's really the direction of, you know, do your own research. I read that as try your own experiments, see what works for you. Yeah.
[00:47:21] ↗[00:47:21] Keith: Yeah. Dr. Jon Elli joining us this morning with Keith, Jon and Marty here this morning. Our morning's in the lab. Hey, doctor. So a number of years ago we were introduced to the term and Jonny, if you gotta sneak away for a break, brother, I invite you to do so, pal. Just yeah.
[00:47:34] ↗[00:47:34] Jon Andersen: I gotta tell you, I'm wiggling, but this conversation is keeping me tight, man.
[00:47:37] ↗[00:47:37] Jon Andersen: It's awesome, man. Listen, awesome.
[00:47:39] ↗[00:47:39] Keith: Oh man.
[00:47:41] ↗[00:47:41] Jon Andersen: If this hand goes away, if this hand goes away as I'm pinching the fireman's cabinet.
[00:47:48] ↗[00:47:48] Keith: Marty, you sneak away when you have to sneak away there, brother. Okay. So, Petrocelli, we were introduced to this idea of quote unquote alternative facts. A number of years ago. It was introduced to the media, it was introduced to the lexicon of language. And you have been saying something a few times here when you said truth, which is related to what, how did you say, what was the definition of truth to you?
[00:48:08] ↗[00:48:08] Keith: What generat? Generative
[00:48:11] ↗[00:48:11] John V Petrocelli: Oh, no. Genuine evidence. Yes. And if you use genuine evidence, people think, oh, you're okay. You're talking about the real stuff, the observable, verifiable. Things that I can demonstrate
[00:48:24] ↗[00:48:24] Keith: is
[00:48:24] ↗[00:48:24] John V Petrocelli: that called truth and that's objective truth. Okay.
[00:48:28] ↗[00:48:28] Keith: Okay. Okay. So what is truth in 2025?
[00:48:32] ↗[00:48:32] Keith: I'm sorry. I'm sorry. So Jimmy, here's the clip. This is a serious question. What is truth in 2025?
[00:48:40] ↗[00:48:40] Jon Andersen: There is none.
[00:48:41] ↗[00:48:41] Keith: Yeah,
[00:48:41] ↗[00:48:41] John V Petrocelli: I'm serious. What is truth? That, that, that particular word has probably been abused more than any other in the, you know, the past decade, I would say. And it's takes the place, I think it's been used as a synonym for opinions and assumptions or my exp experience.
[00:48:58] ↗[00:48:58] John V Petrocelli: It's my truth, my explanation of my experience. And I think maybe it's just a shortcut and it's tried to, people I think have tried to elevate opinions, assumptions and my experience to this, you know, what we used to say, gospel truth, you know? Yeah. But it is just taken at as assumptions and oftentimes again sort of maybe for you, this is your experience, but.
[00:49:25] ↗[00:49:25] John V Petrocelli: You know, but it's not objective truth. Like the truth that we could demonstrate, verify we can observe. And what's interesting, so what
[00:49:36] ↗[00:49:36] Keith: just sort of cut you off, what's interesting, what you just said is that I know you were in the green room while we were kicking this thing off, and I was laughing with Jonny that, you know, I was watching a segment yesterday on social, Megan Kelly was commenting on Jennifer Lopez's thing.
[00:49:47] ↗[00:49:47] Keith: And we live in a world now where the me we're talking heads like me and Jon, and even you right now, I grew up like you did, Jon, we're all 50 here. We grew up. Where you turned the TV on the talking head was giving you truth, right? So at least that's, we believe when you turned on Bo Yeah.
[00:50:03] ↗[00:50:03] Jon Andersen: It was a lot more truth at very least,
[00:50:04] ↗[00:50:04] Keith: right?
[00:50:05] ↗[00:50:05] Keith: So when you turned on whether the nightly news or you turned on the talking head, you know, you, you assumed that it was going to be truth. Now when you listen to Keith talk. I like you're saying this, is that when I'm giving my truth, it very much might be rooted in my experience, which might not be true.
[00:50:24] ↗[00:50:24] Keith: And humans now are leaning into a new term of truth. And that's actually the media of today, isn't it, doc, Dr. Jon, which is today's media is Opinions Disguised the Truth.
[00:50:33] ↗[00:50:33] John V Petrocelli: Yes. Yeah. And it's, I think 1985, Neil Postman's book Amusing Ourselves to Death Public Discourse in the Age of Show business.
