NEXT LIVEMornings in the Lab with Keith, Jon & Friendsin 2h 52m
← All network guests
John Petrocelli
Mornings in the Lab · Center Stage

John Petrocelli

Professor of Psychology

Bullshit DetectionSocial CognitionJudgment and Decision Making
Watch the conversation

Watch John Petrocelli’s appearance in the full show.

Watch guest appearance on YouTube ↗

Questions this episode answers

Can clothing make someone seem more competent?

Dr. John Petrocelli describes research in which people rated faces as more competent when they were paired with richer-looking clothing. He says the effect persisted even when participants were told to ignore the clothes.

Read this moment in the transcript →

How can you judge expertise beyond someone’s appearance?

Petrocelli recommends listening carefully and thinking through the reasoning behind a claim. He describes asking what a person is actually saying and whether a broad statement holds in every case.

Read this moment in the transcript →

Why are first impressions so hard to change?

Petrocelli says a favourable first impression can lead people to excuse later mistakes. An unfavourable impression can have the opposite effect, with later successes dismissed as luck.

Read this moment in the transcript →

Summary

John Petrocelli explains the distinction at the center of his research: lying generally involves knowing the truth, while bullshitting means communicating without concern for truth, genuine evidence or established knowledge. He describes experiments examining when people engage in that behavior, highlighting pressure to offer an opinion beyond their knowledge and audiences that make unsupported claims easy to get away with. He recommends clarifying a claim, asking how the speaker knows it is true and considering what could disprove it, while treating certainty as a feeling rather than proof. The wider discussion connects this approach to decision making, the difference between personal experience and verifiable truth, and his view that social tolerance of careless claims needs to change.

Key takeaways

  • A statement can happen to be correct and still fit Petrocelli’s definition of bullshit if the speaker has not cared about evidence or truth; accuracy by chance does not establish a sound process.
  • His suggested questions go beyond requesting supporting evidence: ask how a claim might be wrong and whether other explanations have been considered, so the conversation also examines evidence against it.
  • Petrocelli reports findings that people especially confident in their ability to detect bullshit can be especially susceptible to it, challenging the assumption that confidence provides protection.
  • He resists concluding that people now want less truth, saying the clearer change is how much communication is digitally recorded and available for examination.
  • His own exercise story illustrates a belief he reconsidered: he thought he disliked working out, but found that a regular group gave him both motivation and time with friends.
Read the transcript →

Jump into the conversation

Why Bullshitters Are More Dangerous Than Liars | Dr. Petrocelli
  1. 00:00The Bullshit Detector Intro
  2. 04:00The "R-Rated" Experience
  3. 06:00Jon Andersen on Sleep & Recovery
  4. 15:30Dr. John Petrocelli: The Science of BS
  5. 26:00Lying vs. Bullshitting: What's the Difference?
  6. 54:00Defining "Intentional Ignorance"
  7. 01:18:00The Cardio Paradox: Why Training Easier Gets Results
  8. 01:22:00Tommy the Cat Dials 911
  9. 01:30:00Live Call: AI Slop & The Future of Content
LIVE | Is Wellness Marketing Selling Hope as Science?
  1. 00:00Pre-Show
  2. 03:47Good Morning, Nation
  3. 06:10Pick a Side: Who Gets the Hours AI Saves?
  4. 16:00The First 3,000-lb Pumpkin
  5. 21:55Why Put Optimus in It?
  6. 35:43Pete Forcelli Joins: Service, Cancer and No More Excuses
  7. 37:58Ozempic or a Power Rack?
  8. 40:04Trying BPC-157
  9. 1:06:13The Trouble With "Treat Myself"
  10. 1:09:43When "Science-Backed" Starts Selling
  11. 1:13:21Puffery vs. Real Claims
  12. 1:22:05How Price Changes the Taste of Wine
  13. 1:30:01Two Weeks of Whole Foods
  14. 1:50:10Trusting Yourself After 100 Days of Age Strong
LIVE | Told You Have High Blood Pressure? You May Feel Worse
  1. 00:00Pre-Show
  2. 04:07Good Morning, Nation
  3. 26:06What's Coming for AI, Work and Money
  4. 35:17We're Never Really Taught to Breathe
  5. 46:15A Strongman's Rookie Season: Learning to Recover
  6. 54:06The United Airplane Story
  7. 1:00:15What If Every Adult Got a Gap Year at 50?
  8. 1:03:58Two Opposite Rules Can Both Sound Obvious
  9. 1:04:45Dr. John Petrocelli Joins
  10. 1:15:39How Often Are People Misdiagnosed?
  11. 1:28:04Misattribution: Blaming Everything on the Diagnosis
  12. 1:32:01Is There Really Such a Thing as Common Sense?
  13. 1:44:01When a Score Tells You How You Feel
  14. 1:50:02Life Hacker: Toilet Leak Test
The Sedation Trap: Why Men Are Quietly Checking Out | MITL #2199
  1. 00:00The Escapism Trap & Sleep Scores
  2. 12:00The Weirdest LinkedIn Pickup Line Ever
  3. 29:00History Rewritten: Fire Discovered 400k Years Ago
  4. 38:00Bullshit or No Bullshit: Hand Gestures & Influence
  5. 55:00The Myth of "Brain Synchrony"
  6. 1:16:00The Peptide Ban: Government vs. Gains
  7. 1:26:00Science Fact: Why Birds Poop on Brown Trucks
  8. 1:40:00Morning Focus: AI is the Great Equalizer
  9. 1:53:005 Habits That Quietly Ruin Relationships
Dream Expert: What Your Dreams Really Mean & The Cockroach Rule for Toxic People
  1. 00:00The "Dumb Sh*t" Sleep Schedule
  2. 12:00Marty's Business: The Safety to Fail
  3. 32:00Meet Caleb Matthews: The Dream Interpreter
  4. 44:00Keith's "Booty" Dream (Yes, really)
  5. 53:00The Evidence: Harriet Tubman & Solomon
  6. 1:06:00Reprogramming Your Subconscious While You Sleep
  7. 1:26:00The Cockroach Rule: React vs. Respond
  8. 1:51:00The Bullshit Professor: Dr. Petrocelli Reacts
  9. 2:01:00The Future of Media: Stepping Into the Video
Your Brain Is Lying To You: EJ Snyder & Dr. Petrocelli Expose the BS Holding You Back
  1. 0:00The "Blind Leading the Naked" Intro
  2. 4:15Weight Loss Drugs: The 4x Rebound Effect
  3. 14:00The "Overton Window": Is AI Desensitizing Us?
  4. 34:00EJ SNYDER: The "Ball Sack" Story (Graphic)
  5. 48:00God's Voice in the Wild vs. The City
  6. 1:09:00DR. PETROCELLI: The Science of Self-Deception
  7. 1:26:00Why "Never Quit" Can Be Self-Destruction
  8. 1:46:00Keith's Monologue: "I Was Wrong"
  9. 1:56:00Community Corner: Dealing with Rejection
Stop Setting Goals Like This (The Avoidance Trap Keeping Men Broke & Unhealthy)
  1. 00:00Intro & The Morning Snooze Button
  2. 05:45The Jelly Roll Transformation (200lbs Down)
  3. 15:00Trading Addictions: Drugs vs. Sugar vs. Gym
  4. 31:00Guest: David Hallangen (The Disney Story)
  5. 46:00The "Asshole Radar" for Clients
  6. 1:01:00Chuck Norris at 85 & The Avoidance Goal Trap
  7. 1:03:00Marty's Chess Lesson: Playing Defense vs. Offense
  8. 1:24:00Why Your Dog is Your Best Therapist