[00:50:43] ↗[00:50:43] John V Petrocelli: I think that's what started to really, I think he, he observed that was what was really shaping what we would see as the news and what we would believe as the truth. It became sort of more of a form of entertainment. Entertainment.
[00:50:57] ↗[00:50:57] Keith: Yes.
[00:50:57] ↗[00:50:57] John V Petrocelli: You know, and that's where you get the, you know, these
[00:50:59] ↗[00:50:59] Keith: opinion themes.
[00:51:00] ↗[00:51:00] Keith: Everything's opinions now. Yes.
[00:51:02] ↗[00:51:02] John V Petrocelli: Yes. If I can't even remember the saying that if it bleeds it,
[00:51:07] ↗[00:51:07] Keith: if its, if it bleeds blue, it's blue or something. I, yeah, there's an old yeah. Jonny knows 'em great with quotes because I'm always gonna yeah. It's, he's the best.
[00:51:15] ↗[00:51:15] John V Petrocelli: Yeah. It's, but it's, yeah, it's I think become what I asked my students about 10 years ago what their primary source of news for college students was, and it was the DA and they said The Daily Show.
[00:51:29] ↗[00:51:29] John V Petrocelli: Yes. It was the da, you know, and I'm, of course you're gonna have. You're gonna be exposed to, you know, factual you know, parts of the information are factual. But then the take on, well what does this mean? Or what were some of the backstories you know, like this thing that's been discussed the last, like the past week with the the Coldplay?
[00:51:51] ↗[00:51:51] John V Petrocelli: Yes. I mean, all, who knows, you know, what is exactly going on there? I mean, it could be a number of different things. I don't particularly know many of the facts. And I would question a lot of the what? Well, the
[00:52:05] ↗[00:52:05] Jon Andersen: dude came and made an ap a formal apology, so, you know, he fucked up.
[00:52:09] ↗[00:52:09] Keith: No, Jonny, that was that No, that, that was a fake. That wasn't even real, Jonny, that, that was a fake release. The guy has not told. Oh, really? Yes. Oh,
[00:52:16] ↗[00:52:16] Jon Andersen: Jesus. Well, that tells you how up speed with the news I am. God damn. You know?
[00:52:19] ↗[00:52:19] Keith: But that's a good point though, Jonny because even Mad Roof roofing with Shaken brother, you know, put that statement out until we all realized that it wasn't real.
[00:52:26] ↗[00:52:26] Keith: But that goes back to what Petrocelli is saying is that what, is it real, is it not true? Because somebody creates the statement and it's all bullshit. Fascinating to me.
[00:52:37] ↗[00:52:37] John V Petrocelli: Yeah. And it's, and it just grows from one thing to another and you know, and then it's shared and actually the, there's be beyond the self the most potent bullshitters or people we know, or our friends, our family, yes.
[00:52:51] ↗[00:52:51] John V Petrocelli: Our neighbors, that, people that we interact with, that we just, we often take at sort of face value. You know, unless they happen to be the, you know, the one, you know, bullshit artist in the building, you know, for whatever reason. Everybody seems to know this same person who's the greatest bullshit artist of all time.
[00:53:09] ↗[00:53:09] John V Petrocelli: It's always someone's like Uncle Bob or it's or it's Tony and accounting on the eighth floor or whatever. It was like, everyone has like these stories and they're ready to like, give me all of their, you know, their. Examples of bullshit. And I asked that, well, when have you used it? You know, has it worked?
[00:53:29] ↗[00:53:29] John V Petrocelli: And oftentimes people believe that they, they have ready-made examples of when they used bullshit. And and in most cases that I usually get examples that they've used bullshit with their children and they say, oh yeah, it works really well. You know, to a point. Well, so
[00:53:44] ↗[00:53:44] Jon Andersen: that's, lemme ask you a question, brother.
[00:53:46] ↗[00:53:46] Jon Andersen: I'm, for me to understand things, I have to boil 'em down, distill 'em, simplify. That's what helps me. So when I use this adjective, not say that it's the best one, but it's one that's coming to my mind. If you had one word, one adjective to describe bullshitting. So I say manipulation, right? Not say that's correct.
[00:54:05] ↗[00:54:05] Jon Andersen: That's what's coming out of me right now. What would your number one descriptive word be for bullshitting? You only get one.
[00:54:15] ↗[00:54:15] John V Petrocelli: I just said bad.
[00:54:18] ↗[00:54:18] Jon Andersen: Bad. Okay. Yeah. Well, so if like the word manipulation kind of gives a little bit more of a direction, can you use one that helps the motive? The, of course we know it's bad, but can you use one that, that actually kind of summarizes the intent?
[00:54:34] ↗[00:54:34] John V Petrocelli: I don't care. That's what it, that's too
[00:54:37] ↗[00:54:37] Jon Andersen: many words.
[00:54:38] ↗[00:54:38] John V Petrocelli: Yeah. One word
[00:54:43] ↗[00:54:43] John V Petrocelli: I guess I would say ignorance.
[00:54:45] ↗[00:54:45] Jon Andersen: Oh, okay. Ignorance, okay. Ignorance. Good. Good. That's really helpful to me, that this is really starting now. The puzzle pieces are starting to fit together better for
[00:54:53] ↗[00:54:53] John V Petrocelli: me. And it's intentional ignorance and again, yes. So, so the intentional ignorant individual will sometimes get it right and they'll use the same language.
[00:55:04] ↗[00:55:04] John V Petrocelli: See, this is part of the problem with bullshit is that makes it so compelling is that it often sounds reasonable. It sound, and it uses the same business speak jargon maybe that every, that everyone in the company uses. And it's you know, bandwidth leverage and, you know, words like that they kind of go with.
[00:55:24] ↗[00:55:24] John V Petrocelli: With the culture. And it often sounds reasonable, but now it's often free of any sources and like, and reason. But sometimes the ignorant individual, the intentionally ignorant individual will, will get it. Right.
[00:55:38] ↗[00:55:38] Jon Andersen: Can you define ignorant? Because I think ignorant is a word that people tend to not totally understand.
[00:55:44] ↗[00:55:44] Jon Andersen: A lot of times it's just your ignorant is like a slap to the face. It doesn't really describe what ignorant is.
[00:55:50] ↗[00:55:50] Keith: It's a easy word to use at Sam. It's an easy word to sling at somebody. Yeah.
[00:55:53] ↗[00:55:53] Jon Andersen: But people don't understand, like a lot of times you'll hear a very educated person, Sam, I'm kind of ignorant in this topic, which he's being honest and he's using the word properly, but people don't understand that, oh, you're not ignorant the guy.
[00:56:06] ↗[00:56:06] Jon Andersen: Yeah. In this topic, I am. You know?
[00:56:09] ↗[00:56:09] John V Petrocelli: Yeah. I would, I'm gonna stick with ignorant in the sense that it is, i, if I don't really care about the truth, establish knowledge, genuine evidence then it's I'm willingly accepting my ignorance.
[00:56:25] ↗[00:56:25] Jon Andersen: I'm willing. And ignorance is meaning that you're just not, you're not, forget the term.
[00:56:29] ↗[00:56:29] Jon Andersen: Educated up to speed in this. Is that what you're, when you say ignorance, is that what
[00:56:34] ↗[00:56:34] Keith: You're not cha I'm thinking what St. Jon is. You're not challenging it. You're accepting it probably, right? Yeah.
[00:56:38] ↗[00:56:38] Jon Andersen: What would, how would you just describe ignorance so people, because your word ignorant is perfect, but now define that for our audience.
[00:56:44] ↗[00:56:44] Jon Andersen: 'cause I think some people have different ideas of what ignorant is.
[00:56:49] ↗[00:56:49] John V Petrocelli: Yeah. I guess on it, on its most. On its rawest level, I would think of it as unknowledgeable or I'm, there we
[00:56:57] ↗[00:56:57] Keith: go. Yeah.
[00:56:59] ↗[00:56:59] John V Petrocelli: Yeah. I'm unknowledgeable. There we go. About the topic or everything or how to behave in this situation or
[00:57:07] ↗[00:57:07] Keith: yeah, or
[00:57:07] ↗[00:57:07] John V Petrocelli: when it's
[00:57:07] ↗[00:57:07] Keith: Yeah.
[00:57:08] ↗[00:57:08] John V Petrocelli: That, that type of, yeah. So in general but yeah, if you forced me into one word, but if I could add another word, I would just say like, intentionally ignorant.
[00:57:16] ↗[00:57:16] Keith: Interesting. Okay. Okay. I like it. Like
[00:57:18] ↗[00:57:18] John V Petrocelli: I'm choosing to not listen to, you know, any of the evidence. Not, I don't care what experts say.
[00:57:27] ↗[00:57:27] John V Petrocelli: I don't care what the evidence might suggest. I don't care about the facts. Yeah. And I just, I think that's it's a tragic thing because again, there's, I mean, if you think about all the decisions that you've ever made in your life I would say people ought to give themselves a break because usually at the time if you did not see things clearly
[00:57:49] ↗[00:57:49] John V Petrocelli: It's usually the root. When people see things clearly I mean, thousands of cognitive psychological studies have already shown that when people view the situation clearly, they can see all of the advantages and disadvantages of the different, you know, options. They actually tend to make pretty rational decisions for themselves and for other people.