  9. 1:42:00Dr. John Petrocelli: The Bullshit Professor Returns
  10. 1:50:00The Skepticism Trap & Science of Sleep Data
LIVE | When AI Sounds Certain, Why Do We Believe It?
  1. 0:00:00Countdown to LIVE
  2. 0:03:32Cold Open: When Did Formatting Become a Qualification?
  3. 0:03:50Good Morning, Nation: Friday in the Lab
  4. 0:04:48Today's Question: Why Do We Believe AI When It Sounds Certain?
  5. 0:07:34Previously On: Yesterday's CTE Conversation
  6. 0:08:31Trending: The Fort Hood Shooter Faces a Firing Squad
  7. 0:11:18Pick a Side: The Encyclopedia or the Search Bar?
  8. 0:13:10What If You Had to Relive One Year?
  9. 0:15:37Jon Joins the Show
  10. 0:17:08Timing Big Talks With Your Wife
  11. 0:19:48SpaceX Buys Spectrum for Starlink Mobile
  12. 0:23:33A Live-Streamed Military Execution and the Double Standard
  13. 0:26:41Aerosmith Announces a Comeback
  14. 0:28:18Jon's Physique Photo: Strong in Your 50s
  15. 0:32:45Heavy Scrolling, Anger and 3 Hours a Day on Social
  16. 0:35:30Ambient Computing: Watching Hockey Without the Phone
  17. 0:38:35Sleep, Water Cutoffs and Nighttime Bathroom Trips
  18. 0:42:19Why "Intentional" Confuses People
  19. 0:44:44Keith's Shoulder Cap Plan
  20. 0:48:02FDA Talks on Access to Restricted Peptides
  21. 0:50:06Epic Fail: The Slingshot Ride
  22. 0:54:43A Camera Pill You Swallow to Read Your Gut
  23. 0:59:16Peptides, Resting Heart Rate and Going Slow
  24. 1:03:12Eating More Than Ever and Leaner Than Ever
  25. 1:05:23Hour Two: Holley Muraco Postponed by a Hurricane
  26. 1:06:13Why Does AI Sound So Official?
  27. 1:07:12Dr. John Petrocelli Joins
  28. 1:10:29Petro on Dr. Bennet Omalu
  29. 1:12:29Study: AI Summaries Distort Memory of a Car Crash
  30. 1:14:46Elizabeth Loftus: How One Word Plants a False Memory
  31. 1:19:09Who Says What to Whom: Credibility Cues
  32. 1:22:09The Decoy Effect: Does a Third Option Change Your Mind?
  33. 1:27:45Petro's Day Seven on Jon's Plan
  34. 1:30:25The Water Schedule Changes Everything
  35. 1:34:46Energy, Boot Camp and No Crashes
  36. 1:39:16Not Hungry, Just Not Full
  37. 1:42:39For Every Petro, There's a Joe and a Lisa
  38. 1:47:12The Lab as a Mentoring Program
  39. 1:50:36Keith's Brother and the New Pavement
  40. 1:51:46Stop Calling It a Diet
  41. 1:54:48A Week of Guests and a Full October
  42. 1:56:12Weekend Plans and the Undefeated Jets
  43. 1:57:52How Lifestyle Changes Business: Three-Hour Blocks
  44. 2:02:06The Closer
  45. 2:03:52That's the Week
The Georgetown Study Was WRONG: Why Your Habits Fail & What Leaders Do Differently
  1. 0:00The Void Week Chaos & Tech Fails
  2. 11:30Drake, Adin Ross & The Scam Allegations
  3. 16:00Keith vs. Jon: The Red Light Therapy Debate
  4. 42:00Eric Schmidt's Warning: 3 Steps to AI Dominance
  5. 1:11:00Dr. Petrocelli: The "Rat Study" on Habits
  6. 1:23:00Debunking the "Muscle Decline at 35" Myth
  7. 1:39:00Did You Know: The President's Waste Protocol
  8. 1:46:00Morning Focus: When "Real" Becomes a Filter (Instagram's Future)
  9. 1:56:00Community Corner: Stronger, Richer, More Attractive
Why Smart Men Believe Things That Aren't True | Dr. John Petrocelli on the Science of Bullshit
  1. 00:00Cold Open & Today's Show
  2. 05:00Why Smart Men Hold False Beliefs
  3. 25:00BS or No BS — Dr. Petrocelli
  4. 55:00The Confidence-Accuracy Gap
  5. 1:25:00How to Actually Change Your Mind
  6. 1:50:00Practical Takeaways & Close
LIVE | Expensive Clothes Make Men Look Competent. Here's Why
  1. 0:00Pre-show and cold open
  2. 3:49Today's rundown
  3. 6:56Friday open and the Morning Loop
  4. 8:51Pick a Side: Halloween candy age limit
  5. 12:01Patrick Stewart and changing family patterns
  6. 16:46What If: objects that reveal the past
  7. 18:22Jon Andersen joins
  8. 19:45Jon's rough night of sleep
  9. 21:33Heirlooms and Grandma's cane
  10. 25:05Picard and generational patterns
  11. 29:47Digging into the past or the future
  12. 34:03Jon on listening skills
  13. 36:45Intimacy-out-of-duty study
  14. 39:55GLP-1 and libido
  15. 43:06Age Strong day 120 update
  16. 47:45No finish line
  17. 48:33Epic Spot: excavator scale
  18. 49:35Labels and hiding behind them
  19. 53:17Knee pain is a symptom, not a diagnosis
  20. 55:25Jon on fixing knee and back pain
  21. 1:01:01Committed: vehicle stunt
  22. 1:03:16Lifestyle Tip: stop hiding
  23. 1:06:48Hour two open
  24. 1:07:55Can you spot expertise without the costume?
  25. 1:08:38Dr. John Petrocelli joins
  26. 1:10:19Petro's recomp progress
  27. 1:14:36The costume effect
  28. 1:16:43The mugshot clothing study
  29. 1:19:38Thinking it through: the calibration effect
  30. 1:21:23Listening vs trust
  31. 1:23:27First impressions stick
  32. 1:26:27One-pillar ponies
  33. 1:28:23Vintage
  34. 1:29:05Jon, Before You Go: chain and bag
  35. 1:32:04Who deserves your thank you?
  36. 1:34:02Protein price shock
  37. 1:35:47Brazil grave-collapse report
  38. 1:36:59Goals men over 40 should ditch
  39. 1:38:42Did You Know: the Pringles can inventor
  40. 1:41:58Words of Wisdom: Joe De Sena's kettlebell
  41. 1:45:18Morning Focus: you don't have to empty the tank
  42. 1:50:46Lifehacker: Galaxy unit converter
  43. 1:51:23Conversation Starters: credit and costumes
  44. 1:53:57Wrap-up and sign-off
Why Smart Men Fall For Bullsh*t (And How To Stop)
  1. 0:00Intro: The "Expert" Trap & Why Smart Men Fake It
  2. 4:15Lying vs. Bullshitting: What’s the actual difference?
  3. 11:30The Avoidance Tactic: Why being "busy" is a form of self-BS
  4. 18:45Intimacy Killers: How the "Social Desirability Bias" ruins relationships
  5. 26:10The Illusion of Optimization: Spotting fitness & nutrition myths
  6. 34:20The Perfect Dad Facade: Why pretending to be flawless hurts your kids
  7. 42:50Post-Mortem Stories: Divorce, failure, and the path to self-forgiveness
  8. 51:15Sincerity as a Superpower: Building real community and leadership
  9. 1:01:30Final Thoughts: Calling out your own BS
LIVE | Why Do Credentials Make Bad Ideas Sound Smarter?
  1. 0:00:00Cold Open: Credentials Make Ideas Sound Smarter
  2. 0:04:08Good Morning, Nation: Show Open
  3. 0:10:30Morning Loop
  4. 0:10:49Pick a Side: Driveway Mechanic vs Garage
  5. 0:14:17LeBron's 95-Mile Helicopter Commute
  6. 0:15:20Jon Joins: Presence vs Performance
  7. 0:34:27Desk: Protein Targets & Quality
  8. 0:35:29Committed
  9. 0:48:35Noah's Ark Discovery Claim
  10. 1:03:34Lifestyle Tip with Jon
  11. 1:05:45Hour Two Reset
  12. 1:17:06Did You Know: Illusory Truth Effect
  13. 1:35:10Jon Before You Go
  14. 1:36:53Keith & Petro Hang
  15. 1:52:38Morning Focus: Curiosity Is Strength
  16. 2:00:24Wrap & Sign-Off
Why Smart Men Fall for Ponzi Schemes & Bad Investments | Dr. John Petrocelli on Detecting BS
  1. 00:00Intro – Why smart men get fooled
  2. 03:00The Madoff Effect: CEOs & VPs as prime targets
  3. 08:00The Ego Blind Spot in high-status men
  4. 15:00The Sleeper Effect & repeated bad pitches
  5. 22:00BS Detection Toolkit with Dr. Petrocelli
  6. 35:00Holding financial gurus accountable
"Motivation Is for Amateurs" — Jon Andersen's Rule for Iron Discipline
  1. 00:00The Bermuda Glitch & AI Confusion
  2. 04:40The Gmail Breach & $1.9M OnlyFans CEO
  3. 13:30Keith's Vulnerable Moment (Son Leaving)
  4. 24:00Hot Wifeing vs. Hot WiFi (The Debate)
  5. 34:00North Korea & The Dictator Summit
  6. 56:00"21 Longevity Techniques" (The Jerking Off Segment)
  7. 01:06:00Discipline vs. Motivation: The Deep Dive
  8. 01:18:00iMessage Hacks You Need
  9. 01:54:00John Petrocelli: The "Bullshit Professor" on Fatherhood
Stop Overthinking & Death Row Psychology w/ Jon Andersen | Mornings in the Lab
  1. 0:00The Grok Intro & AI Chaos
  2. 8:50Jon Andersen: Helicopter Travel vs. Driving
  3. 16:00Marty Drops In (Authenticity in Media)
  4. 26:30The Bidet vs. Toilet Paper Debate
  5. 34:00Last Meal Requests on Death Row
  6. 48:40Jon's Lifestyle Tip: Just Move
  7. 51:00Origin of the Word "Dog" (Mystery)