[00:58:14] ↗[00:58:14] John V Petrocelli: But the major I'm convinced that one of the major sources that distort clarity in decision making is bullshit based reasoning. Where either you don't know the facts you don't know what you need to, you know, to make this situation clear and you're applying assumptions, you know, false beliefs and or just opinions as opposed to evidence to make the decision.
[00:58:45] ↗[00:58:45] John V Petrocelli: So it looks like a good decision at the time, right? But it's actually not because it's just not clear. So, bullshit is a sort of a major opponent of clarity and decision making. And so I think to just completely ignore. Truth, genuine evidence. Established knowledge, which, which could change. I mean, the established knowledge, something that's changing right in the face of, in the face of evidence.
[00:59:11] ↗[00:59:11] John V Petrocelli: But with, you know, with the, with maybe the best data that I've got right now, the best available evidence I've got right now, you know, is this a good decision or not? Most people can make the rational. What appears to be the good decision at the time now in retrospect, you know, hindsight is 2020 and people give themselves, you know, a, you know, I gotta pee now.
[00:59:34] ↗[00:59:34] Jon Andersen: I gotta go now. I'll be right
[00:59:35] ↗[00:59:35] Keith: back. We're gonna, we're gonna reset as well here. Yeah. You're hanging out with Keith and Jon here on Morning, live with Keith, Jon, and friends every single day. Eight o'clock eastern time, right here on YouTube, LinkedIn, and X. A fascinating conversation. I know Jonny can hear me.
[00:59:48] ↗[00:59:48] Keith: I know Jonny can hear me. Might be one of the fa most fascinating conversations we've had on this show. There's been a lot of man, I gotta go back to listen to this later. Dr. Jon Tch. So we're talking bullshit. It's not, and I'm gonna get to the comments here in the feeds here. I see your comment there.
[01:00:01] ↗[01:00:01] Keith: Code sider Epstein files. Yes. Will granola, I see your comment there as well, Paul. You know, I see your comment. Most cable news, either left-leaning or right-leaning some more extreme than others. It's difficult to find unbiased news these days. I'd like to throw the question to Petra around this word, unbiased.
[01:00:18] ↗[01:00:18] Keith: I don't even know what that word means anymore. Bottom line is that people need to stop worshiping politicians. Fair enough. Politicians don't care about you. They only care about being elected and their donors, cable news only cares about views and catering to one side to get those views. And what we're trying to do here is we're trying to provide clarity and try to find truth and put it up there.
[01:00:35] ↗[01:00:35] Keith: But again, Dr. Jon, it's not lost upon me because, you know, you know, the politics of the moment, the scandal at the moment right now is loaded around the Epstein files, and regardless of how one cares about 'em, it's not lost upon me that it's wrapped up in bullshit. Right. And that's what's fascinating to me because it's, you know, there's facts, there's no facts.
[01:00:54] ↗[01:00:54] Keith: There's, and you, there's being dismissive. And it's just a fascinating time, man. I and I'm thoroughly enjoying our conversation with you. We'll get Jonny back before we say goodbye to you. What do you say to the word unbiased? That's a hard, that's a hard word to kind of wrap my head around today as well.
[01:01:10] ↗[01:01:10] John V Petrocelli: Yeah. If I think even if you. Even if you designed a, an algorithm
[01:01:15] ↗[01:01:15] Keith: yeah.
[01:01:15] ↗[01:01:15] John V Petrocelli: Simple on a, on an Excel spreadsheet on how to, I mean, it's gonna the potential, you know, what people value often becomes, you know, pegged as a bias. I mean, we call it a, well, I, you know, I value, you know, this outcome.
[01:01:30] ↗[01:01:30] John V Petrocelli: I value freedom, you know? Yeah.
[01:01:34] ↗[01:01:34] Keith: We talked a couple weeks ago how democracy is defined differently in different parts of the world. So, you know, you define democracy a different way than I define democracy. Freedom is different to you. Freedom's different to me, but yet we're both free. It's just, that's why I'm so fascinated about you.
[01:01:46] ↗[01:01:46] Keith: 'cause I'm a co I'm a conversationalist for a living. So when I hear you talking about this idea of bullshitting in conversation, it makes me really wanna lean in and learn more.
[01:01:56] ↗[01:01:56] John V Petrocelli: Yeah. And it, with my beef, with the sort of the bias literature, I guess and the efforts
[01:02:01] ↗[01:02:01] Keith: yeah.
[01:02:01] ↗[01:02:01] John V Petrocelli: Or the the assumptions around bias is that we can, we just have to become unbiased.
[01:02:07] ↗[01:02:07] John V Petrocelli: Right? But. We know, we've known for probably about 75 years now that it's not so much a motivational, it can be a motivational,
[01:02:18] ↗[01:02:18] Intro: Yeah.
[01:02:18] ↗[01:02:18] John V Petrocelli: Aspect. It's like I just, I want my team to win. I love my team. Yes. It's not that I hate it's not that I hate, it's the Outgroup or the other team. It's just I really love my team.
[01:02:28] ↗[01:02:28] John V Petrocelli: Yeah. That's, you know, I'm, so, I'm motivated to see them win. And the, but my pirates just beat the Detroit Tigers. They swept them by the way. And you said you wanted this to be a current events. I think that's a fact. And there's evidence that the, that one of the worst teams in baseball now has beat the best team.
[01:02:44] ↗[01:02:44] John V Petrocelli: Three games to none. But anyway I think you know, if you. Have any values your biases are gonna come out. And it is, we've known again for 75 years that all it takes to judge the something like as simple as the similarity between two lines drawn on a piece of paper.
[01:03:04] ↗[01:03:04] John V Petrocelli: Okay? Yeah. We could say like, well, one is five inches and then one is three inches, right? And people say, oh, well, well they're similar to an extent 'cause they're lines, right? And they're straight and, but one's bigger than the other. So they say, well, the similarity on a zero to 10 scale, let's say it's a six.
[01:03:21] ↗[01:03:21] John V Petrocelli: Okay? Now if you take in another condition, you take the same line, same piece of paper, and under the, under one of them you write the letter A and other, the other line. You write the letter B. Now that judgment on average of a six laity, now it's like a five. Not a huge difference, but people see less similarity, greater difference as soon as you label things, as soon as you label them.
[01:03:48] ↗[01:03:48] John V Petrocelli: Or if you say like. You know, we give you a person, a bogus personality test, and we say, oh, Keith, you are an over estimator, and Jon, you are an under estimator. And we tell you, you know, so you tend to Jon, you you tend to underestimate things like active volcanoes in the world, maybe the calories in an apple and Keith you overestimate them.
[01:04:11] ↗[01:04:11] John V Petrocelli: You know, just meaningless stuff like that. Yeah. Alright, there are other participants in other cubicles in this experi, in the study experiment. And some of them are underestimates and over estimators. And each round of this game, you're gonna have to allocate a total of 15 points to the other participants.
[01:04:33] ↗[01:04:33] John V Petrocelli: And what we find is people will favor their group. They'll favor, if this is an over estimator, Keith, then you'll tend to favor them and you'll give them more, you'll give them eight points in versus seven as the closest, you know, and you can't split points. So is a, you know, you have to allocate entire points.
[01:04:51] ↗[01:04:51] John V Petrocelli: No, no half points. And Jon, you're gonna tend to. Favor the underestimates. You'll give them as, as close as you can get to eight, eight to seven. Or sometimes it's you give all 15 to your group and you don't meet these people, they don't actually even exist. Okay. You just know that there's an alleged individual in the next cubicle who is either in your group or in the outgroup.
[01:05:15] ↗[01:05:15] John V Petrocelli: And we call these minimal groups. Yeah, minimal groups because you have a minimal similarity with this individual. And that alone can kick off what we observe as a bias. And so it's not motivational, it's just how we're wired. It's a mental process that we just tend to favor our ingroup over the outgroup.
[01:05:41] ↗[01:05:41] John V Petrocelli: And it has nothing to do with motivation. It's just it's how we are wired.
[01:05:46] ↗[01:05:46] Keith: Anderson, you're gonna be fascinated by this. Dr. Petra started out his career working in addiction counseling before pivoting to the world of psychology, of bullshit. And I, you know, I saw your jokes there, Petra Elli, that it's a natural transition from one tough habit to another.
[01:06:01] ↗[01:06:01] Keith: Like you go full, dude,
[01:06:02] ↗[01:06:02] Jon Andersen: that's all me, brother. That's fucking, I mean, Jesus Christ, right? I've just been fucking smart enough, or I had enough discipline to connect my addiction to positive shit.
[01:06:12] ↗[01:06:12] Keith: Well, but what's interesting, Jonny, is because, 'cause Petally brought up at the beginning of a conversation.