  8. 1:27:00The Age Test: "8:45" or "Quarter to Nine"?
  9. 1:40:00Community Calls: Matt Rouff & Petrocelli
A Strongman Cried on Air & The AI Warning No One Expected
  1. 00:00The Pitcher vs. Catcher Debate
  2. 07:00Pitchers and Catchers (The Roast Continues)
  3. 19:15AI Godfather's Warning: Machines With Survival Goals
  4. 30:00The Skyscraper Skateboard Drop (50-Year-Old Skater Goes 22 Stories)
  5. 47:00Jon Anderson's Story About Dave (Must Watch)
  6. 01:04:00Why the One Goal Strategy Doesn't Fit All Men
  7. 01:16:00Neuroscience Identity Hacks: Rewire Who You Become
  8. 01:40:00Dr. Petrocelli on Detecting BS and Giving Real Feedback
Being Cheap Is Keeping You BROKE | Scarcity Mindset, Snake Oil & Office Workouts
  1. 00:00Intro & The 45,000 Egg Diet
  2. 15:30Scarcity Mindset: Why Being Cheap Keeps You Broke
  3. 22:00The Comeback: From Bankruptcy to Billionaire
  4. 26:00She Married an AI Hologram?!
  5. 34:00Guest Brian Korn: The "Happy Juice" Mental Health Debate
  6. 1:04:00Office Workouts: How to Stay Fit at Your Desk
  7. 1:16:00The "Smoke Alarm Beep" Conspiracy
  8. 1:31:00Dr. Petrocelli: The Bullsh*t Meter on Supplements
  9. 2:01:00Community Corner: Flirting, Risk & Confidence
This Ex-Military Sergeant Commands Respect Without Raising His Voice | Bjorn Hagemann
  1. 00:00The Crop Disappointment (YouTube Rant)
  2. 11:00Coke AI Ad & The Outrage Economy
  3. 15:00The "Pulling Levers" Canoe Analogy
  4. 32:00Bjorn Hagemann: The Introvert in the Military
  5. 43:00The "Moses Effect" (Uniform vs. Identity)
  6. 1:08:00Shower Thoughts: Parking in Driveways?
  7. 1:38:00Dr. Petrocelli & The "Halftime" Theory
Your Doctor Won't Say This About Peptides | Microdosing GLP-1s & Asking Better Questions
  1. 0:00The Septic Tank Incident
  2. 12:00Sea Monkeys & 90s Fads
  3. 20:45The Truth About Microdosing Peptides
  4. 37:00Ultra-Processed Food vs. Weight Loss
  5. 52:00Are AI Bots Toxic?
  6. 1:07:00The Art of Asking Better Questions
  7. 1:23:003 Words to Delete (Can't, Should, Try)
  8. 1:56:00The Bullshit Professor Returns
Why Successful Men Still Feel Invisible | The Psychology of "I See You"
  1. 0:00The Lemon Juice Robber
  2. 12:00Jon's Injury & "Trial by Error"
  3. 27:00The Coldplay Incident & Shame
  4. 40:00Center Stage: The Science of Bullshit
  5. 55:00The Dunning-Kruger Effect Explained
  6. 1:06:00Deep Dive: The "I See You" Protocol
  7. 1:39:00Morning Focus: The Safety Net is Gone
  8. 1:51:00CIA Food & Ultra-Processed Lies
Why "Alpha" Men Who Don't Listen Are LOSING Status | Prostate Health, 80s Nostalgia & Coaching BS
  1. 00:00The Morning Wake Up
  2. 04:30The "Midnight Trickle" (Prostate Health & Men's Wellness)
  3. 16:00The "Underwear" Political Divide
  4. 36:00Almonds vs. Walnuts (Simplicity Wins)
  5. 46:00Alana Tart: Listening is Status Allocation
  6. 54:00The "Phone Face" Problem
  7. 1:08:0080s Nostalgia: Party Lines & Blockbuster
  8. 1:39:00Dr. Petrocelli: The BS Detector (Evidence vs. Explanation)
  9. 2:04:00The Community Corner
Ex-Addict Neuroscientist: How To Reset Your Dopamine & Destroy Brain Fog | George Haymaker
  1. 00:00The Cold Open & Dad Stories
  2. 06:30The News: NBA Mafia Scandal & Rigged Games
  3. 13:00Detective Marty & The "Soar" AI Tech
  4. 20:00How the Mafia Rigged NBA Prop Bets
  5. 30:00The Louvre Heist: Hiding in Plain Sight
  6. 34:30CENTER STAGE: George Haymaker (Brain Performance)
  7. 38:00George's Battle with Addiction & Pills
  8. 49:00Training Neurons Like Muscle Fibers
  9. 01:06:00Jon's Gratitude Protocol
  10. 01:09:00DEEP DIVE: Alcohol vs. Fat Loss (The Real Number)
  11. 01:18:003 Ways to Start a Tough Conversation
  12. 01:38:00Petrocelli's Points: The Psychology of Parody
  13. 02:05:00Community Corner & Men's Health Roundup
6 Rules To Stay Sharp as an Entrepreneur (Most Men Lose Their Edge)
  1. 00:00The Morning Loop: Black Friday Chaos
  2. 10:30Keith's "Off Day" & The Pizza Temptation
  3. 16:00Jon Andersen: "Don't Reward a Win with a Loss"