[01:06:17] ↗[01:06:17] Keith: He linked it to, to the philosophy of communication. Right. And Anderson, I'm sorry, petal, you would know this, but Anderson's a philosophy major. He graduated philosophy major. So, and I always minor. And I always don't oversell
[01:06:27] ↗[01:06:27] Jon Andersen: me.
[01:06:28] ↗[01:06:28] Keith: Yeah. And I always, I'm bullshitting and I'm always and I'm always you know, talk.
[01:06:32] ↗[01:06:32] Keith: So I'm an AI nerd. I spend a lot of time in the AI world and nerdy about all that stuff. And I and to me the future of the world is being a good communicator and leaning into ideas like philosophy 'cause critical thinking. Right. So, you know, when I hear you communicator and Anderson talk, the idea of, I think the idea of philosophy is more important than ever to Jon Petrocelli because it's that critical thinking aspect, you know, snuffing out the bullshitters.
[01:06:54] ↗[01:06:54] Keith: Would you agree with that in a world of AI and what's true and what's not true?
[01:06:59] ↗[01:06:59] John V Petrocelli: Oh, absolutely. I think that the best tools that we have for rational decision making is critical thinking and a willingness to experiment. Yeah. To find the truth in this, you know, in this context, you know, for this person under these circumstances.
[01:07:18] ↗[01:07:18] John V Petrocelli: And if, yeah, if you don't lean into that then it's really a crapshoot in as far as deci your quality of decision making in life. I would say too, my, my book really is a critical thinking skills book, but if you call it critical thinking skills one oh one, nobody wants to read it, you know, a life changing science of
[01:07:37] ↗[01:07:37] Keith: attitude life.
[01:07:38] ↗[01:07:38] Keith: So your book is the Life Changing Science of Detecting Bullshit? Yes.
[01:07:41] ↗[01:07:41] John V Petrocelli: Yes. It's, and it's not a political book. It's the fly on the cover too is that was actually decided six months before the Mike Pence you know, incident during the vice presidential debate. It had nothing to do with that, but I just thought, you know, the fly is the prototypical bullshit debate.
[01:08:00] ↗[01:08:00] John V Petrocelli: Yeah. I have no
[01:08:00] ↗[01:08:00] Jon Andersen: fucking idea what you guys were talking about right
[01:08:02] ↗[01:08:02] John V Petrocelli: now.
[01:08:04] ↗[01:08:04] Keith: During the VP debate, there was there was a fly that was part of the
[01:08:07] ↗[01:08:07] John V Petrocelli: yeah. And here's the flies, right. I insisted that the, that there be a fly. Oh, Petra, you're
[01:08:13] ↗[01:08:13] Keith: funny, man.
[01:08:14] ↗[01:08:14] John V Petrocelli: The artist loved it. He put all kinds of, you know, like the trail of a fly there.
[01:08:19] ↗[01:08:19] John V Petrocelli: Yeah. There, you know, anybody who has a dog or has been to a zoo, or has a farm, you know, the flies coming right away. That the flies are on it. I mean, they detected it immediately. So, I just thought, you know, that's the best, you know. Prototype. That's
[01:08:38] ↗[01:08:38] Jon Andersen: actually guy. That's cool, man.
[01:08:39] ↗[01:08:39] Jon Andersen: It's really good.
[01:08:40] ↗[01:08:40] Keith: It's really good. Yeah. So listen, dude, I so Jimmy Producer, Jimmy's been in my ear. The whole show thing. We gotta move it on. I love the conversation.
[01:08:47] ↗[01:08:47] Jon Andersen: No. This is the one where we just let it roll. I'm happy to bypass my segment. Marty segment was gone. See, brother, this is a huge compliment to you.
[01:08:55] ↗[01:08:55] Jon Andersen: There's normally a bunch of shit that would've gone on. Yeah. But you're such a good guest. We're saying fuck all that stuff. Yeah. Because we don't get guests like you that are truly like bringing the hammer with real fucking solid, informative information.
[01:09:09] ↗[01:09:09] Keith: You've been the longest guest in the history of the show so far.
[01:09:11] ↗[01:09:11] John V Petrocelli: Oh, wow. Okay. Wow.
[01:09:12] ↗[01:09:12] John V Petrocelli: And I
[01:09:13] ↗[01:09:13] Keith: and I'm purposely not bringing out the goat button because I would be bullshitting you with the goat button. 'cause I have a, I, yeah, the
[01:09:19] ↗[01:09:19] Jon Andersen: goat, it sounds like a fucking castrated goat. I told him, I said, do not give that to a female doing. Well, maybe, but do not give that to another male.