  4. 21:00The Tragic End of a Fitness Blogger
  5. 30:00The "Nut Maxing" Trend (Reaction)
  6. 40:00Is Holiday Stress Killing Marriages?
  7. 48:00The Ozempic Debate: Is Discipline Dead?
  8. 01:11:00Petrocelli: Return on Experience vs. ROI
  9. 01:43:00Keith's Rant: 6 Ways to Keep Your Edge Sharp
The Brain Hack That Kills Anxiety Instantly | Build a Community in 2025
  1. 00:00The "Summer of the Long Ball" & Technical Meltdowns
  2. 08:30The Spigot Method: How to Stop Anxiety Instantly
  3. 18:15Tarantula Migration: Why They're Moving Across 8 States
  4. 29:00Guest: John Petrocelli (The Bullshit Guy) on Community Building
  5. 43:00Lifestyle Hack: Turning Off the Anxiety Switch
  6. 57:00The White Bear Theory: Controlling Intrusive Thoughts
  7. 01:06:00The Secret Full Body Workout (Treading Water)
  8. 01:26:00AI Girlfriends: Are We Replacing Human Connection?
  9. 01:47:00Community Corner & Social Media Trends 2025
The 90-Day Identity Shift That Will Make You Richer
  1. 00:00The Morning Loop & The Spiral
  2. 06:30The "Hollow-een" Pronunciation War
  3. 13:00Jon's Sleep Recovery & Bodybuilding Stress
  4. 31:40Why You Need to Start Squatting (Age 40+)
  5. 42:30The Denim Scandal: 8 Years Without Washing
  6. 57:30Lifestyle Tip: Determining Your Identity
  7. 01:07:00The 90-Day Identity Shift (Feat. Matt Rouff)
  8. 01:35:00The "No Spend Morning" Challenge
  9. 01:51:00Dr. Petrocelli: Bullshit Detection & Goals
LIVE | You Don’t Need More Discipline. You Need Fewer Decisions
  1. 0:00:00Countdown to LIVE
  2. 0:02:22Cold Open: Getting Dressed Shouldn't Need a Strategy Session
  3. 0:02:36Good Morning, Nation: Thursday in the Lab
  4. 0:06:22Previously On: Yesterday's Show in 30 Seconds
  5. 0:07:55Trending: Yankees Swept, 17 Years and Nobody Fired
  6. 0:09:36Pick a Side: Did Music Matter More on MTV?
  7. 0:12:36Sea-Monkeys and the 45-Degree Turbulence Study
  8. 0:16:01Jon Joins the Show
  9. 0:20:31Decision Fatigue: Prepare Tomorrow, Today
  10. 0:22:22Your 50s Body Is a Full-Time Job
  11. 0:24:12Stop Eating Loophole Food
  12. 0:30:30Wife Gaining Weight on the Same Food? Menopause and Muscle
  13. 0:32:05Quitting GLP-1s Without an Exit Plan
  14. 0:33:20Center Stage: Dr. Bennet Omalu, the Autopsy That Changed Football
  15. 0:35:23Welcome, Dr. Bennet Omalu
  16. 0:36:22Born a Refugee: How Depression Led Him to Mike Webster
  17. 0:39:12Giving the Disease a Name
  18. 0:40:12Not Against Football: Protect the Children
  19. 0:42:34The Helmet Doesn't Protect Your Brain
  20. 0:43:38Jon's Question: Football, Rugby and Head Trauma
  21. 0:47:30How to Live Well After Brain Trauma
  22. 0:49:36Sitting in Silence, Prayer and Mental Hygiene
  23. 0:54:17Jon's Wife: The Elixir That Does Magic
  24. 0:56:34Has CTE Been Over-Hyped?
  25. 0:59:13Not Every Ex-Athlete Has CTE
  26. 1:00:11Misdiagnosed: When It Wasn't CTE at All
  27. 1:03:04How He Named CTE: The Branding Story
  28. 1:07:30Chris Nowinski and the CTE Narrative
  29. 1:11:05Will Smith Plays Bennet in Concussion
  30. 1:13:25Why Will Smith Deserves the Credit
  31. 1:15:05What Will Smith Got Right, and the Laugh He Left Out
  32. 1:16:45The 67-Year-Old Doing Donuts on the Courthouse Lawn
  33. 1:17:37What Do His Critics Still Get Wrong?
  34. 1:18:07Sony's Fame Psychologist: It's Not About You
  35. 1:20:56Bennet Meets Dr. Petrocelli, and Where to Find Him
  36. 1:23:17Jon's Takeaway: Confirmation From the Expert
  37. 1:26:36Debrief: It's Not All CTE, It's Weather
  38. 1:28:56Karl Bushby's 28-Year Walk Home
  39. 1:30:50The Plastic Bag Trend Doctors Warn Against
  40. 1:32:09Vintage: The King Julien Halloween Costume
  41. 1:34:09Morning Focus: A Bad Morning Doesn't Get the Whole Day
  42. 1:35:43Keith: A Bad Night's Sleep Isn't a Bad Day
  43. 1:41:55Deep Dive: You Don't Need More Discipline
  44. 1:44:23Life Hacker: The Key Fob Chin Trick
  45. 1:45:45Before You Go: What Deserves a Fresh Decision?
  46. 1:47:02Up Next: Holley Muraco and Pixar's Hoppers