[01:09:27] ↗[01:09:27] Keith: So I gotta get a better goat for the next time Petally shows up here, because I think we gotta bring it back. Dude, you have been dropping bombs. I wanna be respectful of your time and work you on your way here. How can folks connect with you, find you, engage with you, hire you, get you to speak, find your book.
[01:09:42] ↗[01:09:42] Keith: Please take a couple of minutes to, or a minute or so, promote yourself and make sure the audience knows all about Dr. Jon Petrocelli.
[01:09:50] ↗[01:09:50] John V Petrocelli: Okay, well, I'm, you can find me easily. J Jon v petrocelli.com. I had to add the V because there is another Jon Petrocelli in New York. Oh shit. Yeah, he's a h he's a hypnotist and he wasn't willing to sell me his website for like $5,000 or something.
[01:10:09] ↗[01:10:09] John V Petrocelli: You couldn't bullshit him enough there. Pet. You couldn't. Yeah. So, so Jon v Petrocelli.
[01:10:15] ↗[01:10:15] Keith: Petrocelli. Okay.
[01:10:16] ↗[01:10:16] John V Petrocelli: Okay. do.com and I'm at Jon v Petro on X Twitter. Awesome. Hey, do you have kids? Yes. One 16-year-old daughter who, it's crazy about tennis. And I that's what I do in my, my my off times is I just pick up tennis balls.
[01:10:32] ↗[01:10:32] John V Petrocelli: I'm a tennis ball retriever in my Good for you brother. In my other life. That's all I do.
[01:10:38] ↗[01:10:38] Keith: Curious before you go, because I've really enjoyed our conversation and so, you know, and I know how our kids deal with their parents, but I gotta be curious, how do you talk with your daughter about truth and bullshitting and just kind of life and how, and I'm thinking you're just constantly giving her nuggets to be considering, right?
[01:10:53] ↗[01:10:53] Keith: Or is she just walking around as one big, Jonny, she's one big skeptic, doesn't believe anything around her. Is that, would that be fair to say?
[01:11:01] ↗[01:11:01] John V Petrocelli: I'm the one person probably in this world, that's not a lot of bullshit at all in my home because my wife and my daughter will, they'll call me and I bet immediately
[01:11:13] ↗[01:11:13] Jon Andersen: what a great environment.
[01:11:14] ↗[01:11:14] Jon Andersen: What a great environment that everybody, nobody will put up with bullshit.
[01:11:18] ↗[01:11:18] John V Petrocelli: Yeah. So I, and this wasn't bullshit, but this was a lot. I guess it was alive, but for whatever reason I think my daughter was four and I told her, oh yes, my high school football team. Yep. We won all of our games. We won all of our games.
[01:11:33] ↗[01:11:33] John V Petrocelli: We never lost. I don't know why I told her that. We were like 500, you know this oh. And she said, no, dad, you didn't win all. You didn't win all of your games. I was like, oh my goodness. She was four or five, and I was like, no, this, yeah this is gonna work.
[01:11:50] ↗[01:11:50] Jon Andersen: You got her detector working early, didn't you?
[01:11:52] ↗[01:11:52] John V Petrocelli: Oh, yeah. Yeah. She's much more intelligent than I'll ever be. She was at fi fifth grade concerned about a science grade grade, and her fir she didn't have a phone. She didn't have a phone until about two years ago. I didn't have let her have a cell phone until two years ago.
[01:12:09] ↗[01:12:09] John V Petrocelli: And she's in fifth grade concerned about a science grade. She gets straight A's, and she searched her first search on Google. I let her use my laptop and I, of course check the history. You know, her search, you know what she searched Google was, does Harvard take fifth grade grades? And I'm thinking, okay, I don't have,
[01:12:34] ↗[01:12:34] Jon Andersen: yeah, you're not worried about future searches after that?
[01:12:37] ↗[01:12:37] John V Petrocelli: I'm not worried about her she's, yeah, self-motivated. She studies her I never have to tell her to do her homework or anything, so o okay. She's just has that inner. Will and motivation to just excel. And so, but yeah I can't get away with any bullshit with in, in my home, unfortunately.
[01:12:56] ↗[01:12:56] John V Petrocelli: 'cause it does come in handy because the problem is, you know, people use it so much because it often works. It often works. So,
[01:13:03] ↗[01:13:03] Keith: got some great comments in the community. I wanna throw what your pet Shelley, before you go, we got Bernard coming in saying, Jon, thank you for your time and wisdom today.