Their story

Dr. John V. Petrocelli is a distinguished Professor of Psychology at Wake Forest University, where he has taught since 2007, rising through the ranks from Assistant to Associate and now full Professor. Known colloquially as the 'Professor of Bullshit,' he directs the Bullshit Studies Lab, pioneering research into bullshitting—a unique form of communication indifferent to truth or evidence, distinct from lying. His seminal book, *The Life-Changing Science of Detecting Bullshit* (2021), distills decades of empirical work into practical strategies for identifying and disposing of pervasive BS in daily life, business, and media. Petrocelli's scholarship spans experimental social cognition, judgment and decision making, with over 50 publications in elite journals like the *Journal of Personality and Social Psychology* and *Journal of Experimental Social Psychology*. He serves as Associate Editor for both *JPSP: Attitudes and Social Cognition* and *Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin*, shaping the field's discourse. Research foci include attitude strength and persuasion—exploring how certainty, ambivalence, and accessibility fortify or weaken beliefs against change; counterfactual thinking, where mental 'what if' simulations impact learning, memory, decisions, and even physician diagnostics; and metacognition, thoughts about thoughts that underpin effective BS detection. Petrocelli earned his Ph.D. in social psychology from Indiana University Bloomington (2007) after a B.A. from Westminster College. A TEDx speaker and keynote expert on evidence-based leadership, he consults on no-BS decision-making, contributes to *Psychology Today*, and advises tech firm Seekr. Courses like 'Misinformation, BSing, and Calling BS' equip students to navigate a post-truth world. In an era of fake news and buzzword salads, Petrocelli's work equips individuals and organizations to sharpen rusty BS detectors, fostering clearer communication, smarter choices, and critically discerning cultures. [Wake Forest Psychology](https://psychology.wfu.edu/john-petrocelli/), [LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/in/johnvpetrocelli), [Book Insights](https://nextbigideaclub.com/magazine/life-changing-science-detecting-bullshit-bookbite/29360/).

In their own words

BS Definition

Bullshitting is communication with little to no concern for evidence and/or established knowledge.

Distinguishes BS from lies, where liars care about truth but deceive; impacts receptivity in sales, politics, media.

Detection Cues

Cues like buzzword salads ('Hidden meaning transforms unparalleled abstract beauty') signal BS.

Trains detection skills vital for better decisions in business and personal life.

Counterfactual Thinking

Counterfactual potency influences affect, judgments, and decisions.

Mental simulations of alternatives affect real-world choices, from relationships to medicine.

Attitude Strength

Attitude certainty resists persuasion via metacognitive stability perceptions.

Explains enduring beliefs and change resistance, informing marketing and policy.

Appearances & videos

Why Bullshitters Are More Dangerous Than Liars | Dr. Petrocelli

Why Bullshitters Are More Dangerous Than Liars | Dr. Petrocelli

LIVE | Is Wellness Marketing Selling Hope as Science?

LIVE | Is Wellness Marketing Selling Hope as Science?

LIVE | Told You Have High Blood Pressure? You May Feel Worse

LIVE | Told You Have High Blood Pressure? You May Feel Worse

The Sedation Trap: Why Men Are Quietly Checking Out | MITL #2199

The Sedation Trap: Why Men Are Quietly Checking Out | MITL #2199

Dream Expert: What Your Dreams Really Mean & The Cockroach Rule for Toxic People

Dream Expert: What Your Dreams Really Mean & The Cockroach Rule for Toxic People

Your Brain Is Lying To You: EJ Snyder & Dr. Petrocelli Expose the BS Holding You Back

Your Brain Is Lying To You: EJ Snyder & Dr. Petrocelli Expose the BS Holding You Back

Stop Setting Goals Like This (The Avoidance Trap Keeping Men Broke & Unhealthy)

Stop Setting Goals Like This (The Avoidance Trap Keeping Men Broke & Unhealthy)

LIVE | When AI Sounds Certain, Why Do We Believe It?

LIVE | When AI Sounds Certain, Why Do We Believe It?

The Georgetown Study Was WRONG: Why Your Habits Fail & What Leaders Do Differently

The Georgetown Study Was WRONG: Why Your Habits Fail & What Leaders Do Differently

Why Smart Men Believe Things That Aren't True | Dr. John Petrocelli on the Science of Bullshit

Why Smart Men Believe Things That Aren't True | Dr. John Petrocelli on the Science of Bullshit

LIVE | Expensive Clothes Make Men Look Competent. Here's Why

LIVE | Expensive Clothes Make Men Look Competent. Here's Why

Why Smart Men Fall For Bullsh*t (And How To Stop)

Why Smart Men Fall For Bullsh*t (And How To Stop)

LIVE | Why Do Credentials Make Bad Ideas Sound Smarter?

LIVE | Why Do Credentials Make Bad Ideas Sound Smarter?

Why Smart Men Fall for Ponzi Schemes & Bad Investments | Dr. John Petrocelli on Detecting BS

Why Smart Men Fall for Ponzi Schemes & Bad Investments | Dr. John Petrocelli on Detecting BS

Defeat Your Inner Vecna: The Hidden Mental Health Message in Stranger Things

Defeat Your Inner Vecna: The Hidden Mental Health Message in Stranger Things

"Motivation Is for Amateurs" — Jon Andersen's Rule for Iron Discipline

"Motivation Is for Amateurs" — Jon Andersen's Rule for Iron Discipline

Stop Overthinking & Death Row Psychology w/ Jon Andersen | Mornings in the Lab

Stop Overthinking & Death Row Psychology w/ Jon Andersen | Mornings in the Lab

A Strongman Cried on Air & The AI Warning No One Expected

A Strongman Cried on Air & The AI Warning No One Expected

AI Is Replacing You and You Don't Even Know It | Deep Dive #3013

AI Is Replacing You and You Don't Even Know It | Deep Dive #3013

Being Cheap Is Keeping You BROKE | Scarcity Mindset, Snake Oil & Office Workouts

Being Cheap Is Keeping You BROKE | Scarcity Mindset, Snake Oil & Office Workouts

This Ex-Military Sergeant Commands Respect Without Raising His Voice | Bjorn Hagemann

This Ex-Military Sergeant Commands Respect Without Raising His Voice | Bjorn Hagemann

Your Doctor Won't Say This About Peptides | Microdosing GLP-1s & Asking Better Questions

Your Doctor Won't Say This About Peptides | Microdosing GLP-1s & Asking Better Questions

Why Successful Men Still Feel Invisible | The Psychology of "I See You"

Why Successful Men Still Feel Invisible | The Psychology of "I See You"

Why "Alpha" Men Who Don't Listen Are LOSING Status | Prostate Health, 80s Nostalgia & Coaching BS

Why "Alpha" Men Who Don't Listen Are LOSING Status | Prostate Health, 80s Nostalgia & Coaching BS

Ex-Addict Neuroscientist: How To Reset Your Dopamine & Destroy Brain Fog | George Haymaker

Ex-Addict Neuroscientist: How To Reset Your Dopamine & Destroy Brain Fog | George Haymaker

6 Rules To Stay Sharp as an Entrepreneur (Most Men Lose Their Edge)

6 Rules To Stay Sharp as an Entrepreneur (Most Men Lose Their Edge)

The Brain Hack That Kills Anxiety Instantly | Build a Community in 2025

The Brain Hack That Kills Anxiety Instantly | Build a Community in 2025

The 90-Day Identity Shift That Will Make You Richer

The 90-Day Identity Shift That Will Make You Richer

LIVE | You Don’t Need More Discipline. You Need Fewer Decisions

LIVE | You Don’t Need More Discipline. You Need Fewer Decisions

  • Mornings in the Lab · Center StageJuly 24, 2025Watch →

From the interview

Your BS detector is rusty. It’s time to sharpen it.
Bullshitting is a pervasive social behavior involving communication with little to no concern for evidence.
BS is more dangerous than a lie because it doesn't pretend to care about the truth.

The guest conversation

[00:15:52] Keith: Alright. Alright. Alright. There he is. Dr. Jon Petra, professor of psychology at Wake Forest, internationally recognized for his research into communication, persuasion, and yes bullshit. [00:16:05] Keith: As the director of the Bullshit Studies Lab, that's actually on the actual door, apparently Jon investigates why we fall for misleading claims and how to, he's gonna be busy in the world of ai bullshit and how to outsmart them with evidence-based thinking. The guy's published over 50 scientific papers, an associate editor of two top journals, and his book, Jonny Marty, A Life-Changing Science of Detecting Bullshit. [00:16:29] Keith: Fun fact. Jon's core syllabus is probably the only one that makes mums blush. Let's welcome him to the stage, doctor Jon Petro Sally, what's going on, Jon? What's up brother? Hey, thanks. Going on for having me guys. How are you pal? Ar…

Read the full transcript →
Guest gallery
Pre-show shareable graphic generated by the Authority Page Builder.
Announcement card · Pre-show shareable graphic generated by the Authority Page Builder.
BS Definition
BS Definition
Detection Cues
Detection Cues
Counterfactual Thinking
Counterfactual Thinking
Attitude Strength
Attitude Strength
Original headshot ↗

Appeared in