[01:13:10] ↗[01:13:10] Keith: Terrific addition to the growth process, lady Drew comes in and says you are great. Keep up. It's excellent. And then Bernard comes in and says, teaching your kids to have a BS detector is key to great decision making skills. And bru a five or 4-year-old is dialed in on deciding if you are playing them or not.
[01:13:26] ↗[01:13:26] Keith: I love it. Where your kid is recognizing, dad, you're bullshitting me, man. That's that's awesome. That means you're doing a great job being a parent. Dude, I'm very grateful for your time today. You've given me more than I could have asked for and I know I'm, oh my God, I know behalf of Anderson here.
[01:13:41] ↗[01:13:41] Keith: We're very grateful for your time, your extra, your knowledge. You dropped nuggets after nugget and I hope you'll find some time to come back and hang with us again sometime.
[01:13:48] ↗[01:13:48] John V Petrocelli: Sure, sure thing. Thanks guys. That'd be awesome. Alright, Jimmy, let's
[01:13:53] ↗[01:13:53] Keith: walk him outta here. Let's walk out. Thank you
[01:13:54] ↗[01:13:54] Jon Andersen: brother.
[01:13:54] ↗[01:13:54] Jon Andersen: Pleasure. Thank you so much. Well,
Appeared in
- Magazine #3178Is Nostalgia a Terrible Judge?
- Magazine #3173Is “Just Try Harder” Bad Advice?
- Magazine #3168Can You Spot Expertise Without the Costume?
- EpisodeLIVE | Expensive Clothes Make Men Look Competent. Here's Why
- EpisodeLIVE | Told You Have High Blood Pressure? You May Feel Worse
- EpisodeLIVE | Is Wellness Marketing Selling Hope as Science?
- EpisodeLIVE | When AI Sounds Certain, Why Do We Believe It?
- EpisodeLIVE | You Don’t Need More Discipline. You Need Fewer Decisions
- EpisodeLIVE | Why Do Credentials Make Bad Ideas Sound Smarter?
- EpisodeWhy Smart Men Believe Things That Aren't True | Dr. John Petrocelli on the Science of Bullshit
- EpisodeWhy Smart Men Fall for Ponzi Schemes & Bad Investments | Dr. John Petrocelli on Detecting BS
- EpisodeWhy Smart Men Fall For Bullsh*t (And How To Stop)
- EpisodeAI Is Replacing You and You Don't Even Know It | Deep Dive #3013
- EpisodeYour Brain Is Lying To You: EJ Snyder & Dr. Petrocelli Expose the BS Holding You Back
- EpisodeThe Georgetown Study Was WRONG: Why Your Habits Fail & What Leaders Do Differently
- EpisodeDefeat Your Inner Vecna: The Hidden Mental Health Message in Stranger Things
- EpisodeWhy Successful Men Still Feel Invisible | The Psychology of "I See You"
- EpisodeThe Sedation Trap: Why Men Are Quietly Checking Out | MITL #2199
- Episode6 Rules To Stay Sharp as an Entrepreneur (Most Men Lose Their Edge)
- EpisodeStop Setting Goals Like This (The Avoidance Trap Keeping Men Broke & Unhealthy)
- EpisodeBeing Cheap Is Keeping You BROKE | Scarcity Mindset, Snake Oil & Office Workouts
- EpisodeThis Ex-Military Sergeant Commands Respect Without Raising His Voice | Bjorn Hagemann
- EpisodeThe 90-Day Identity Shift That Will Make You Richer
- EpisodeEx-Addict Neuroscientist: How To Reset Your Dopamine & Destroy Brain Fog | George Haymaker
- EpisodeDream Expert: What Your Dreams Really Mean & The Cockroach Rule for Toxic People
- EpisodeWhy "Alpha" Men Who Don't Listen Are LOSING Status | Prostate Health, 80s Nostalgia & Coaching BS
- EpisodeA Strongman Cried on Air & The AI Warning No One Expected
- Episode"Motivation Is for Amateurs" — Jon Andersen's Rule for Iron Discipline
- EpisodeYour Doctor Won't Say This About Peptides | Microdosing GLP-1s & Asking Better Questions
- EpisodeStop Overthinking & Death Row Psychology w/ Jon Andersen | Mornings in the Lab
- EpisodeThe Brain Hack That Kills Anxiety Instantly | Build a Community in 2025
- EpisodeWhy Bullshitters Are More Dangerous Than Liars | Dr. Petrocelli